From [email protected] Mon Feb 14 19:54:21 1994
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected]
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,soc.culture.jewish,soc.history
Subject: RFD: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust moderated
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 12 Feb 1994 00:31:40 -0500
Organization: University of North Carolina Extended Bulletin Board Service
Lines: 50
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: 
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:4601 news.groups:95207 soc.culture.jewish:88024 soc.history:33579

This is a RFD in accordance with Usenet guidelines.  I am proposing that
we add the following moderated newsgroup.  We will be voting on this issue
alone.

RFD
________________________________________________________________
Name: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust
Status: moderated
Charter:

I propose to create a storagehouse for testimonies and materials on the
Holocaust in Germany and Poland that will be called
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.  While the newsgroup is entitled
"holocaust," it will involve materials only from the situation known in
Hebrew as the Shoah -- the systematic genocide of 9 million individuals,
including 6 million Jews.  This newgroup will include Holocaust materials
>from both personal testimonies of survivors and their families and "hard"
facts from historians and observers.

This newsgroup will be moderated to prevent any anti-Semitic or
race-baiting comments from Neo-Nazis or self-proclaimed "academic"
Holocaust deniers or revisionists.  This will not be a forum for
discussing whether or not the Shoah happened; instead, it will be a place
for intelligent and factual discussion of those events.  For those Usenet
readers who wish to debate the existence of the Holocaust, they are
encouraged to read the groups alt.revisionists and soc.history, along with
the group alt.skinheads.

The guidelines for moderation are as follows:  materials which are not
accurate factually or are seen as being anti-Semitic or revisionist will
not be allowd on the group.  All other posts will be accepted.  As of now,
the moderators for the group include Bob Michael of Dartmouth, Rick
Horowitz of the California State University at Fresno, and Daniel Aldrich
of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

While there are several groups in existence that cover similar subject
matter, such as the group on the nysernet and several mailing lists and
anonymous ftp sites, I believe that only a newsnet Internet group will
provide access to the millions of users around the world.

Further, in this era when one out of four high schoolers do not know what
the Holocaust is, and when revisionists like the Institute for Historical
Review and people like David Cole and Mr. Gannon deny the existence of the
Holocaust, I feel it is urgent that we create a newgroup on the Shoah.

Ron Dippold will act as the third party vote taker when the CFV goes out;
that will hopefully be in early March.  This RFD will last for one month.

Please followup to news.groups.
Thank you.

From [email protected] Wed Mar  9 23:38:48 1994
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Rick Horowitz)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,soc.culture.jewish,soc.history
Subject: 2nd RFD: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust moderated
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 9 Mar 1994 17:56:46 -0500
Organization: California State University, Fresno
Lines: 52
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: 
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:4717 news.groups:97615 soc.culture.jewish:92471 soc.history:34987

This is a second posting of the RFD for soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.

This is a RFD in accordance with Usenet guidelines.  I am proposing that
we add the following moderated newsgroup.  We will be voting on this issue
alone.

RFD
________________________________________________________________
Name: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust
Status: moderated
Charter:

I propose to create a storagehouse for testimonies and materials on the
Holocaust in Germany and Poland that will be called
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.  While the newsgroup is entitled
"holocaust," it will involve materials only from the situation known in
Hebrew as the Shoah -- the systematic genocide of 9 million individuals,
including 6 million Jews.  This newgroup will include Holocaust materials
>from both personal testimonies of survivors and their families and "hard"
facts from historians and observers.

This newsgroup will be moderated to prevent any anti-Semitic or
race-baiting comments from Neo-Nazis or self-proclaimed "academic"
Holocaust deniers or revisionists.  This will not be a forum for
discussing whether or not the Shoah happened; instead, it will be a place
for intelligent and factual discussion of those events.  For those Usenet
readers who wish to debate the existence of the Holocaust, they are
encouraged to read the groups alt.revisionism and soc.history, along with
the group alt.skinheads.

The guidelines for moderation are as follows:  materials which are not
accurate factually or are seen as being anti-Semitic or revisionist will
not be allowed on the group.  All other posts will be accepted.  As of now,
the moderators for the group include Bob Michael of Dartmouth, Rick
Horowitz of the California State University at Fresno, and Daniel Aldrich
of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

While there are several groups in existence that cover similar subject
matter, such as the group on the nysernet and several mailing lists and
anonymous ftp sites, I believe that only a newsnet Internet group will
provide access to the millions of users around the world.

Further, in this era when one out of four high schoolers do not know what
the Holocaust is, and when revisionists like the Institute for Historical
Review and people like David Cole and Mr. Gannon deny the existence of the
Holocaust, I feel it is urgent that we create a newsgroup on the Shoah.

Ron Dippold will act as the third party vote taker when the CFV goes out;
that will hopefully be in early March.  This RFD will last for one month.

Please followup to news.groups.
Thank you.

From [email protected] Thu Mar 24 18:10:20 1994
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Jan Isley)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,soc.culture.jewish
Subject: CFV: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust moderated
Followup-To: poster
Date: 23 Mar 1994 18:53:20 -0500
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 105
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Expires: 14 Apr 1994 00:00:00 GMT
Message-ID: 
References: 
Reply-To: [email protected] (Jan Isley)
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:4832 news.groups:98843 soc.culture.jewish:95036

                    FIRST CALL FOR VOTES (of 2)
          moderated group soc.culture.jewish.holocaust

Newsgroups line: 
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust:	A factually accurate forum on the Holocaust. (Moderated)

Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 13 April 1994.

Please read this entire post before replying.  Voting instructions
are given below.

This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party.  Please
direct all voting and procedural questions and reports of problems
to Jan Isley .  This is NOT the voting address!

Please direct all questions regarding the proposed new group to the
proponent, Daniel Aldrich .

CHARTER
-------
This newsgroup will create a storagehouse for all kinds of information
>from various sources on the Holocaust in Europe that occurred between
1942-1945 (along with the events leading up to it that happened
in the early 30's).  This newsgroup will be called
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.  While the newsgroup is entitled
"Holocaust," it will involve materials only from the situation known in
Hebrew as the Shoah -- the systematic genocide of 9 million individuals,
including 6 million Jews.  This newgroup will include Holocaust materials
>from both personal testimonies of survivors and their families and "hard"
facts from historians and observers.

This newsgroup will be moderated to prevent any anti-Semitic or
race-baiting comments from Neo-Nazis or self-proclaimed "academic"
Holocaust deniers or revisionists.  This will not be a forum for
discussing whether or not the Shoah happened; instead, it will be a place
for intelligent and factual discussion of those events.  For those Usenet
readers who wish to debate the existence of the Holocaust, they are
encouraged to read the groups alt.revisionists and soc.history, along with
the group alt.skinheads.

MODERATION
----------
The guidelines for moderation are as follows:  materials which are not
accurate factually or are seen as being anti-Semitic or revisionist will
not be allowed on the group.  All other posts will be accepted.  As of now,
the moderators for the group include Bob Michael of Dartmouth, Rick
Horowitz of the California State University at Fresno, and Daniel Aldrich
of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

If an article is considered to be factually inaccurate or purposefully
anti-Semitic (or any kind of hate speech) then a vote will be taken
among the moderators.  Two of of the three must agree that the
material is hateful in order for it to be removed.

All other material will be accepted, be it theological or factual
or personal in nature.

RATIONALE
---------
While there are several groups in existence that cover similar subject
matter, such as the group on the nysernet and several mailing lists and
anonymous ftp sites, I believe that only a newsnet Internet group will
provide access to the millions of users around the world.

Further, in this era when one out of four high schoolers do not know what
the Holocaust is, and when revisionists like the Institute for Historical
Review and people like David Cole and Mr. Gannon deny the existence of the
Holocaust, I feel it is urgent that we create a newgroup on the Shoah.

This newsgroup will help us to remember and understand the events in
Germany so that they will not happen again.
Thank you.

VOTING INSTRUCTIONS
-------------------
Your vote will be counted by a program.  Please use the template
below and follow the instructions exactly.

Send mail to [email protected] containing these three
lines in the body:

   ballot-scjh
   My name is XXXXX
   I vote _____ on soc.culture.jewish.holocaust

Replace XXXXX with your name (not your email address!).
Replace _____ with either YES, NO, or ABSTAIN.

Please use the template *exactly* and delete *all* other text from
this post.  Anything else may be rejected by the vote counting program.

You will receive a personal acknowledgment by email within a few days.
It is your responsibility to make sure your vote is registered correctly.

ONE VOTE PER PERSON, no more than one per account.  Voting from multiple
accounts may result in all of your votes being rejected... do not do it.
Addresses and votes of all voters will be published in the final voting
results list.

Do not distribute mutated voting instructions.  This can cause serious
problems for the voters who use them and for me as vote taker.  If you
are in any doubt, please contact me - I'll be very happy to advise you.
-- 
Jan Isley 
votes-to: 

From [email protected] Thu Apr  7 13:55:37 1994
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Jan Isley)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,soc.culture.jewish
Subject: 2nd CFV: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust moderated
Supersedes: 
Followup-To: poster
Date: 6 Apr 1994 17:21:32 -0400
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 144
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Expires: 14 Apr 1994 00:00:00 GMT
Message-ID: 
References:  
Reply-To: [email protected] (Jan Isley)
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:4903 news.groups:100027 soc.culture.jewish:96695

                    LAST CALL FOR VOTES (of 2)
          moderated group soc.culture.jewish.holocaust

Newsgroups line: 
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust:	A factually accurate forum on the Holocaust. (Moderated)

Votes must be received by 23:59:59 UTC, 13 April 1994.

Please read this entire post before replying.  Voting instructions
are given below.

This vote is being conducted by a neutral third party.  Please
direct all voting and procedural questions and reports of problems
to Jan Isley .  This is NOT the voting address!

Please direct all questions regarding the proposed new group to the
proponent, Daniel Aldrich .

CHARTER
-------
This newsgroup will create a storagehouse for all kinds of information
>from various sources on the Holocaust in Europe that occurred between
1942-1945 (along with the events leading up to it that happened
in the early 30's).  This newsgroup will be called
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.  While the newsgroup is entitled
"Holocaust," it will involve materials only from the situation known in
Hebrew as the Shoah -- the systematic genocide of 9 million individuals,
including 6 million Jews.  This newgroup will include Holocaust materials
>from both personal testimonies of survivors and their families and "hard"
facts from historians and observers.

This newsgroup will be moderated to prevent any anti-Semitic or
race-baiting comments from Neo-Nazis or self-proclaimed "academic"
Holocaust deniers or revisionists.  This will not be a forum for
discussing whether or not the Shoah happened; instead, it will be a place
for intelligent and factual discussion of those events.  For those Usenet
readers who wish to debate the existence of the Holocaust, they are
encouraged to read the groups alt.revisionists and soc.history, along with
the group alt.skinheads.

MODERATION
----------
The guidelines for moderation are as follows:  materials which are not
accurate factually or are seen as being anti-Semitic or revisionist will
not be allowed on the group.  All other posts will be accepted.  As of now,
the moderators for the group include Bob Michael of Dartmouth, Rick
Horowitz of the California State University at Fresno, and Daniel Aldrich
of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

If an article is considered to be factually inaccurate or purposefully
anti-Semitic (or any kind of hate speech) then a vote will be taken
among the moderators.  Two of of the three must agree that the
material is hateful in order for it to be removed.

All other material will be accepted, be it theological or factual
or personal in nature.

RATIONALE
---------
While there are several groups in existence that cover similar subject
matter, such as the group on the nysernet and several mailing lists and
anonymous ftp sites, I believe that only a newsnet Internet group will
provide access to the millions of users around the world.

Further, in this era when one out of four high schoolers do not know what
the Holocaust is, and when revisionists like the Institute for Historical
Review and people like David Cole and Mr. Gannon deny the existence of the
Holocaust, I feel it is urgent that we create a newgroup on the Shoah.

This newsgroup will help us to remember and understand the events in
Germany so that they will not happen again.
Thank you.

VOTING INSTRUCTIONS
-------------------
Your vote will be counted by a program.  Please use the template
below and follow the instructions exactly.

Send mail to [email protected] containing these three
lines in the body:

   ballot-scjh
   My name is XXXXX
   I vote _____ on soc.culture.jewish.holocaust

Replace XXXXX with your name (not your email address!).
Replace _____ with either YES, NO, or ABSTAIN.

Please use the template *exactly* and delete *all* other text from
this post.  Anything else may be rejected by the vote counting program.

You will receive a personal acknowledgment by email within a few days.
It is your responsibility to make sure your vote is registered correctly.

ONE VOTE PER PERSON, no more than one per account.  Voting from multiple
accounts may result in all of your votes being rejected... do not do it.
Addresses and votes of all voters will be published in the final voting
results list.

Do not distribute mutated voting instructions.  This can cause serious
problems for the voters who use them and for me as vote taker.  If you
are in any doubt, please contact me - I'll be very happy to advise you.

soc.culture.jewish.holocaust Bounce List - No need to revote
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                           Douglas Okun
[email protected]                         Karen Weltchek
[email protected]                                          ALPER ALALUF

Votes in error
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                                               B.J. Herbison
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                   Rachel Garshick
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                        Rhona
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                              
   ! No ballot, No name given
[email protected]                                          Sol Katz
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                 Marlyn Gershman
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                                           
   ! No ballot, No name given
[email protected]                                                 
   ! No name given
[email protected]                             Rachel Beth Cohen
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                       Rebekah Hasman-Judd
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                              raanan shlomi
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                         Shiri Ayalon
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                          Robert Skloot
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                           
   ! No ballot, No name given
[email protected]                                                         
   ! No ballot, No name given
-- 
Jan Isley 
votes-to: 

From [email protected] Tue Apr 19 17:51:15 1994
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Jan Isley)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,soc.culture.jewish
Subject: RESULT: soc.culture.jewish.holocaust moderated passes 430:42
Supersedes: 
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 14 Apr 1994 16:02:21 -0400
Organization: Usenet Volunteer Votetakers
Lines: 584
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
References:   
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:4947 news.groups:100742 soc.culture.jewish:97915

        moderated group soc.culture.jewish.holocaust passes 430:42

There were 430 YES votes and 42 NO votes, for a total of 472 valid votes. 
There were 2 abstains and 10 invalid ballots.

For group passage, YES votes must be at least 2/3 of all valid (YES and
NO) votes.   There also must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes.

There is a five day discussion period after these results are posted.  If
no serious allegations of voting irregularities are raised, the moderator
of news.announce.newgroups will create the group shortly thereafter.

This vote was conducted by a neutral third party.  Please direct all voting
questions and reports of problems to Jan Isley .

Newsgroups line: 
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust:	A factually accurate forum on the Holocaust. (Moderated)

CHARTER
-------
This newsgroup will create a storagehouse for all kinds of information
>from various sources on the Holocaust in Europe that occurred between
1942-1945 (along with the events leading up to it that happened
in the early 30's).  This newsgroup will be called
soc.culture.jewish.holocaust.  While the newsgroup is entitled
"Holocaust," it will involve materials only from the situation known in
Hebrew as the Shoah -- the systematic genocide of 9 million individuals,
including 6 million Jews.  This newgroup will include Holocaust materials
>from both personal testimonies of survivors and their families and "hard"
facts from historians and observers.

This newsgroup will be moderated to prevent any anti-Semitic or
race-baiting comments from Neo-Nazis or self-proclaimed "academic"
Holocaust deniers or revisionists.  This will not be a forum for
discussing whether or not the Shoah happened; instead, it will be a place
for intelligent and factual discussion of those events.  For those Usenet
readers who wish to debate the existence of the Holocaust, they are
encouraged to read the groups alt.revisionists and soc.history, along with
the group alt.skinheads.

MODERATION
----------
The guidelines for moderation are as follows:  materials which are not
accurate factually or are seen as being anti-Semitic or revisionist will
not be allowed on the group.  All other posts will be accepted.  As of now,
the moderators for the group include Bob Michael of Dartmouth, Rick
Horowitz of the California State University at Fresno, and Daniel Aldrich
of the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill.

If an article is considered to be factually inaccurate or purposefully
anti-Semitic (or any kind of hate speech) then a vote will be taken
among the moderators.  Two of of the three must agree that the
material is hateful in order for it to be removed.

All other material will be accepted, be it theological or factual
or personal in nature.

RATIONALE
---------
While there are several groups in existence that cover similar subject
matter, such as the group on the nysernet and several mailing lists and
anonymous ftp sites, I believe that only a newsnet Internet group will
provide access to the millions of users around the world.

Further, in this era when one out of four high schoolers do not know what
the Holocaust is, and when revisionists like the Institute for Historical
Review and people like David Cole and Mr. Gannon deny the existence of the
Holocaust, I feel it is urgent that we create a newgroup on the Shoah.

This newsgroup will help us to remember and understand the events in
Germany so that they will not happen again.
Thank you.

soc.culture.jewish.holocaust Final Vote Ack

Voted Yes
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                                    Daniel B. Goodman
[email protected]                                            Jay Levin
[email protected]                                     Jaimie Miller
[email protected]                                  Jason P. Lorber
[email protected]                                         Marc Spier
[email protected]                                             Pam Fox
[email protected]                                  Steven Aldrich
[email protected]                                           Anthony Burokas
[email protected]                                 Michael J. Wilson
[email protected]                                                        Aahz
[email protected]                                              Alberto Pinkas
[email protected]                                       Mindy Chanoff
[email protected]                                         Chaim Jacobs
[email protected]                                   Adriana Arcia
[email protected]                                       Alan Dobkin
[email protected]                                   Douglas Limburg
[email protected]                                             Andrew Fabbro
[email protected]                                           Al Filreis
[email protected]                                                Andrew Cytron
[email protected]                                        Aimee EIsenberg
[email protected]                                            Anita Michel
[email protected]                           Adam J. Schechner
[email protected]                                       Randall Schroeder
[email protected]                                     Allen Shifrin
[email protected]                                              Alon Risdon
[email protected]                                   Amos Wittenberg
[email protected]                                        Jess Anderson
[email protected]                                              Andy Latto
[email protected]                                       Andrew R. Shulman
[email protected]                                    Andrzej A. Borowiec
[email protected]                                          Alan Pfeffer
[email protected]                                            Amitha P. Reddy
[email protected]                                       Shevy Adler
[email protected]                                     Tzippora Eyal
[email protected]                                       Jim Arnow
[email protected]                                          Alex Rogers
[email protected]                                     Allison Kamen
[email protected]                                                 Jim Ault
[email protected]                                 Amelia R. Weitzman
[email protected]                                    Barry Kingsbury
[email protected]                                                Bart Miller
[email protected]                                   Brian Darer
[email protected]                                    Manuel Bekier
[email protected]                                           David Bell
[email protected]                                    Shag Aristotelis
[email protected]                                               B.J. Herbison
[email protected]                                           Bjorn Hell Larsen
[email protected]                                         Ben Marks
[email protected]                                        Brian Kupersmit
[email protected]                                       Brian Cohen
[email protected]                                   nicole weinreb
[email protected]                                                Bob McCormick
[email protected]                                               Patrick Schaaf
[email protected]                        William Brandsdorfer
[email protected]                                            Bruce Baugh
[email protected]                      Barry M. Schlesinger
[email protected]                                         Ben Gerber
[email protected]                                      Martin Bunzendahl
[email protected]                                            alan bush
[email protected]                      Christopher Campbell
[email protected]                                       Chris Antle
[email protected]                                 Mark Kupferman
[email protected]                                             T Cavanagh
[email protected]                                               Ellen Kranzser
[email protected]                                                Simon Hawkin
[email protected]                                       Chris Hass
[email protected]                                       Christopher J. Hoover
[email protected]                                           Israel Cidon
[email protected]                           Christopher Richmond
[email protected]                             Christian L Claiborn
[email protected]                                        Charles McNeil=BD
[email protected]                                     Gregory Jansen
[email protected]                                             Karl Crary
[email protected]                                          Charles Rosen
[email protected]                     Kenneth P. Crouch, Jr.
[email protected]                                     ILAN GRAIFER
[email protected]                                          David Sheen
[email protected]                                        Tammy Nusbaum
[email protected]                                               Michal
[email protected]                                        Barry Fischer
[email protected]                                   Christopher Stone
[email protected]                                          Craig Tovey
CUNYVM.CUNY.EDU!BKLYN.bitnet!ZZYHA                          Maya Balakirsky
[email protected]                                       Craig Verver
[email protected]                                           Daniel Epstein
[email protected]                              David J. Greenberger
[email protected]                           Douglas Okun
[email protected]                         Karen Weltchek
[email protected]                                                 Dale Smoak
[email protected]                                Simon Damberger
[email protected]                                      Dennis L. Anderson
[email protected]                                               George Amoss
[email protected]                                         David Lewin
[email protected]                                              Bill Davidsen
[email protected]                                          Daniel Bernstein
[email protected]                                            Sandy Barnes
[email protected]                                          David Cox
[email protected]                                      David Dickerson
[email protected]                                     Ken Robinson
[email protected]                                          David F. Skoll
[email protected]                                         Paul Diamond
[email protected]                                           Daniel Keren
[email protected]                                            Daniel Gamulka
[email protected]                                          Darcie and
[email protected]                                  Rebecca Drayer
[email protected]                               Daniel R. Reitman
[email protected]                                                 David Rising
[email protected]                               Daniel E. Rogers
[email protected]                                           David Wright
[email protected]                                       Bertil Askelid
[email protected]                                            Edward Suranyi
[email protected]                                                    Eric Blum
[email protected]                                          Ellen Tauber
[email protected]                                          Robert Smits
ersys.edmonton.ab.ca!Gallif!Yadallee                  Dave Shariff Yadallee
[email protected]                                   Emilie Bruchon
[email protected]                                     Ethan M. Gelman
[email protected]                                  Eva Ungar Grudin
[email protected]                             Evelyn C. Leeper
[email protected]                               johan de tavernier
[email protected]                                               Daniel Faigin
[email protected]                         Richard Hulkenberg II
[email protected]                                          ALPER ALALUF
[email protected]                                        Stuart Feldhamer
[email protected]                               Howard Feldmesser
[email protected]!SNYFARVA.bitnet                     Charles Fishman
[email protected]                                       Frank Lam
[email protected]                                   Reva Freedman
[email protected]                                           Gabe Helou
[email protected]                                 Michal Koren-Ganor
[email protected]                                   Rachel Garshick
[email protected]                                 Gary Eisenberg
[email protected]                                                  Gerben Vos
[email protected]                                     Greg Guffey
[email protected]                                      Gregory G. Woodbury
[email protected]                                            Gary Sitzmann
[email protected]                                                Gil Neiger
[email protected]                                     Glenn Forbes Larratt
[email protected]                                        Tamara Felden
[email protected]                                          Jack Goldberg
[email protected]                                Leo Goldberger
[email protected]                                                Avi Golden
[email protected]                                  Mark Goldman
[email protected]                                    Graham Forst
[email protected]                              David Iain Russell Greig
[email protected]                                    Greg Weiss
[email protected]                                    Robert Weinmann
[email protected]                                     Gil grodzinsky
[email protected]                                   Brennan T. Price
[email protected]                                     Jacob P. Kovel
[email protected]                                       Adira Netzel
[email protected]                                    Matthew Kressel
[email protected]                                      Meira P. Katz
[email protected]                                            Gur Hoshen
[email protected]                                     Gabriel Zitrin
[email protected]                                 Yossi Halberstadt
[email protected]                                Stefanie Hausman
[email protected]                                          Chip Dunham
[email protected]                                    Penny Aldrich
[email protected]                                 Stephan Heilmayr
[email protected]                                        Steven Zdatny
[email protected]                                         Herman Rubin
[email protected]                                        Matt Hucke
[email protected]                                              Mark James
[email protected]                                               Jamie Andrews
[email protected]                                Jason Fliegel
[email protected]                                             Jason Schwartz
[email protected]                                     Jay Sitkin
[email protected]                                          Jeremy C. Roberts
[email protected]                                             J.D. Cain
[email protected]                                        jessica ross
[email protected]                                  Jeff Russakow
[email protected]                                 Jen McGillan
[email protected]                                        Jenny Helbraun
[email protected]                                         Jeremy Levine
[email protected]                                Randell Jesup
[email protected]                                     Jennifer Exelbierd
[email protected]                                    Julian Fogel
[email protected]                                      Jonathan H.H. Bloedow
[email protected]                                      Jonathan Herzog
[email protected]                                    Jeff Bloom
[email protected]                                  Jill Steinberg
[email protected]                                                 Jim Cerny
[email protected]                                           Jim J. Jewett
[email protected]                                      Daniel Brownstone
[email protected]                                  Jeremy Leonard Hardison
[email protected]                                          Jonathan Mark
[email protected]                                       Janet Menaker
[email protected]                                              Jason Matyas
[email protected]                               Jonathan Morse
[email protected]                                             Maddy Demsky
[email protected]                                                    Josh Granof
[email protected]                      Joseph R. Partridge
[email protected]                                                    Jim Atkinson
[email protected]                                    Jeremy R. Jacobs
[email protected]                                Jennifer Rothstein
[email protected]                                             John Rogers
[email protected]                                     Julie Roskies
[email protected]                                                Jeff Schultz
[email protected]                                             John Locke
[email protected]                                      Jamie McCarthy
[email protected]                                              Dafna Kalish
[email protected]                         Joseph V. Kaszynski
[email protected]                                             Morry Katz
[email protected]                                          Sol Katz
[email protected]                                   Kelsey Libner
[email protected]                                 Ken Sallenger
[email protected]                                           Kenneth Brody
[email protected]                                       Ken Russell
[email protected]                                     Jitendra Khare
[email protected]                                Jolanta Kisler-Goldstein
[email protected]                                         Ken McVay
[email protected]                                      Andrew Koren
[email protected]                                  David Kreindler
[email protected]                                   Kathryn Schoenbrun
[email protected]                                     Martin Schr"oder
[email protected]                                  Christopher Clark
[email protected]                                             Joshua Manning
[email protected]                           Leonard Grossman
[email protected]                                                 Joel B. Levin
[email protected]                              Liza Stavchansky
[email protected]                                             Leon Dworsky
[email protected]                                     Lynne Joyrich
[email protected]                                          Leah M. Hollister
[email protected]                                Erin Locklear
[email protected]                         Lorraine Whitmore
[email protected]                                          Louis Sokol
[email protected]                                     Lisa Robbins
[email protected]                                              Linda Saegert
[email protected]                                    Michael Adams
[email protected]                                     Lisa Malik
[email protected]                              Reed Maltzman
[email protected]                                    Mark Opper
[email protected]                                           Marc Dashevsky
[email protected]                                                  Max Heffler
[email protected]                                             Micha Berger
[email protected]                              Michael Fredericks
[email protected]                                     Michael Chorost
[email protected]                              Mark Cunningham
[email protected]                                      Matthew E. Merkelson
[email protected]                                             M. Rappoport
[email protected]                                             Clark Merrill
[email protected]                                    Luke Meyer
[email protected]                                   Martin F. Melhus
[email protected]                                 Marlyn Gershman
[email protected]                            Michael K. Hauser
[email protected]                                        Martin Eiger
[email protected]                                        Mike Fessler
[email protected]                              Margaret Mikulska
[email protected]                                            milton botwinick
[email protected]                                        Mitchell Weiss
[email protected]                                               Marc Zemel
[email protected]                                         Michael Kovacs
[email protected]                                              MICAH LISSY
[email protected]                                         Mark Leighton
[email protected]                                      Matthew A. Lynch
[email protected]                                           Marc Meltzer
[email protected]                               Michael L. Michlin
[email protected]                               Johanna Moorman
[email protected]                               Melissa Warden
[email protected]                                 Michael Frank
[email protected]                                   Martha Turner
[email protected]                                        Mike Swihart
[email protected]                                        Michael D. Taylor
[email protected]                                 Marissa Tiamfook
[email protected]                                          C.K. Bryant
[email protected]                                       Joachim Mugdan
[email protected]                                  Randy Finder
[email protected]                                        Neil Citron
[email protected]                                Neocles Serafimidis
netcom.com!thewoz!rswill                                   R Scott Williams
[email protected]                              Nicole J. Cunningham
[email protected]                                           niles ray
[email protected]                                     Nina Rosenhan
[email protected]                                 Ariel Nowersztern
[email protected]                                       Nancy R Blake
[email protected]                                      Gideon Goldstein
[email protected]                                          Peter Keller
[email protected]                                          Anthony Waller
[email protected]                                            Daniel Packman
[email protected]                                        Doug Parvin
[email protected]                                            Paul Cohen
[email protected]                             Priscilla Coit Murphy
[email protected]                                              Peter Copen
[email protected]                                            Bob Peterson
[email protected]                                    Perri GOODMAN
[email protected]                                             Phil Hammond
[email protected]                                   Philip A. Kaufman
[email protected]                         N. Christopher Phillips
[email protected]                                                     Peter Klungel
[email protected]                                                 Peter Lindley
[email protected]                                       Paul Lawrence Rose
[email protected]                                          Paulo Melo
[email protected]                                     Peter S. Morris
[email protected]                                        Howard M. Moss, MD 
[email protected]                                Victoria Surliuga
[email protected]                                               Peter Zavon
[email protected]                                               Paul Zola
[email protected]                                         Lewis Eisen
[email protected]                                   Michael Quinn
[email protected]                               Rachel Wellner
[email protected]                                        Michael McCarthy
[email protected]                                                      Raven
[email protected]                             rachel beth cohen
[email protected]                                  rebecca carver
[email protected]                                       Regina Igel
[email protected]                                    Nick Remmes
[email protected]                                         Regina Gorokhovsky
[email protected]                                  Ruthanna Gordon
[email protected]                                       Rebekah Hasman-Judd
[email protected]                               Rick Horowitz
[email protected]                                    Rich. Neumann
[email protected]                                             Richard Miller
[email protected]                                            Ross Labaugh
[email protected]                                          Robert MICHAEL
[email protected]                                      Jim Robertson
[email protected]                                                Robi Karp
[email protected]                                    Jean-Marc Rocher
[email protected]                             Robert H. Klein
[email protected]                                              Ronnie B. Kon
[email protected]                                    Gary Rosenzweig
[email protected]                                     Michael Rothstein
[email protected]                                       Ronald S. Goodwin
[email protected]                                           Richard Senzel
[email protected]                                            Robert Teeter
[email protected]                                    Ruben Krasnopolsky
[email protected]                        Daniel Rubin
[email protected]                                Lucia Ruedenberg
[email protected]                                      Julie A. Young
[email protected]                                            Russell Gold
rutgers!pdnis.paradyne.com!G.LEVINE                             Gary Levine
[email protected]                                    Lotte Evans
[email protected]                                       Seth Goldman
[email protected]                              raanan shlomi
[email protected]                                     Pia Saari
[email protected]                                   Sam Sommers
[email protected]                                           SaraAnne Gelser
[email protected]                                     Kevin Satisky
[email protected]                                Stephen David Beck
[email protected]                                   Martin Schafer
[email protected]                                      Sterling Chen
[email protected]                                         Schoen Books
[email protected]                                    Aaron Schuman
[email protected]                                            Scott Levine
[email protected]                                            Daniel Martinez
[email protected]                                      Seth D. Kaplan
[email protected]                                               Sheila Dresser
[email protected]                                            Scott Sigethy
[email protected]                                          Samuel Fintz
[email protected]                                  Jeffrey Shallit
[email protected]                           Sheila Goodman Brown
[email protected]                                        Jill Shepherd
[email protected]                                              Eliot Shimoff
[email protected]                                     Michael Shoshani
[email protected]                                 Aleksandras Shtromas
[email protected]                                      Simon Sharwood
[email protected]                               Stephanie JL Gertz
[email protected]                                Jennifer Rhyne
[email protected]                                              Steve J. Rose
[email protected]                            Stuart Michael Kuntz
[email protected]                                        Susan J. Leclair
[email protected]                               Sam Friedlander
[email protected]                                                Jim Maxwell
[email protected]                                       Sethh Cohen
[email protected]                                          Stanley Krieger
[email protected]                                        Steve Newman
[email protected]                             Anna D. Socrates
[email protected]                                   David Solomon
[email protected]                                   Sam Kaplan
[email protected]                                            Sanford Jacobs
[email protected]                               samantha spencer
[email protected]                                          Stacy Marcus
[email protected]                                               Dwight Brown
[email protected]                                       Filex Vagabond
[email protected]                               Johnie Cleo Stegall
[email protected]                                             Alan Stein
[email protected]                                 Steve Friedberg
[email protected]                                          Jessica Stine
[email protected]                                       Stu Labovitz
[email protected]                                        Sue-Jin McCoy
[email protected]                                        Susan King
[email protected]                         Jorge Ignacio Szewkies
[email protected]                                           Zale Tabakman
[email protected]                                       Thomas Brett Hall
[email protected]                                              Tom Rees
[email protected]                                  Tamara Reynolds
[email protected]                       Thomas Vanderbloemen
[email protected]                               Manfredo Tichauer M.
[email protected]                                           Tilney L. Marsh
[email protected]                                 Bruce Tindall
[email protected]                             Michael Tirenin
[email protected]                                      Ted Louis Glenn
[email protected]                       Towner A. Blackstock
[email protected]                                       Toby Schonfeld
[email protected]                                    Tom Rubinstein
[email protected]                                        Tim Pierce
[email protected]                                              Mary Todd
[email protected]                               Chris Lasdauskas
[email protected]                                              Irving Greisman
uga.cc.uga.edu!LSUVM.BITNET!XP2938                            John P. Jones
[email protected]                                    Shaya Goldmeier
[email protected]                               Dimitrios Nikolaidis
[email protected]                                   Richard R Urena
[email protected]                                Daniel P. Aldrich
[email protected]                                   Daniel Case
[email protected]                                Seth Lipschitz
[email protected]                                                 Ken Varnum
[email protected]                                         Jason Verch
[email protected]                                            Vincent Laplante
[email protected]                                                Les Vogel
[email protected]                                          David Wald
[email protected]                                     Crystal E. Ward
[email protected]                                    Warren Burstein
[email protected]                                              William Daroff
[email protected]                                            Lauren Webb
[email protected]                                   Christoph Weber-Fahr
[email protected]                                     Gary Weissman
[email protected]                                         Wendy L. Rosen
[email protected]                                      Bill Huber
[email protected]                            Christopher M. Conway
[email protected]                                     Rae Wyshynski
[email protected]                                         Yehuda Poch
[email protected]                                        Sean Guttmann
[email protected]                                            Yukiko Mori
[email protected]                                             Daniel Yolkut
[email protected]                              Mordecai Kornfeld
[email protected]                                           Andrew S. Zafft
[email protected]                        Cara Diane Zanoff
[email protected]                                           Jackie Ziff
[email protected]                               David E. Zinman

Voted No
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                                    Paul S. Wolf
[email protected]                         Eugenio Sanchez-Pena
[email protected]                                                Ken Ballou
[email protected]                                        Bas Braams
[email protected]                                                  Burt Holzman
[email protected]                                      Charles Morant
[email protected]                                           Cecelia A Clancy
[email protected]                                     Brian J. Catlin
[email protected]                                 Ernest Cline
[email protected]                                       Paulo da Costa
[email protected]                                         D. C. Sessions
[email protected]                                              Olivier Devuns
[email protected]                                             Dave Flewitt
dick@@smith.chi.il.us                                         Richard Smith
[email protected]                                                  Edward Bertsch
[email protected]                                          Ed Taychert
[email protected]                                   Gedaliah Friedenberg
[email protected]                               Sean P. Ryan
[email protected]                                           Peter Anvin
[email protected]                                         Juergen Christoffel
[email protected]                                    James Chokey
[email protected]                                 Julian C. Lander
[email protected]                                            Jim Cowling
[email protected]                                                John De Armond
[email protected]                                                       John
[email protected]                                     John MacWilliamson
[email protected]                                                Axl
[email protected]                                           Kari E. Hurtta
[email protected]                                           Miguel Farah
[email protected]                                                Michael Grubb
[email protected]                                              Maxime Taksar
[email protected]                                         Nigel Mitchell
[email protected]                                       Neil Broderick
[email protected]                                     Pierre Uszynski
[email protected]                          Richard T. Girards, Jr.
[email protected]                                  Michael Sanford McGuire
[email protected]                                      Steven Inglis
[email protected]                                    Marc Moorcroft
[email protected]                                               Randy Moore
[email protected]                                        Tom Jaskiewicz
[email protected]                                           Warren Lavallee
[email protected]                                           Wilhelm Bock

Abstained
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                                     Mitchell Bruntel
[email protected]                                           Greg Morrow


Votes in error
---------------------------------------------------------------------------
[email protected]                         Daniel E. Friedman
   ! No ballot
[email protected]                                               Erik
   ! No ballot
[email protected]                                             G. Shih
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                              
   ! No ballot
[email protected]                                                           
   ! No ballot
[email protected]                              ronnen ariely
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                         Shiri Ayalon
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                          Robert Skloot
   ! No vote statement in message
[email protected]                                                         
   ! No ballot
[email protected]                                     Elliott Zenick
   ! No ballot
-- 
Jan Isley 
votes-to: