• Your Trusted Usenet Provider
  • Secure, Private, Unlimited

Newsgroups Main » Newsgroups Directory » Arts and Literature » Books

Tolkien, J.R.R. ( rec.arts.books.tolkien )
 
From [email protected] Sat Feb 13 12:48:00 1993
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.fan.tolkien,rec.arts.sf.written,rec.arts.books
Path: uunet!ferkel.ucsb.edu!taco!gatech!swrinde!zaphod.mps.ohio-state.edu!rpi!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Andrew Solovay)
Subject: RFD: rec.arts.books.tolkien
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
Followup-To: news.groups
Organization: Castle Anthrax
Date: Mon, 1 Feb 1993 19:25:35 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 24
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3211 news.groups:65731 alt.fan.tolkien:2197 rec.arts.sf.written:19508 rec.arts.books:59280

I propose that a new group be created for discussion of the works of
J.R.R. Tolkien. This group, rec.arts.books.tolkien, would supersede
the existing "alt.fan.tolkien".

The group would be a forum for discussion about the works in Professor
Tolkien's "Middle-Earth" cycle (including "The Hobbit", "The Lord of
the Rings", and "The Silmarillion") and all his related writings
("Unfinished Tales", "Book of Lost Tales", "Lays of Beleriand",
"History of Middle Earth"...). It would also be open to discussion of
related and supplemental works by other authors (such as the "Atlas of
Middle-Earth").

According to estimates in news.lists, there are roughly 9900 readers
of alt.fan.tolkien worldwide. Roughly 150 articles were posted in the
week of Jan. 23-30, despite the limited number of sites which carry
alt.fan newsgroups. This volume merits a newsgroup in the regular
hierarchy. The topic is one with staying power; Professor Tolkien has
had an enthusiastic (not to say "fanatical") following for several
decades.
-- 
Andrew Solovay    

"Wait a minute! You guys are NINJAS!"
                ---The Tick

From [email protected] Tue Feb 23 23:39:42 1993
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Andrew Solovay)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.fan.tolkien,rec.arts.books,rec.arts.sf.written
Subject: CFV: rec.arts.books.tolkien
Followup-To: poster
Date: 23 Feb 1993 14:36:30 -0500
Organization: Castle Anthrax
Lines: 105
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3272 news.groups:67295 alt.fan.tolkien:2667 rec.arts.books:60880 rec.arts.sf.written:20803

This is a call for votes to create a new unmoderated group,
rec.arts.books.tolkien. (The name was determined by a straw poll.)
This post contains information about the proposed group and voting
instructions. The full charter is at the end of this post.

NEWSGROUP

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (unmoderated)

VOTING

  The voting period will begin when this CFV is posted. It will end at
  23:59:59 PST March 19, 1993. Votes must be *received* by the
  deadline. According to the USENET rules, in order for the group to
  be created, at least 2/3 of the votes cast must be "YES" votes, and
  there must be at least 100 more "YES" votes than "NO" votes.

  Votes must be sent to one of the following two addresses:

        [email protected]
	[email protected]

  You may simply "reply" to this posting. Each address can accept both
  "YES" and "NO" votes. Votes posted to any newsgroup will NOT be
  counted.

  The subject line should be an unambiguous "yes" or "no" vote (e.g.
  "I vote {YES,NO} on the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien as
  proposed"). If the subject line doesn't have such a statement, I
  will check the body of the message for the vote.

  Please include your full name, if your mailer doesn't do this for
  you.

  Conditional statements (e.g. "I would vote YES if...") will be
  considered comments, not votes. If you wish to make comments, you
  are welcome to do so; however, please make sure that your ballot
  begins with an unambiguous vote.

  No more than one vote may come from any one account; you may not
  mail votes on behalf of another person. Each person is permitted to
  vote only once, no matter how many accounts he or she might have. If
  a single person or account sends more than one vote, the vote with
  the latest "sending" time will be the official vote.

  I will attempt to acknowledge every vote via EMail (i.e. "Your NO
  vote against the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien has been
  received").  There will also be two repeats of this CFV, each of
  which will have a full list of voters (without specifying which way
  they voted).

  If you are unsure whether your vote was received, you may EMail me
  at either of the above addresses. However, I cannot divulge the vote
  tallies until the end of the voting period. I also cannot answer
  questions about the content of the group (other than by mailing a
  copy of the charter).

============================================================

CHARTER 

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (hereinafter referred to as "The Group")
  would be a forum for discussion of all the works of Professor J.R.R.
  Tolkien (hereinafter "JRRT"). It would be open to discussion of his
  "Middle-earth" works, his scholarly writings, his essays and poetry,
  and all other works of JRRT (of whatever nature). The Group would be
  open to discussion at any level; for example, discussion of his
  "Middle-Earth" works could vary from literary criticism to
  philological discussion of the book's languages, or any other topic
  bearing on the works.

  The Group would also be open for discussion of works by other
  authors which relate to JRRT's work (including, but not limited to,
  scholarly criticism of his work, supplemental and speculative
  writings about his worlds, analyses of the various languages created
  by JRRT, and (of course) the elaborate historical material published
  by Christopher Tolkien). The group would be open to discussion about
  art works which are based on Tolkien's works (e.g. graphic
  depictions of scenes from his worlds, musical settings of his
  ballads and poetry).  The group would furthermore be open to
  discussion about JRRT the man, and how the circumstances of his life
  relate to his writing.

  The Group would be open to comparisons of Tolkien's works with those
  of other authors, e.g. comparing the influence of Christianity
  JRRT's writing with its influence on C.S. Lewis's works; comparing
  Sauron with Milton's Satan as a figure of evil; etc.  If such a
  discussion drifted into a discussion of the other author alone (and
  no longer touched on Tolkien), it would no longer be appropriate for
  the Group, and participants would be asked to move the discussion to
  a more appropriate newsgroup, or to EMail.

  Fan fiction would be permitted, provided that it did not violate
  anyone's rights or copyrights (especially the rights and copyrights
  of the Tolkien estate). Posters of fan fiction would be strongly
  encouraged to put the identifying word "FANFIC" in the "subject"
  line (to simplify kill-filing). Satire and parody of Tolkien's work
  would also be permitted. If the poster could reasonably expect
  readers to be offended by the posting, he or she should post it in
  rot-13 encryption (i.e. each letter is mapped to the letter 13
  places on in the alphabet, so that 'a' becomes 'n', 'b' becomes 'o',
  etc.).

  Willful and/or repeated spelling of JRRT's name as "Tolkein" would
  be punished by brutal sarcasm.

From [email protected] Wed Mar 10 21:08:23 1993
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Andrew Solovay)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.fan.tolkien,rec.arts.books,rec.arts.sf.written
Subject: 2nd CFV and VOTE ACK: rec.arts.books.tolkien
Followup-To: poster
Date: 3 Mar 1993 23:53:36 -0500
Organization: Castle Anthrax
Lines: 459
Sender: [email protected]
Approved: [email protected]
Message-ID: <[email protected]>
References: <[email protected]>
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3323 news.groups:67538 alt.fan.tolkien:2879 rec.arts.books:61500 rec.arts.sf.written:21350

This is a reposting of the call for votes to create a new unmoderated
group, rec.arts.books.tolkien. (The name was determined by a straw
poll.)  This post contains information about the proposed group and
voting instructions.

This posting also contains a listing of all people from whom valid
votes have been received (as of 3/1/93). The listing follows the
charter.

NEWSGROUP

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (unmoderated)

VOTING

  The voting period will begin when this CFV is posted. It will end at
  23:59:59 PST March 19, 1993. Votes must be *received* by the
  deadline. According to the USENET rules, in order for the group to
  be created, at least 2/3 of the votes cast must be "YES" votes, and
  there must be at least 100 more "YES" votes than "NO" votes.

  Votes must be sent to one of the following two addresses:

        [email protected]
	[email protected]

  You may simply "reply" to this posting. Each address can accept both
  "YES" and "NO" votes. Votes posted to any newsgroup will NOT be
  counted.

  The subject line should be an unambiguous "yes" or "no" vote (e.g.
  "I vote {YES,NO} on the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien as
  proposed"). If the subject line doesn't have such a statement, I
  will check the body of the message for the vote.

  Please include your full name.

  Conditional statements (e.g. "I would vote YES if...") will be
  considered comments, not votes. If you wish to make comments, you
  are welcome to do so; however, please make sure that your ballot
  begins with an unambiguous vote.

  No more than one vote may come from any one account; you may not
  mail votes on behalf of another person. Each person is permitted to
  vote only once, no matter how many accounts he or she might have. If
  a single person or account sends more than one vote, the vote with
  the latest "sending" time will be the official vote.

  I will attempt to acknowledge every vote via EMail (i.e. "Your NO
  vote against the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien has been
  received").  There will also be two repeats of this CFV, each of
  which will have a full list of voters (without specifying which way
  they voted).

  If you are unsure whether your vote was received, you may EMail me
  at either of the above addresses. However, I cannot divulge the vote
  tallies until the end of the voting period. I also cannot answer
  questions about the content of the group (other than by mailing a
  copy of the charter).

============================================================

CHARTER 

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (hereinafter referred to as "The Group")
  would be a forum for discussion of all the works of Professor J.R.R.
  Tolkien (hereinafter "JRRT"). It would be open to discussion of his
  "Middle-earth" works, his scholarly writings, his essays and poetry,
  and all other works of JRRT (of whatever nature). The Group would be
  open to discussion at any level; for example, discussion of his
  "Middle-Earth" works could vary from literary criticism to
  philological discussion of the book's languages, or any other topic
  bearing on the works.

  The Group would also be open for discussion of works by other
  authors which relate to JRRT's work (including, but not limited to,
  scholarly criticism of his work, supplemental and speculative
  writings about his worlds, analyses of the various languages created
  by JRRT, and (of course) the elaborate historical material published
  by Christopher Tolkien). The group would be open to discussion about
  art works which are based on Tolkien's works (e.g. graphic
  depictions of scenes from his worlds, musical settings of his
  ballads and poetry).  The group would furthermore be open to
  discussion about JRRT the man, and how the circumstances of his life
  relate to his writing.

  The Group would be open to comparisons of Tolkien's works with those
  of other authors, e.g. comparing the influence of Christianity
  JRRT's writing with its influence on C.S. Lewis's works; comparing
  Sauron with Milton's Satan as a figure of evil; etc.  If such a
  discussion drifted into a discussion of the other author alone (and
  no longer touched on Tolkien), it would no longer be appropriate for
  the Group, and participants would be asked to move the discussion to
  a more appropriate newsgroup, or to EMail.

  Fan fiction would be permitted, provided that it did not violate
  anyone's rights or copyrights (especially the rights and copyrights
  of the Tolkien estate). Posters of fan fiction would be strongly
  encouraged to put the identifying word "FANFIC" in the "subject"
  line (to simplify kill-filing). Satire and parody of Tolkien's work
  would also be permitted. If the poster could reasonably expect
  readers to be offended by the posting, he or she should post it in
  rot-13 encryption (i.e. each letter is mapped to the letter 13
  places on in the alphabet, so that 'a' becomes 'n', 'b' becomes 'o',
  etc.).

  Willful and/or repeated spelling of JRRT's name as "Tolkein" would
  be punished by brutal sarcasm.

VOTE ACK

  As of 3/1/93, 23:59:59 PST, votes have been received from the
  following people. If you sent a vote much earlier than that, please
  contact me at the voting addresses to make sure your vote was
  received.

  I attempted to send a confirmation notice to everyone who voted. If
  you received a confirmation notice dated on or before 3/1/93 and
  your name is not listed here, please contact me immediately.

  Votes are listed in order by account name. "YES" and "NO" votes are
  *not* separated.

[email protected]                   
[email protected]                     
[email protected]              Bruce Alan Wilson 
[email protected]          Chris Marble  
[email protected]                  David W. Wright 
[email protected]           
[email protected]               Brett   
[email protected]                  Daniel Triplett  
[email protected]          Dave Wyble  
[email protected]        David Empson  
[email protected]               Hector Cancela  
[email protected]        Herbert Leitz  
[email protected]               Eric Alfred Burns 
[email protected]               Kevin Foss  
[email protected]            Elaine Tindill  
[email protected]               "J.W.Baxter"   
[email protected]             
[email protected]               "Juha M{enp{{, puh. 508
[email protected]                  "James L. Durrell" 
[email protected]                Juhani Polvinen  
[email protected]        Kay Shapero  
[email protected]        Erick D. Mccroskey 
[email protected]                    
[email protected]        "Loren J. Miller" 
[email protected]            Michael Quinn  
[email protected]                  Greg Morrow  
[email protected]        Michael P. Colburn 
[email protected]                 "M. Otto"  
[email protected]                   Patrick S. Clark 
[email protected]             Anna-Maija Rajakangas  
[email protected]        Kevin W. Welch 
[email protected]                    Steve Fagg  
[email protected]                     
[email protected]               
[email protected]              Tony Zbaraschuk  
[email protected]                       Carl Patrik Andila 
[email protected]          Arthur Rubin  
[email protected]                       Al Wesolowsky  
[email protected]                    Andrew A. Chernov 
[email protected]            Steve C Liu 
[email protected]                               
[email protected]                  Jun Akiyama  
[email protected]                Alex Knight  
[email protected]            John Allen  
[email protected]              Amberle Ferrian  
[email protected]                   Adam Costello  
[email protected]                  Andrew McCown  
[email protected]                  Andrew Finkenstadt  
[email protected]                      Antti Miettinen  
[email protected]                   Stephanie da Silva 
[email protected]                   Alan R. Minns 
[email protected]             Arthur Chandler  
[email protected]        Ran Atkinson  
[email protected]           Ed Bailey  
[email protected]                    Nathan Bardsley  
[email protected]                      David Barr  
[email protected]                      J. Kintscher  
[email protected]                   Bengt Larsson  
[email protected]                   Magne Bergland  
[email protected]               Bram Smits  
[email protected]                    Brian Troxell  
[email protected]                   Anthony Brock  
[email protected]                   Jan Brittenson  
[email protected]             Dan Burnett  
[email protected]                         Burt N Holzman 
[email protected]        Paul Fisahn  
[email protected]                     Charlie Collins  
[email protected]           Mark Thomas  
[email protected]              Carl F. Hostetter 
[email protected]              Mike Carney  
[email protected]                 Dave Carr  
[email protected]        Kai-Uwe Froehlich  
[email protected]              John Lindsey  
[email protected]                  Charles Fitzgerald  
[email protected]             C G Kolar 
[email protected]                  Charlie Hancock  
[email protected]              Len Charest  
[email protected]          Charles Emmons  
[email protected]               Chris Cole  
[email protected]        Matt Deter  
[email protected]                           Christopher Davis  
councill@levy.bard.edu                John Councill  
craigb@sdd.hp.com                     Craig Bosworth  
creps@nickel.ucs.indiana.edu          "Stephen A. Creps" 
crispops@world.std.com                Dale A Smoak 
crosby@caesar.cs.colorado.edu         Matthew Crosby  
curtw@euler.jsc.nasa.gov              Curt Wiederhoeft  
cwes1@cs.aukuni.ac.nz                    
d1pihlan@dtek.chalmers.se             Fredrik Pihlstr|m  
d90-flu@nada.kth.se                      
d90-joh@nada.kth.se                      
d90-two@nada.kth.se                   Thomas Wolmer  
darsys@pro-entropy.cts.com            Eric A. Seiden 
dasmith@husc.harvard.edu              David A. Smith 
dave@twg.com                          "David E. Boyce" 
davei@wam.umd.edu                     Dave Israel  
david@albertina.inesc.pt              David M. M. de
dfaulkne@uafhp.uark.edu               Don Faulkner  
dgk4@po.cwru.edu                      David G. Kahane 
djweisbe@unix.amherst.edu             David Weisberger  
dko@cs.wisc.edu                       David Olsen  
dmize@bluemoon.use.com                Dave Mize  
dmosher@nyx.cs.du.edu                 David Mosher  
dmsilev@athena.mit.edu                Daniel Silevitch  
dnh@mfltd.co.uk                       Des Herriott  
dpn2@po.cwru.edu                      Damien P. Neil 
dricki@rpi.edu                           
dunphy@sparc0a.cs.uiuc.edu            Michael Dunphy  
durrell@chop.isca.uiowa.edu           Bryant Durrell  
dwiseman@erim.org                     Dave Wiseman  
dzik@access.digex.com                 Joseph Dzikiewicz  
eckman@eos1.larc.nasa.gov             Richard Eckman  
edh@staff.tc.umn.edu                  Eric D. Hendrickson 
ejo@kaja.gi.alaska.edu                "Eric J. Olson" 
emma@russell.stanford.edu             Emma Pease  
er@iscp.bellcore.com                  Elie Rosenfeld  
erwvegm@cs.vu.nl                      Erwin van Egmond 
esri!esrican!scarlett@uunet.uu        Brian Scarlett  
eyhung@garnet.berkeley.edu            Eugene Hung  
fath@mbcrr.harvard.edu                Michael Fath  
fehr@ms.uky.edu                       Jeff Davis  
fischer@mermaid.micro.umn.edu         Scott W Fischer 
fishe@casbah.acns.nwu.edu             Carwil James  
fls@keynes.econ.duke.edu              Forrest Smith  
folta@cs.umd.edu                      Wayne Folta  
forb0004@student.tc.umn.edu           Eric Forbis  
futor@llnl.gov                           
genetic+@pitt.edu                     David Tate  
geoffb@coos.dartmouth.edu                
ggurman@cory.berkeley.edu             Gail Gurman  
ggw@wolves.durham.nc.us               Gregory G. Woodbury 
gix@mdd.comm.mot.com                  Brian Gix  
goolsbey@cs.utexas.edu                Keith Goolsbey  
gorgen@ann-arbor.applicon.slb.        David Gorgen  
gottscha@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de              Thomas Gottschalk  
graham@cs.washington.edu              Stephen Graham  
gt0644c@prism.gatech.edu              Scott Gust  
gt5052b@prism.gatech.edu              Erica Liebman Sadun 
guenther@stolaf.edu                   Philip Guenther  
gulla@pvv.unit.no                     Anders H}kon Gulla 
gumby@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                David Brian Gumminger 
hades@coos.dartmouth.edu              Brian Hughes  
hanoune@ensisun.imag.fr                  
hansenr@ohsu.edu                      Robert Hansen  
hansm@info.win.tue.nl                 Hans Mulder  
hayter@ramsesii.ultryx.com            Jim Hayter  
hinshaw@vsopz3.cern.ch                Dean A. Hinshaw 
holly@kauri.vuw.ac.nz                 RH Schone  
huff@mcclb0.med.nyu.edu               Edward J. Huff 
iba@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov              Wayne Iba  
ig25@rz.uni-karlsruhe.de              Thomas Koenig  
jamie@cs.sfu.ca                       Jamie Andrews  
jan@lyr.dhmolde.no                    Jan Ove Liatun 
jbaxter@leland.stanford.edu           Joel Kent Baxter 
jbjorklu@aton.abo.fi                  Joakim Bjorklund  
jc@crosfield.co.uk                    Jerry Cullingford  
jchokey@leland.stanford.edu           James Alexander Chokey 
jclander@maestro.mitre.org            Julian C. Lander 
jdh34098@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             "John D. Harper" 
jduncan@prism.nmt.edu                 John Duncan  
jep1@cec2.wustl.edu                   Jason Edward Purcell 
jfarrell@morgan.ucs.mun.ca            James Farrell  
jfurr@nyx.cs.du.edu                   Joel Furr  
jhawk@panix.com                       John Hawkinson  
jim@mycroft.rand.org                  Jim Gillogly  
jimbo@math.psu.edu                    Jim Humphreys  
jkellett@netcom.com                   Joe Kellett  
jks2j@faraday.clas.virginia.ed        Skip Sizemore  
jmann@vineland.pubs.stratus.co        Jim Mann  
jmaynard@nyx.cs.du.edu                Jay Maynard  
jms@tardis.tymnet.com                 Joe Smith  
jmw-b@minster.york.ac.uk                 
john@iastate.edu                         
jonas@beor.informatik.rwth-aac        Josef Nelissen  
jreese@sablon.ics.uci.edu             Jon Damon Reese 
jrr@oolong.la.locus.com               Jefery Roberts  
jsax@igc.apc.org                      Joel Sax  
jspencer@world.std.com                Jeffrey C Spencer 
julliard@di.epfl.ch                   Alexandre Julliard  
jvh@mdata.fi                          Jussi-Ville Heiskanen  
jw@eng.ufl.edu                        "John White"  
jxh@unixhub.slac.stanford.edu         John Halperin  
kaig@ccmail.odh.no                    Kai Gjessing  
kaltef@theo-physik.uni-kiel.db        Roland Kaltefleiter  
karyn@cheetah.llnl.gov                Karyn Pichnarczyk  
kelsey@unixhub.slac.stanford.e        Michael Kelsey  
kenney@saturn.hsi.com                 Brian Kenney  
klaus@diku.dk                         Klaus Ole Kristiansen 
konrad@mace.cc.purdue.edu             Bill Konrad  
kpaasial@cc.helsinki.fi               Kimmo T Paasiala 
kthompso@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov         Kevin Thompson  
lampson@software.pulse.com            Dave Lampson  
lau@ai.sri.com                        Stephen Lau  
laura@catfish.ocpt.ccur.com           Laura Gillespie  
lees@asf.com                          Lee Short  
leet@acsu.buffalo.edu                 Brian D. Leet 
leitm@essex.ac.uk                     Miguel Leith  
leneis@cse.ogi.edu                    Tony Leneis  
leonard@ssd.intel.com                 Leonard Bottleman  
librik@cory.berkeley.edu              David Librik  
lindaas@cae.wisc.edu                  Bradley Lindaas  
lisbon@vpnet.chi.il.us                Gerry Swetsky  
lorenz@wu-wien.ac.at                  (Bernhard Lorenz)  
lucas@scicom.alphacdc.com             Kevin L. Lord 
lytle@noao.edu                        Dyer Lytle  
ma9tn@ss1.bath.ac.uk                  Tom Nettleship  
magi@eng.umd.edu                      "John E. Krokes" 
mastr@husc.harvard.edu                Claudia Mastroianni  
matwood@peruvian.cs.utah.edu          Mark Atwood  
maureen@lamar.colostate.edu           Lynn Bormann  
maus@olias.linet.org                     
mbm@dsbc.icl.co.uk                    Malcolm Mladenovic  
mcconnel@mcs.kent.edu                 Mike McConnell  
mcglk@cpac.washington.edu             Ken McGlothlen  
mcgregoa@cognos.com                   Alayne McGregor  
mcmurry%orion.physics@ox.ac.uk        Andrew McMurry  
meyers@alpha.ces.cwru.edu             Greg Meyers  
mf23@umd5.umd.edu                     James B. Whitmore 
mfey@cco.caltech.edu                  Mark P. Fey 
mhatz@nyx.cs.du.edu                   Mike Hatz  
mho@stacken.kth.se                    Magnus Holmberg  
microsoc@ox.ac.uk                     Nicholas McMurray  
miked@phenos.physics.wisc.edu         Michael A. Doncheski 
mikep@sequent.com                     Michael A. Prescott 
minnotte@raven.math.usu.edu           Mike Minnotte  
mjm@hplb.hpl.hp.com                   Martin Merry  
mkelly@ovid.helios.nd.edu             Michael Kelly  
mmunoz@vxcrna.cern.ch                 Mark Munoz  
mnaka@john-whorfin.ics.uci.edu        Merri L Naka 
morgoth@titan.ucs.umass.edu           Scott M. Rogala 
msg@cse.iitb.ernet.in                 Milind Gandhe  
msp@physique.ens.fr                   Michael S. Pettersen 
msuzio@tiamat.umd.umich.edu           Mike Suzio  
mworley@mathcs.emory.edu              Meg Worley  
nagjpw@vax.ox.ac.uk                   Jeremy Walton  
odgate!homebru!smith!dick@sunb           
paul@erc.msstate.edu                  Paul Adams  
paul@oberon.econ.yale.edu             Paul McGuire  
paulg@convex.csd.uwm.edu              Paul A Gunderson 
pavalin@bnr.ca                        "Paul (P.A.) Valin" 
per@front.se                          "Per Lindberg"  
peters@physics.ubc.ca                 Dan Peters  
petervr@sci.kun.nl                    Peter van Rossum 
pevans@sanjuan.uvic.ca                Patricia Evans  
phaniraj@plains.nodak.edu             "V. Phaniraj"  
phiber@eff.org                        Phiber Optik  
phillips@syrinx.umd.edu               Leanne Phillips  
phoenix@ugcs.caltech.edu              Damien R. Sullivan 
phydeaux@guru.med.cornell.edu         Dave Weingart  
pjb4288@ultb.isc.rit.edu              Pete Boulay  
plutchak@porter.geo.brown.edu         Joel Plutchak  
ponds!squink.UUCP!biljir@dg-rt        Alan Beale  
pv02@lehigh.edu                       Peter V. Vorobieff 
rachel@phsbbs.princeton.nj.us         Rachel Meredith Kadel 
rcb3@win.tue.nl                       Olaf Weber  
rezk@bourbaki.mit.edu                 Charles Rezk  
rfd@po.cwru.edu                       Richard F. Drushel 
rick@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu          Richard H. Miller 
rka20423@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             Ruben Areyzaga  
rkamal@ccs.carleton.ca                R Kamal  
rlb@access.digex.com                  "Richard L. Butler" 
rlcarr@animato.network23.com          Rich Carreiro  
rleroux1@ra.uvic.ca                   Roger Leroux  
rmg3@grebyn.com                       Robert Grumbine  
rn.1558@rose.com                      Jo Churcher  
rnichols@ihlpm.att.com                Bob Nichols  
rnlee@sdcc3.ucsd.edu                  Roderick Lee  
rnmg1200@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             John W. Vargas 
roberson@masc1.rice.edu               Kyle Ray Roberson 
ronena@ccsg.tau.ac.il                 Ronen Altman  
ronnie@cisco.com                      "Ronnie B. Kon" 
roshne@faerun.mi.org                  Rod Shelton  
rp04@lehigh.edu                       R M Price 
rsquires@cyclops.eece.unm.edu         Roger Squires  
samw@bucket.rain.com                  Sam Warden  
samw@bucket.rain.com                  Sam Warden  
sandee@quake.think.com                Daan Sandee  
scruggs@gtewd.mtv.gsc.gte.com         BCFD #36  
sears@cello.hpl.hp.com                Bart Sears  
seurer+@rchland.ibm.com               Bill Seurer  
shimeall@taurus.cs.nps.navy.mi        Timothy Shimeall  
siler@cs.utk.edu                      Vernon Siler  
simpsong@dns0.bham.ac.uk              Glyn Simpson  
sirowe@suncis.ycc.yale.edu            Si Rowe  
sjm1@postoffice.mail.cornell.e        Seth J. Morabito 
sjsmith@cs.umd.edu                    Stephen Joseph Smith 
smacmanu@brahms.helios.nd.edu         stephen macmanus  
smarry@zooid.guild.org                Marc Moorcroft  
snabb@apu.fi                          Janne Snabb  
soepstad@nora.gih.no                  lars soepstad  
solovay@netcom.com                    Andrew Solovay  
spenceb@ucunix.san.uc.edu             Brad A. Spencer 
spm2d@topaz.cs.virginia.edu              
sshriner@magnus.acs.ohio-state        Sara L Shriner 
ssircar@canon.com                     Subrata Sircar  
ssleong@csasoft.csam.my                  
steve@kittyhawk.ecn.uoknor.edu        Steve Coltrin  
stssram@st.unocal.com                 Bob Myers  
stu@valinor.mythical.com              Stu Labovitz  
stuart@scs.leeds.ac.uk                S Butterfield  
svasi@skinner.cs.uoregon.edu          Nathan Tenny  
t92etr@bellatrix.tdb.uu.se            Erik Trulsson  
tamora@owlnet.rice.edu                Tami Dawn Kimmel 
tdober@simtow.netcom.com              Terri Oberkamper  
tim@fiu.edu                           Timothy Walker  
tittle@alexandre-dumas.ics.uci        Cindy Tittle Moore 
tmm@cs.brown.edu                      T. M. Murali 
torpana@vinkku.hut.fi                    
tredysvr!tredysvr!cnmss!mcl@gv        Michael C. Leap 
troyer@ips.id.ethz.ch                    
tsnow@bigbird.cs.ohiou.edu            Todd Snow  
ttiittan@vinkku.hut.fi                Tero Tiittanen  
tyg@valhalla.hq.ileaf.com             Tom Galloway  
umgelter@azu.informatik.uni-st           
uunet!atlantis!aaron                  Aaron Humphrey  
uunet!decwrl!decvax!nj8j.black        Ben Coleman  
uunet!impmh!dsg                       Dave Gordon  
uunet!uflorida!sinkhole!junix!        Melinda Smirl  
vernon@safe.ia.gov                    Mark Vernon  
vjg@cbnews.att.com                    Vince Guinto  
wald@theory.lcs.mit.edu               David Wald  
warninm@xanth.cs.orst.edu             Michael Warning  
wenzelm@informatik.tu-muenchen        Markus Wenzel  
werner@soe.berkeley.edu               John Werner  
wft@math.canterbury.ac.nz                
wmperry@blueberry.ucs.indiana.        William M. Perry 
xmed@vse.vse.cs                       Hynek Med  
yyy2t@holmes.acc.virginia.edu         "Yvonne Y. Yang" 
zippy@berry.cs.brandeis.edu           Patrick Tufts  
zkessin@chaos.cs.brandeis.edu         "Zach Kessin"  
zorak@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                Scott E Flowers 
-- 
Andrew Solovay    

"I am the Golux, the only Golux in the world, 
 and not a mere Device."

From solovay@netcom.com Thu Mar 11 11:35:25 1993
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: solovay@netcom.com (Andrew Solovay)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.fan.tolkien,rec.arts.books,rec.arts.sf.written
Subject: 3rd CFV and VOTE ACK: rec.arts.books.tolkien
Followup-To: poster
Date: 11 Mar 1993 01:38:42 -0500
Organization: Castle Anthrax
Lines: 652
Sender: tale@rodan.UU.NET
Approved: tale@uunet.uu.net
Message-ID: <1nmmpiINN5bj@rodan.UU.NET>
References: <1mdubuINNsai@rodan.UU.NET> <1n420gINNhof@rodan.UU.NET>
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3347 news.groups:67887 alt.fan.tolkien:3026 rec.arts.books:61970 rec.arts.sf.written:21675

This is a call for votes to create a new unmoderated group,
rec.arts.books.tolkien. (The name was determined by a straw poll.)
This post contains information about the proposed group and voting
instructions.

This posting also contains a listing of all people from whom valid
votes have been received (as of 3/9/93). The listing follows the
charter.

One small request: If you vote by "reply"ing to this CFV, *please*,
*please*, *please* don't include this posting. I already have a copy
of it; you don't have to send all 644 lines to me. 

Remember, only those votes *received* by 23:59:59, March 19, 1993 will
be counted. 

NEWSGROUP

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (unmoderated)

VOTING

  The voting period will begin when this CFV is posted. It will end at
  23:59:59 PST March 19, 1993. Votes must be *received* by the
  deadline. According to the USENET rules, in order for the group to
  be created, at least 2/3 of the votes cast must be "YES" votes, and
  there must be at least 100 more "YES" votes than "NO" votes.

  Votes must be sent to one of the following two addresses:

        solovay@netcom.com
	bsw!asolovay@uunet.uu.net

  You may simply "reply" to this posting. Each address can accept both
  "YES" and "NO" votes. Votes posted to any newsgroup will NOT be
  counted.

  The subject line should be an unambiguous "yes" or "no" vote (e.g.
  "I vote {YES,NO} on the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien as
  proposed"). If the subject line doesn't have such a statement, I
  will check the body of the message for the vote.

  Please include your full name.

  Conditional statements (e.g. "I would vote YES if...") will be
  considered comments, not votes. If you wish to make comments, you
  are welcome to do so; however, please make sure that your ballot
  begins with an unambiguous vote.

  No more than one vote may come from any one account; you may not
  mail votes on behalf of another person. Each person is permitted to
  vote only once, no matter how many accounts he or she might have. If
  a single person or account sends more than one vote, the vote with
  the latest "sending" time will be the official vote.

  I will attempt to acknowledge every vote via EMail (i.e. "Your NO
  vote against the creation of rec.arts.books.tolkien has been
  received").  There will also be two repeats of this CFV, each of
  which will have a full list of voters (without specifying which way
  they voted).

  If you are unsure whether your vote was received, you may EMail me
  at either of the above addresses. However, I cannot divulge the vote
  tallies until the end of the voting period. I also cannot answer
  questions about the content of the group (other than by mailing a
  copy of the charter).

============================================================

CHARTER 

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (hereinafter referred to as "The Group")
  would be a forum for discussion of all the works of Professor J.R.R.
  Tolkien (hereinafter "JRRT"). It would be open to discussion of his
  "Middle-earth" works, his scholarly writings, his essays and poetry,
  and all other works of JRRT (of whatever nature). The Group would be
  open to discussion at any level; for example, discussion of his
  "Middle-Earth" works could vary from literary criticism to
  philological discussion of the book's languages, or any other topic
  bearing on the works.

  The Group would also be open for discussion of works by other
  authors which relate to JRRT's work (including, but not limited to,
  scholarly criticism of his work, supplemental and speculative
  writings about his worlds, analyses of the various languages created
  by JRRT, and (of course) the elaborate historical material published
  by Christopher Tolkien). The group would be open to discussion about
  art works which are based on Tolkien's works (e.g. graphic
  depictions of scenes from his worlds, musical settings of his
  ballads and poetry).  The group would furthermore be open to
  discussion about JRRT the man, and how the circumstances of his life
  relate to his writing.

  The Group would be open to comparisons of Tolkien's works with those
  of other authors, e.g. comparing the influence of Christianity
  JRRT's writing with its influence on C.S. Lewis's works; comparing
  Sauron with Milton's Satan as a figure of evil; etc.  If such a
  discussion drifted into a discussion of the other author alone (and
  no longer touched on Tolkien), it would no longer be appropriate for
  the Group, and participants would be asked to move the discussion to
  a more appropriate newsgroup, or to EMail.

  Fan fiction would be permitted, provided that it did not violate
  anyone's rights or copyrights (especially the rights and copyrights
  of the Tolkien estate). Posters of fan fiction would be strongly
  encouraged to put the identifying word "FANFIC" in the "subject"
  line (to simplify kill-filing). Satire and parody of Tolkien's work
  would also be permitted. If the poster could reasonably expect
  readers to be offended by the posting, he or she should post it in
  rot-13 encryption (i.e. each letter is mapped to the letter 13
  places on in the alphabet, so that 'a' becomes 'n', 'b' becomes 'o',
  etc.).

  Willful and/or repeated spelling of JRRT's name as "Tolkein" would
  be punished by brutal sarcasm.

VOTE ACK

  As of 3/9/93, 23:59:59 PST, votes have been received from the
  following people. If you sent a vote much earlier than that, please
  contact me at the voting addresses to make sure your vote was
  received.

  I attempted to send a confirmation notice to everyone who voted. If
  you received a confirmation notice dated on or before 3/9/93 and
  your name is not listed here, please contact me immediately.

  If a name has a question mark (i.e. "John Smith?"), it means the
  post did not include a real name, and I got the name by fingering
  the account.
  
Invalid votes:
-------------
  Some votes were invalid, for various reasons (usually because the
  vote was overly vague). For example, several people sent me messages
  which consisted only of the word "yes" or "no", with no mention of
  the vote or the group name. These messages *could* have been
  intended as votes, but I decided they were invalid.

  I made at least one attempt to contact every person who sent me an
  invalid vote. Most of those people responded with acceptable votes,
  and are listed under the "valid votes" list. Thos who have sent in
  invalid votes and have not yet corrected them are listed here.

GANESH@jhuvms.hcf.jhu.edu        
rvblumer@mailbox.syr.edu         Robert V. Blumer
ma_blase@csd.uwe-bristol.ac.uk   Fox

Valid votes:
-----------

003166J@axe.acadiau.ca                Jason
A.J.Harlow@city.ac.uk                 A.J. Harlow
ALC110@psuvm.psu.edu                  
ALI00BAW@unccvm.uncc.edu              Bruce Wilson
Brian.Ewald@math.lsa.umich.edu        Brian Ewald
CMARBLE@hmcvax.claremont.edu          Chris Marble
D.T.Shield@compsci.liverpool.ac.uk    Dave Shield
D.W.Wright@bnr.co.uk                  David Wright
DAVEL%EARLHAM.BITNET@uicvm.uic.edu    
DAVID@master.uchicago.edu             David Hardin
DEMON@desire.wright.edu               
DTRIPLETT@loyola.edu                  Dan Triplett
Dave_Wyble.wbst147@xerox.com          Dave Wyble
David.Empson@bbs.actrix.gen.nz        David Empson
FSSPR@acad3.alaska.edu                
GRAJEK@yalevm.ycc.yale.edu            Susan Grajek
Hector.Cancela@irisa.fr               Hector Cancela
Herbert.Leitz@physik.uni-muenchen.de   Herbert Leitz
IK20001@maine.maine.edu               Eric Alfred Burns
IO20816@maine.maine.edu               Kevin Foss
ISTS015@uabdpo.dpo.uab.edu            Elaine Tindill
J.W.Baxter@durham.ac.uk               "J.W.Baxter"
JDPURNELL@sae.towson.edu              David Purnell
JLM@slacvm.slac.stanford.edu          Jose Martinez?
JMAENPAA@cc.helsinki.fi               "Juha M{enp{{, puh. 508 5291"
JXD132@psuvm.psu.edu                  "James L. Durrell"
Juhani.Polvinen@fmi.fi                Juhani Polvinen
KELSEY@slacvm.slac.stanford.edu       "KELSEY, Michael H."
Kay.Shapero@f524.n102.z1.fidonet.org   Kay Shapero
MCCROSKEYED%DFP@pcmail.usafa.af.mil    Erick D. Mccroskey
MCSPIKTA@cluster.cc.dundee-tech.ac.uk   Kenny Armstrong
MECE23J@jetson.uh.edu                 Mats O. Orrhede?
MGL4@psuvm.psu.edu                    Michael G. LeSeny
MILLERL@wilma.wharton.upenn.edu       "Loren J. Miller"
MJQUINN@pucc.princeton.edu            Michael Quinn
MORROW@fnal.fnal.gov                  Greg Morrow
Michael.Norrish@comp.vuw.ac.nz        Michael Norrish
Michael.P.Colburn@dartmouth.edu       Michael P. Colburn
OTTO@vaxb.acs.unt.edu                 "M. Otto"
PATRICKC@cc.usu.edu                   Patrick S. Clark
PRRONAN@chemical.watstar.uwaterloo.ca    Patrick Robert Ronan
RAJAKANGAS@cc.helsinki.fi             Anna-Maija Rajakangas
RIAWELCH@ubvmsb.cc.buffalo.edu        Mad City Blues
S.L.Fagg@bnr.co.uk                    Steve Fagg
SODONNELL@umassd.edu                  
SPROLES@pine.circa.ufl.edu            
TOHALL@ariel.lerc.nasa.gov            
TZBARASC@ucs.indiana.edu              Tony Zbaraschuk
U48073@uicvm.uic.edu                  "Cole Kendall"
USER2E9P@um.cc.umich.edu              
Undergraduate.Math.Club@um.cc.umich.edu   
Wayne.G.Hammond@williams.edu          Wayne Hammond Jr
Wilson.M.Clements@dartmouth.edu       Wilson M. Clements
a70860@uwasa.fi                       Carl Patrik Andila
a_rubin@dsg4.dse.beckman.com          Arthur Rubin
abw@crsa.bu.edu                       Al Wesolowsky
ac544@freenet.carleton.ca             Michael MacKay
ache@astral.msk.su                    Andrew A. Chernov
achille@nemo.greco-prog.fr            Jean-Pierre BRAQUELAIRE
acw@apple.com                         Art Willis
admiral@jhunix.hcf.jhu.edu            Steve C Liu
ag@sics.se                            Anders G|ransson?
akiy@cs.titech.ac.jp                  Jun Akiyama
alan@alan.b30.ingr.com                Alan Barksdale
alex@mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk                Knight Alex
alg@cs.cornell.edu                    Anne Louise Gockel
allen@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov            John Allen
amberle@staff.tc.umn.edu              Amberle Ferrian
amc@wucs1.wustl.edu                   Adam Costello
anderson@alexia.lis.uiuc.edu          Chris Anderson
andy@cs.rhbnc.ac.uk                   Andy Thomas
andy@pic.melco.co.jp                  Andrew McCown
andy@vistachrome.com                  Andrew Finkenstadt
ap1i+@andrew.cmu.edu                  "Andrew C. Plotkin"
apm@kikka.hut.fi                      Antti Miettinen
arielle@neosoft.com                   Stephanie da Silva
arm16@cus.cam.ac.uk                   A.R. Minns
arthurc@sfsuvax1.sfsu.edu             Arthur Chandler
atkinson@tengwar.itd.nrl.navy.mil     Ran Atkinson
bailey@utpapa.ph.utexas.edu           Ed Bailey
bards_n@cs.odu.edu                    Nathan Bardsley
barr@pop.psu.edu                      David Barr
beast@netcom.com                      J. Kintscher
bell@aussie.enet.dec.com              Peter Bell
bengtl@maths.lth.se                   Bengt Larsson
bergland@edb.uib.no                   Magne Bergland
bls101@deakin.anu.edu.au              Barbara La Scala
bouillon@cs.uni-sb.de                 Peter G. Bouillon
bouvin@daimi.aau.dk                   Niels Olof Bouvin
bram@fangorn.hacktic.nl               Bram Smits
brian@audiofax.com                    Brian TroxeLL
brocka@ucs.orst.edu                   Anthony Brock
bson@gnu.ai.mit.edu                   Jan Brittenson
btree!cjohn@ucsd.edu                  John C. Ruff
burnett@gummo.cse.ogi.edu             Dan Burnett
burt+@cmu.edu                         Burt N Holzman
cabfi01@mailserv.zdv.uni-tuebingen.de    Paul Fisahn
cac@space.mit.edu                     Charlie Collins
capitol!thomas@uunet.uu.net           Mark Thomas
caplan@barrier.island.com             Rob Caplan
cargo@cherry.cray.com                 David S. Cargo
carl@class.gsfc.nasa.gov              Carl F. Hostetter
carney@igor.rational.com              Mike Carney
carr@acsu.buffalo.edu                 Dave Carr
cbkfr01@mailserv.zdv.uni-tuebingen.de    Kai-Uwe Froehlich
ccastjl@prism.gatech.edu              John Lindsey
cffitzge@iastate.edu                  Charles F. Fitzgerald
cfgcs@ux1.cts.eiu.edu                 Grant C. Sterling
cgk26737@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             C G Kolar
chancock@igc.apc.org                  Charlie Hancock
charest@aig.jpl.nasa.gov              Len Charest
charles%trintex@uunet.uu.net          Charles Emmons
chh9@midway.uchicago.edu              "Conrad Halling"
chris@porsche.visix.com               Chris Cole
chrise@srlr13.sr.hp.com               Chris Eich
chs1pm@surrey.ac.uk                   Dr Paul J Mitchell
citrus!mld@csusac.ecs.csus.edu         Matt Deter 
ckd@eff.org                           Christopher Davis
cmp0118@information-systems.east-anglia.ac.uk   "S." Green
connersb@cae.wisc.edu                 Brian Patrick Conners?
councill@levy.bard.edu                John Councill
cpresson@jido.b30.ingr.com            Craig Presson
craigb@sdd.hp.com                     Craig Bosworth
creps@nickel.ucs.indiana.edu          "Stephen A. Creps"
crispops@world.std.com                Dale A Smoak
crosby@caesar.cs.colorado.edu         Matthew Crosby
cstracha@casper.cs.uct.ac.za          Craig Strachan
curtw@euler.jsc.nasa.gov              Curt Wiederhoeft
cwes1@cs.aukuni.ac.nz                 
d1pihlan@dtek.chalmers.se             Fredrik Pihlstr|m
d88hanpe@und.ida.liu.se               Hans Persson
d90-flu@nada.kth.se                   Fredrik Lundberg?
d90-joh@nada.kth.se                   Jan-Erik 2hman?
d90-two@nada.kth.se                   Thomas Wolmer
darsys@pro-entropy.cts.com            Eric A. Seiden
dasher@well.sf.ca.us                  D Anton Sherwood
dasmith@husc.harvard.edu              David A. Smith
dave@rincon.ema.rockwell.com          Dave Emde
dave@twg.com                          "David E. Boyce"
davei@wam.umd.edu                     Dave Israel
david@albertina.inesc.pt              David M. M. de Matos
davidf@xenitec.on.ca                  David Fiander
deroo@eecs.umich.edu                  Roger DeRoo
dfaulkne@uafhp.uark.edu               Don Faulkner
dgk4@po.cwru.edu                      David G. Kahane
dhamilto@gssec.bt.co.uk               David Hamilton
djohnson@willamette.edu               Dane Johnson
djweisbe@unix.amherst.edu             David Weisberger
dko@cs.wisc.edu                       David Olsen
dmize@bluemoon.use.com                Dave Mize
dmk8r@birch.cs.virginia.edu           Darrell M. Kienzle
dmosher@nyx.cs.du.edu                 David Mosher
dmsilev@athena.mit.edu                Daniel Silevitch
dnh@mfltd.co.uk                       Des Herriott
dpn2@po.cwru.edu                      Damien P. Neil
dricki@rpi.edu                        Ilya Dricker?
dunphy@sparc0a.cs.uiuc.edu            Michael Dunphy
durrell@chop.isca.uiowa.edu           Bryant Durrell
dwiseman@erim.org                     Dave Wiseman
dzik@access.digex.com                 Joseph Dzikiewicz
eab@msc.edu                           Edward Bertsch
ebner@informatik.tu-muenchen.de       Ralf Ebner
eckman@eos1.larc.nasa.gov             Richard Eckman
edb@fairport.hq.ileaf.com             Ed Blachman x4420
edh@staff.tc.umn.edu                  Eric D. Henderson
edsr!jat@uunet.uu.net                 Jon A. Turner
ejo@kaja.gi.alaska.edu                "Eric J. Olson"
elentar@camelot.bradley.edu           Michael Carman
eliaz@techunix.technion.ac.il         Amir Eliaz
emcguire@intellection.com             Ed McGuire
emma@russell.stanford.edu             Emma Pease
en2prmm@ss1.bath.ac.uk                P R Martell-Mead
eoq@vthnw.cvm.msu.edu                 Edward Quillen
er@iscp.bellcore.com                  Elie Rosenfeld
erick@engin.umich.edu                 erick  alvarado
erwvegm@cs.vu.nl                      Erwin van Egmond
esi104@cch.coventry.ac.uk             Jo
esri!esrican!scarlett@uunet.uu.net    Brian Scarlett
eugene_rick@macmail1.csg.mot.com      Rick M. Eugene
eyhung@garnet.berkeley.edu            Eugene Hung
fath@mbcrr.harvard.edu                Michael Fath
fehr@ms.uky.edu                       Jeff Davis
fingon@archtwr.tower.nullnet.fi       Markus Stenberg
fischer@iesd.auc.dk                   Lars Peter Fischer
fischer@mermaid.micro.umn.edu         Scott W Fischer
fishe@casbah.acns.nwu.edu             Carwil James
fls@keynes.econ.duke.edu              Forrest Smith
folta@cs.umd.edu                      Wayne Folta
forb0004@student.tc.umn.edu           "Eric J Forbis-1"
futor@llnl.gov                        Randall J. Futor
fzimmerm@erim.org                     Fred Zimmerman
galahad@leland.stanford.edu           Scott Compton
gauecs@elara.fnma.com                 Eileen Scott
genetic+@pitt.edu                     David Tate
geoffb@coos.dartmouth.edu             Geoffrey Bronner?
ggurman@cory.berkeley.edu             Gail Gurman
ggw@wolves.durham.nc.us               Gregory G. Woodbury
gix@mdd.comm.mot.com                  Brian Gix
goolsbey@cs.utexas.edu                Keith Goolsbey
gorgen@ann-arbor.applicon.slb.com     David Gorgen
gottscha@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de              Thomas Gottschalk
gptrenow@teaching.cs.adelaide.edu.au    GP TRENOWDEN
gradient!rogerc@uunet.uu.net          
graham@cs.washington.edu              Stephen Graham
gt0644c@prism.gatech.edu              Scott Gust
gt5052b@prism.gatech.edu              Erica Liebman Sadun
guenther@stolaf.edu                   "Philip Guenther"
gulla@pvv.unit.no                     Anders H}kon Gulla
gumby@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                David Brian Gumminger
hades@coos.dartmouth.edu              Brian Hughes
hamerb@casbah.acns.nwu.edu            Barbara Hamer
hanoune@ensisun.imag.fr               Pierre
hansenr@ohsu.edu                      Robert Hansen
hansm@info.win.tue.nl                 Hans Mulder
harper!rmartine@uunet.uu.net          Rick Martinez
hatakka@cc.helsinki.fi                Yrjo Hatakka
hayter@ramsesii.ultryx.com            Jim Hayter
hdupless@stellenbos.csir.co.za        Heinrich Du Plessis
heinau@chemie.fu-berlin.de            Vera Heinau
herbison@lassie.enet.dec.com          
hid009@cent1.lancs.ac.uk              James Masterton
hinshaw@vsopz3.cern.ch                Dean A. Hinshaw
hkhenson@cup.portal.com               Keith Henson
holly@kauri.vuw.ac.nz                 RH Schone
hooverb@cs.wvu.wvnet.edu              Bruce Hoover
huff@mcclb0.med.nyu.edu               Edward J. Huff
iba@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov              Wayne Iba
ibmpa!squirrel.austin.ibm.com!chesky@ibminet.awdpa.ibm.com    Bill Chesky
ig25@rz.uni-karlsruhe.de              Thomas Koenig
j_herlih@oz.plymouth.edu              Jay A. Herlihy?
jamie@cs.sfu.ca                       Jamie Andrews
jan@bagend.atl.ga.us                  Jan Isley
jan@lyr.dhmolde.no                    Jan Ove Liatun
jbaxter@leland.stanford.edu           Joel Kent Baxter
jbjorklu@aton.abo.fi                  Joakim Bj|rklund INF
jbuckley@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu    James Buckley
jc@crosfield.co.uk                    jerry cullingford
jc@slim.gmd.de                        Juergen Christoffel
jcb@dcs.ed.ac.uk                      Julian Bradfield
jchokey@leland.stanford.edu           James Alexander Chokey
jclander@maestro.mitre.org            Julian C. Lander
jdh34098@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             "John D. Harper"
jduncan@prism.nmt.edu                 John Duncan
jeff@casbah.acns.nwu.edu              Jeff Williamson
jep1@cec2.wustl.edu                   Jason Edward Purcell
jf41+@andrew.cmu.edu                  "Jonathan R. Ferro"
jfarrell@morgan.ucs.mun.ca            James Farrell
jfurr@nyx.cs.du.edu                   Joel Furr
jgn@ukc.ac.uk                         
jgostin@eternal.chi.il.us             Jeff Gostin
jhawk@panix.com                       John Hawkinson
jhi@vinkku.hut.fi                     Jarkko Hietaniemi
jhopkins@cbacc.cba.uga.edu            John Hopkins
jim@mycroft.rand.org                  Jim Gillogly
jimbo@math.psu.edu                    Jim Humphreys
jimk@engin.umich.edu                  
jjonsson@alexandria.lib.utah.edu      Jeffrey Jonsson
jkellett@netcom.com                   Joe Kellett
jks2j@faraday.clas.virginia.edu       Skip Sizemore
jmann@vineland.pubs.stratus.com       Jim Mann
jmaynard@nyx.cs.du.edu                Jay Maynard
jms@tardis.tymnet.com                 Joe Smith
jmw-b@minster.york.ac.uk              
joern@ifi.uio.no                      J|rn Hagerup
john@iastate.edu                      John Hascall?
jonas@beor.informatik.rwth-aachen.de   Josef Nelissen
jreese@sablon.ics.uci.edu             Jon Damon Reese
jrr@oolong.la.locus.com               Jefery Roberts
jsax@igc.apc.org                      Joel Sax
jspencer@world.std.com                Jeffrey C Spencer
julliard@di.epfl.ch                   "(Alexandre Julliard)"
jute@sday.pulp.nullnet.fi             Jussi Kantola
jvh@mdata.fi                          Jussi-Ville Heiskanen
jw@eng.ufl.edu                        "John White"
jwhitney@seas.smu.edu                 John Whitney
jxh@unixhub.slac.stanford.edu         John Halperin
kaig@ccmail.odh.no                    Kai Gjessing
kaltef@theo-physik.uni-kiel.dbp.de    Roland Kaltefleiter
karyn@cheetah.llnl.gov                Karyn Pichnarczyk
kelsey@unixhub.slac.stanford.edu      Michael Kelsey
kenney@saturn.hsi.com                 Brian Kenney
kenw%bilbo@ihs.com                    Ken Weinert
klaus@diku.dk                         Klaus Ole Kristiansen
kogoma@triton.unm.edu                 Taki Kogoma
konrad@mace.cc.purdue.edu             Bill Konrad
kozlowsk@acs.ucalgary.ca              Don Kozlowski
kpaasial@cc.helsinki.fi               Kimmo T Paasiala
kreitzer@husc.harvard.edu             Joshua Kreitzer
ksackett@uahcs2.cs.uah.edu            Karl R. Sackett
kthompso@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov         Kevin Thompson
lampson@software.pulse.com            Dave Lampson
lau@ai.sri.com                        Stephen Lau
laura@catfish.ocpt.ccur.com           Laura Gillespie
lees@asf.com                          Lee Short
leet@acsu.buffalo.edu                 Brian D. Leet
leitm@essex.ac.uk                     Leith M F
leneis@cse.ogi.edu                    Tony Leneis
leonard@ssd.intel.com                 Leonard Bottleman
lgainor@panix.com                     Larry Gainor
librik@cory.berkeley.edu              David Librik
lindaas@cae.wisc.edu                  Bradley Lindaas
lindemul@cs.purdue.edu                Timothy Andrew Lindemulder
lisbon@vpnet.chi.il.us                Gerry Swetsky
ljones@cithe502.cithep.caltech.edu    Lawrence Jones
loren@leland.stanford.edu             Elina Aulikki Compton
lorenz@wu-wien.ac.at                  (Bernhard Lorenz)
louison@wfw.wtb.tue.nl                Louison Buijs
lucas@scicom.alphacdc.com             Kevin L. Lord
lundgren@polaris.unm.edu              Chad Lundgren
lytle@noao.edu                        Dyer Lytle
ma0dmr@ss1.bath.ac.uk                 
ma0dmr@ss1.bath.ac.uk                 Dan Reed
ma9tn@ss1.bath.ac.uk                  Tom Nettleship
magi@eng.umd.edu                      "John E. Krokes"
mason@finsen.chara.gsu.edu            Brian D. Mason
mastr@husc.harvard.edu                Claudia Mastroianni
matwood@peruvian.cs.utah.edu          Mark Atwood
maureen@lamar.colostate.edu           Lynn Bormann
maus@olias.linet.org                  
maverick@fir.cs.berkeley.edu          Vance Maverick
mbm@dsbc.icl.co.uk                    Malcolm Mladenovic
mcconnel@mcs.kent.edu                 Mike McConnell
mcglk@cpac.washington.edu             Ken McGlothlen
mcgregoa@cognos.com                   Alayne McGregor
mcmurry%orion.physics@ox.ac.uk        Andrew McMurry
meldal@fanaraaken.stanford.edu        Sigurd Meldal
meyers@alpha.ces.cwru.edu             Greg Meyers
mf23@umd5.umd.edu                     James B. Whitmore
mfey@cco.caltech.edu                  Mark P. Fey
mfreid@hkuxa.hku.hk                   Mike Reid
mhatz@nyx.cs.du.edu                   Mike Hatz
mhn@hpfcmhn.fc.hp.com                 Mark Notess
mho@stacken.kth.se                    Magnus Holmberg
microsoc@ox.ac.uk                     Nicholas McMurry
miked@phenos.physics.wisc.edu         Michael A. Doncheski
mikep@sequent.com                     Michael A. Prescott
minnotte@raven.math.usu.edu           Mike Minnotte
mj@wyvern.dfv.rwth-aachen.de          Martin Junius
mjm@hplb.hpl.hp.com                   Martin Merry
mjw@cck.coventry.ac.uk                Alien
mkelly@ovid.helios.nd.edu             michael kelly
mmunoz@vxcrna.cern.ch                 Marc Munoz
mnaka@john-whorfin.ics.uci.edu        Merri L Naka
moonman@camelot.bradley.edu           Craig Levin
morgoth@titan.ucs.umass.edu           Scott M. Rogala
mpope@itd.dsto.gov.au                 Michael Pope
msg@cse.iitb.ernet.in                 Milind Gandhe
msp@physique.ens.fr                   Michael Pettersen
msroark@silver.ucs.indiana.edu        michael roark
mss2@midway.uchicago.edu              "Michael S. Schiffer"
msuzio@tiamat.umd.umich.edu           Mike Suzio
mtaranto@panix.com                    Mark Taranto
mvoorhis@wpi.wpi.edu                  Michael C Voorhis
mworley@mathcs.emory.edu              Meg Worley
nadeau@bnr.ca                         "Rheal (R.J.) Nadeau"
nagjpw@vax.ox.ac.uk                   Jeremy Walton
norm@starfish.webo.dg.com             Norm Joslin
odgate!homebru!smith!dick@sunbird.central   
paist@cyclonic.sw.stratus.com         David Paist
paul@erc.msstate.edu                  Paul Adams
paul@oberon.econ.yale.edu             Paul McGuire
paulg@convex.csd.uwm.edu              Paul A Gunderson
pavalin@bnr.ca                        "Paul (P.A.) Valin"
pbhyc!djdaneh@ns.pacbell.com          Dan'l Danehy-Oakes
pelindb@utu.fi                        Petteri Lindberg
per@front.se                          "Per Lindberg"
peters@physics.ubc.ca                 Dan Peters
petervr@sci.kun.nl                    Peter van Rossum
pevans@sanjuan.uvic.ca                Patricia Evans
phaniraj@plains.nodak.edu             "V. Phaniraj"
phiber@eff.org                        Phiber Optik
phillips@syrinx.umd.edu               Felan shena Thoron'edras
phoenix@ugcs.caltech.edu              Damien R. Sullivan
phydeaux@guru.med.cornell.edu         Dave Weingart
pierpons@bones.et.byu.edu             Scott Pierpont
pjb4288@ultb.isc.rit.edu              Pete Boulay
plutchak@porter.geo.brown.edu         Joel Plutchak
pmfitzge@fitz.b30.ingr.com            Patrick Fitzgerald
polvinen@cc.helsinki.fi               Sari H Polvinen
ponds!squink.UUCP!biljir@dg-rtp.dg.com    Alan Beale
ppeltone@hkkk.fi                      Petri Peltonen
prauda@dol-guldur.hut.fi              Kristiina Prauda
prking@silver.cs.umanitoba.ca         Peter King
pv02@lehigh.edu                       Peter V. Vorobieff
pxs@dcs.ed.ac.uk                      Perdita Stevens
rabin@osf.org                         
rabin@osf.org                         rabin@osf.org
rachel@phsbbs.princeton.nj.us         Rachel Meredith Kadel
rcb3@win.tue.nl                       Olaf Weber
rene@iesd.auc.dk                      Rene Boe Soerensen
rev2@po.cwru.edu                      Robert E. Vogel
rezk@bourbaki.mit.edu                 Charles Rezk
rfd@po.cwru.edu                       Richard F. Drushel
rick@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu          Richard H. Miller
rka20423@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             Ruben Areyzaga
rkamal@ccs.carleton.ca                R Kamal
rlb@access.digex.com                  "Richard L. Butler"
rlcarr@animato.network23.com          Rich Carreiro
rleroux1@ra.uvic.ca                   Roger Leroux
rmg3@grebyn.com                       Robert Grumbine
rn.1558@rose.com                      Jo Churcher
rnichols@ihlpm.att.com                Bob Nichols
rnlee@sdcc3.ucsd.edu                  Roderick Lee
rnmg1200@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu             John W. Vargas
roberson@masc1.rice.edu               Kyle Ray Roberson
robh@cyberspace.org                   Robert Henderson
ronena@ccsg.tau.ac.il                 Ronen Altman
ronnie@cisco.com                      "Ronnie B. Kon"
roshne@faerun.mi.org                  Rod Shelton
rp04@lehigh.edu                       R M Price
rsquires@cyclops.eece.unm.edu         Roger Squires
rtbunker@princeton.edu                Ross Thomas Bunker
rwang@husc.harvard.edu                Richard Wang
s_latour@oz.plymouth.edu              Steven M. Latour
salome@leland.stanford.edu            Guinevere Marie Boostrom?
samw@bucket.rain.com                  Sam Warden
samw@bucket.rain.com                  Sam Warden
sandee@quake.think.com                Daan Sandee
schaller@hsi.com                      "Dave V. Schaller"
scruggs@gtewd.mtv.gsc.gte.com         BCFD #36
sears@cello.hpl.hp.com                Bart Sears
seurer+@rchland.ibm.com               Bill Seurer
sfd@soda.berkeley.edu                 Scott Drellishak
shimeall@taurus.cs.nps.navy.mil       timothy shimeall
siler@cs.utk.edu                      Vernon Siler
simpsong@dns0.bham.ac.uk              Glyn Simpson
sirowe@suncis.ycc.yale.edu            Si Rowe
sjm1@postoffice.mail.cornell.edu      Seth J. Morabito
sjsmith@cs.umd.edu                    Stephen Joseph Smith
slb22@cunixb.cc.columbia.edu          Seth Blumberg?
smacmanu@brahms.helios.nd.edu         stephen macmanus
smarry@zooid.guild.org                Marc Moorcroft
snabb@apu.fi                          Janne Snabb
soepstad@nora.gih.no                  lars soepstad
solovay@netcom.com                    Andrew Solovay
spenceb@ucunix.san.uc.edu             Brad A. Spencer
spm2d@topaz.cs.virginia.edu           Steven Miale?
spriyana@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu    Sahana Priyanath
sshriner@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu    Sara L Shriner
ssircar@canon.com                     Subrata Sircar
ssleong@csasoft.csam.my               
starhunter@cix.compulink.co.uk        Peter Boulter
steve@kittyhawk.ecn.uoknor.edu        Steve Coltrin
stssram@st.unocal.com                 Bob Myers
stu@valinor.mythical.com              Stu Labovitz
stuart@scs.leeds.ac.uk                S Butterfield
suo@cs.uwp.edu                        Franklin Suo
svasi@skinner.cs.uoregon.edu          Nathan Tenny
sven@cs.widener.edu                   "Sven M. Heinicke"
sward+@cmu.edu                        David Reeve Sward
swf@elsegundoca.ncr.com               Stan Friesen
szymon@uci.agh.edu.pl                 Szymon Sokol
t92etr@bellatrix.tdb.uu.se            Erik Trulsson
tamora@owlnet.rice.edu                Tami Dawn Kimmel
tdarcos@access.digex.com              Paul Robinson
tdober@simtow.netcom.com              Terri Oberkamper
thompson@cisco.com                    Elaine Thompson
tim@fiu.edu                           Timothy Walker
tittle@alexandre-dumas.ics.uci.edu    Cindy Tittle Moore
tkoelman@cs.vu.nl                     Tom Koelman
tmm@cs.brown.edu                      T. M. Murali
todd@alembic.com                      Todd Steigerwald
todd@alembic.com                      Todd Steigerwald
torpana@vinkku.hut.fi                 Tommi Orpana?
tredysvr!tredysvr!cnmss!mcl@gvls1.vfl.paramax.com   Michael C. Leap
trier@slc6.ins.cwru.edu               Stephen C. Trier
trodrigu@spock.ecs.umass.edu          Tao R or Stephen L
troyer@ips.id.ethz.ch                 
tsnow@bigbird.cs.ohiou.edu            Todd Snow
ttiittan@vinkku.hut.fi                Tero Tiittanen
twk@zycad.com                         Tom Kronmiller
tyg@valhalla.hq.ileaf.com             Tom Galloway
tyrone@minnie.cs.su.oz.au             Tyrone Jude Joseph O'Neill?
umgelter@azu.informatik.uni-stuttgart.de   Peter Umgelter?
uunet!atlantis!aaron                  Aaron Humphrey
uunet!decwrl!decvax!nj8j.blackwlf.mese.com!ben   Ben Coleman
uunet!impmh!dsg                       Dave Gordon
uunet!uflorida!sinkhole!junix!msmirl    Melinda Smirl
vernon@safe.ia.gov                    	Mark Vernon - DSB	
vjg@cbnews.att.com                    Vince Guinto
vk@aloft.att.com                      Vivek Kalra
wald@theory.lcs.mit.edu               David Wald
warninm@xanth.cs.orst.edu             Michael Warning
wbralick@afit.af.mil                  
wenzelm@informatik.tu-muenchen.de     Markus Wenzel
werner@soe.berkeley.edu               John Werner
wft@math.canterbury.ac.nz             
wmperry@blueberry.ucs.indiana.edu     "William M. Perry"
wwhitman@nevada.edu                   Michael Wise
xmed@vse.vse.cs                       Hynek Med
yyy2t@holmes.acc.virginia.edu         "Yvonne Y. Yang"
zeeshan@occs.cs.oberlin.edu           Zeeshan Hasan
zimmer@marvin.or.uni-bonn.de          Carsten Zimmer
zippy@berry.cs.brandeis.edu           Patrick Tufts
zkessin@chaos.cs.brandeis.edu         "Zach Kessin"
zorak@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                Scott E Flowers
-- 
Andrew Solovay    

"I am the Golux, the only Golux in the world, 
 and not a mere Device."

From solovay@netcom.com Mon Mar 29 20:40:42 1993
Path: uunet!bounce-back
From: solovay@netcom.com (Andrew Solovay)
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,alt.fan.tolkien,rec.arts.books,rec.arts.sf.written
Subject: RESULT: rec.arts.books.tolkien passes 488:109
Followup-To: news.groups
Date: 26 Mar 1993 11:09:01 -0500
Organization: 100 Aker Wood
Lines: 738
Sender: tale@rodan.UU.NET
Approved: tale@uunet.uu.net
Message-ID: <1ov9qtINNao8@rodan.UU.NET>
NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net
Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3388 news.groups:68547 alt.fan.tolkien:3506 rec.arts.books:62950 rec.arts.sf.written:22833

Voting has ended for the proposed unmoderated newsgroup
rec.arts.books.tolkien. The vote tally was 488 YES votes and 109 NO
votes, which is sufficient for newsgroup creation. Details follow.

This post consists of:
  A summary and explanation of the results
  An explanation of what happens next
  A repost of the group's charter
  A list of voters, divided into YES and NO, sorted by mailing address
  A list of invalid votes

RESULTS:

  In order for a newsgroup to be created, the YES votes must outnumber
  the NO votes by at least 2 to 1, and the number of YES votes must
  exceed the number of NO votes by at least 100.

  Number of valid YES votes received:	488
  Number of valid NO votes received:	109
  YES-NO vote difference:		379 (> 100)
  Ratio of YES to NO votes:		4.5 (> 2)

  This is adequate for newsgroup creation.

WHAT HAPPENS NEXT:

  The group will not be created immediately. The USENET group creation
  guidelines call for a 5-day waiting period after the results are
  posted, during which time people can raise any appropriate
  objections to the vote. 

  If no irregularities are found which would invalidate the vote, and
  if the margin of YES votes remains adequate for group creation, the
  moderator of news.announce.newgroups will send out a control message
  to create the newsgroup.

  The group will follow the charter which was posted in the CFV. A
  copy of that charter follows.

CHARTER:

  rec.arts.books.tolkien (hereinafter referred to as "The Group")
  would be a forum for discussion of all the works of Professor J.R.R.
  Tolkien (hereinafter "JRRT"). It would be open to discussion of his
  "Middle-earth" works, his scholarly writings, his essays and poetry,
  and all other works of JRRT (of whatever nature). The Group would be
  open to discussion at any level; for example, discussion of his
  "Middle-Earth" works could vary from literary criticism to
  philological discussion of the book's languages, or any other topic
  bearing on the works.

  The Group would also be open for discussion of works by other
  authors which relate to JRRT's work (including, but not limited to,
  scholarly criticism of his work, supplemental and speculative
  writings about his worlds, analyses of the various languages created
  by JRRT, and (of course) the elaborate historical material published
  by Christopher Tolkien). The group would be open to discussion about
  art works which are based on Tolkien's works (e.g. graphic
  depictions of scenes from his worlds, musical settings of his
  ballads and poetry).  The group would furthermore be open to
  discussion about JRRT the man, and how the circumstances of his life
  relate to his writing.

  The Group would be open to comparisons of Tolkien's works with those
  of other authors, e.g. comparing the influence of Christianity
  JRRT's writing with its influence on C.S. Lewis's works; comparing
  Sauron with Milton's Satan as a figure of evil; etc.  If such a
  discussion drifted into a discussion of the other author alone (and
  no longer touched on Tolkien), it would no longer be appropriate for
  the Group, and participants would be asked to move the discussion to
  a more appropriate newsgroup, or to EMail.

  Fan fiction would be permitted, provided that it did not violate
  anyone's rights or copyrights (especially the rights and copyrights
  of the Tolkien estate). Posters of fan fiction would be strongly
  encouraged to put the identifying word "FANFIC" in the "subject"
  line (to simplify kill-filing). Satire and parody of Tolkien's work
  would also be permitted. If the poster could reasonably expect
  readers to be offended by the posting, he or she should post it in
  rot-13 encryption (i.e. each letter is mapped to the letter 13
  places on in the alphabet, so that 'a' becomes 'n', 'b' becomes 'o',
  etc.).

  Willful and/or repeated spelling of JRRT's name as "Tolkein" would
  be punished by brutal sarcasm.

==========

LIST OF VOTERS:

  The voters are sorted by mailing address. If a voter's name ends with
  a question mark (e.g. "Suzy Cobol?") it means the mail did not have
  the user's full name, and I found the name out by fingering the
  account. 

YES votes (488)
===============

003166J@axe.acadiau.ca                     
A.J.Harlow@city.ac.uk                      A. J. Harlow
ALC110@psuvm.psu.edu                       
ALI00BAW@unccvm.uncc.edu                   Bruce Alan Wilson
BDUVAL%WVNVM.BITNET@vtvm2.cc.vt.edu        "Robert D. Duval"
BSCHLESINGER@nssdca.gsfc.nasa.gov          Barry Schlesinger
Brian.Ewald@math.lsa.umich.edu             Brian Ewald
CMARBLE@hmcvax.claremont.edu               Chris Marble
D <KBOOTH@eagle.wesleyan.edu>              Katherine P. Booth?
D.T.Shield@compsci.liverpool.ac.uk         Dave Shield
D.W.Wright@bnr.co.uk                       David Wright
DAVEL%EARLHAM.BITNET@uicvm.uic.edu         
DAVID@master.uchicago.edu                  David Hardin
DTRIPLETT@loyola.edu                       Dan Triplett
Dave_Wyble.wbst147@xerox.com               Dave Wyble
David.Empson@bbs.actrix.gen.nz             David Empson
GRAJEK@yalevm.ycc.yale.edu                 Susan Grajek
HSKINNER@ren.ir.miami.edu                  Halcyon Skinner
Hector.Cancela@irisa.fr                    Hector Cancela
Herbert.Leitz@physik.uni-muenchen.de       Herbert Leitz
IK20001@maine.maine.edu                    Eric Alfred Burns
IO20816@maine.maine.edu                    Kevin Foss
ISTS015@uabdpo.dpo.uab.edu                 Elaine Tindill
J.W.Baxter@durham.ac.uk                    "J.W.Baxter"
JDPURNELL@sae.towson.edu                   David Purnell
JKRAMER@eagle.wesleyan.edu                 Jeanne R. Kramer?
JMAENPAA@cc.helsinki.fi                    "Juha M{enp{{, puh. 508 5291"
JVINCENT@eagle.wesleyan.edu                Tawil at'Umr
JXD132@psuvm.psu.edu                       "James L. Durrell"
John_Jenkins@taligent.com                  John Jenkins
Juhani.Polvinen@fmi.fi                     Juhani Polvinen
KELSEY@slacvm.slac.stanford.edu            "KELSEY, Michael H."
Kay.Shapero@f524.n102.z1.fidonet.org       Kay Shapero
LEFF@tdcsys2.vnet.ibm.com                  "Avraham Leff (1-914-435-5124)"
MCCROSKEYED%DFP@pcmail.usafa.af.mil        Erick D. Mccroskey
MCSPIKTA@cluster.cc.dundee-tech.ac.uk      Kenny Armstrong
MECE23J@jetson.uh.edu                      Mats O. Orrhede
MGL4@psuvm.psu.edu                         Michael G. LeSeney
MILLERL@wilma.wharton.upenn.edu            "Loren J. Miller"
MJQUINN@pucc.princeton.edu                 Michael Quinn
Michael.Norrish@comp.vuw.ac.nz             Michael Norrish
Michael.P.Colburn@dartmouth.edu            Michael P. Colburn
NOVOTNYP%CSEARN.BITNET@helios.edvz.univie.ac.at   Petr Novotny
PATRICKC@cc.usu.edu                        Patrick S. Clark
PRRONAN@chemical.watstar.uwaterloo.ca      Patrick Robert Ronan
RAJAKANGAS@cc.helsinki.fi                  Anna-Maija Rajakangas
S.L.Fagg@bnr.co.uk                         Steve Fagg
SPROLES@pine.circa.ufl.edu                 "SPROLES"
Stefan.Blixten.Karlsson@lu.erisoft.se      Stefan -Blixten- Karlsson
TZBARASC@ucs.indiana.edu                   Tony Zbaraschuk
USER2E9P@um.cc.umich.edu                   
Undergraduate.Math.Club@um.cc.umich.edu    
Wayne.G.Hammond@williams.edu               Wayne Hammond Jr
Wilson.M.Clements@dartmouth.edu            Wilson M. Clements
a70860@uwasa.fi                            Carl Patrik Andila
abw@crsa.bu.edu                            Al Wesolowsky
ac544@freenet.carleton.ca                  Michael MacKay
ache@astral.msk.su                         "Andrew A. Chernov, Black Mage"
achille@nemo.greco-prog.fr                 Jean-Pierre BRAQUELAIRE
acw@apple.com                              Art Willis
admiral@jhunix.hcf.jhu.edu                 Steve C Liu
ag@sics.se                                 Anders G|ransson?
ajg0@aberystwyth.ac.uk                     
al147841@academ01.mty.itesm.mx             Fermin Revueltas Rodriguez
al157961@academ07.mty.itesm.mx             "Fernando Careaga S."
al158305@academ03.mty.itesm.mx             Gustavo Cordova Avila
alan@alan.b30.ingr.com                     Alan Barksdale
alex@mrc-lmb.cam.ac.uk                     Alex Knight
alg@cs.cornell.edu                         Anne Louise Gockel
allen@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov                 John Allen
amc@wucs1.wustl.edu                        Adam Costello
anderson@alexia.lis.uiuc.edu               Chris Anderson
andy@cs.rhbnc.ac.uk                        Andy Thomas
andy@pic.melco.co.jp                       
annye@netcom.com                           Annye Scherer
apm@kikka.hut.fi                           Antti Miettinen
arielle@neosoft.com                        Stephanie da Silva
arm16@cus.cam.ac.uk                        A.R. Minns
arthurc@sfsuvax1.sfsu.edu                  Arthur Chandler
atkinson@tengwar.itd.nrl.navy.mil          Ran Atkinson
bailey@utpapa.ph.utexas.edu                Ed Bailey
bards_n@cs.odu.edu                         Nathan Bardsley
beast@netcom.com                           J. Kintscher
bell@aussie.enet.dec.com                   Peter Bell
bengtl@maths.lth.se                        Bengt Larsson
bergland@edb.uib.no                        Magne Bergland
biff@biff.jpunix.com                       Dwight Everhart
blanford@spf.trw.com                       Ronald P. Blanford
bls101@deakin.anu.edu.au                   Barbara La Scala
bond@nttkb.ntt.jp                          Francis Bond
boon@uow.edu.au                            Boon Chye Lee
bouillon@cs.uni-sb.de                      Peter G. Bouillon
bouvin@daimi.aau.dk                        Niels Olof Bouvin
bram@fangorn.hacktic.nl                    Bram Smits
brocka@ucs.orst.edu                        Anthony Brock
brown@ncoast.org                           Stan Brown
btree!cjohn@ucsd.edu                       John C. Ruff
burnett@gummo.cse.ogi.edu                  Dan Burnett
c60a-ir@danube.berkeley.edu                Max Hsieh
cabfi01@mailserv.zdv.uni-tuebingen.de      Paul Fisahn
cac@space.mit.edu                          Charlie Collins
capitol!thomas@uunet.uu.net                Mark Thomas
cargo@cherry.cray.com                      David S. Cargo
carl@class.gsfc.nasa.gov                   Carl F. Hostetter
carney@igor.rational.com                   Mike Carney
castle@ug.cs.dal.ca                        JULIAN GUTHRIE CASTLE
cbkfr01@mailserv.zdv.uni-tuebingen.de      Kai-Uwe Froehlich
ccastjl@prism.gatech.edu                   John Lindsey
cffitzge@iastate.edu                       Charles F. Fitzgerald
cfgcs@ux1.cts.eiu.edu                      Grant C. Sterling
cgk26737@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu                  C G Kolar
charest@aig.jpl.nasa.gov                   Len Charest
chh9@midway.uchicago.edu                   "Conrad Halling"
chris@porsche.visix.com                    Chris Cole
chrise@srlr13.sr.hp.com                    Chris Eich
chs1pm@surrey.ac.uk                        Dr Paul J Mitchell
chute@mayo.edu                             C G Chute
citrus!mld@csusac.ecs.csus.edu              Matt Deter 
cld@wucs1.wustl.edu                        Christopher L. Davis
cmp0118@information-systems.east-anglia.ac.uk   "S." Green
connersb@cae.wisc.edu                      Brian Patrick Conners?
councill@levy.bard.edu                     John Councill
count@mdata.fi                             Bror Heinola
cpresson@jido.b30.ingr.com                 Craig Presson
craigb@sdd.hp.com                          Craig Bosworth
creps@nickel.ucs.indiana.edu               "Stephen A. Creps"
crosby@caesar.cs.colorado.edu              Matthew Crosby
cstracha@casper.cs.uct.ac.za               Craig Strachan
curtw@euler.jsc.nasa.gov                   Curt Wiederhoeft
cwes1@cs.aukuni.ac.nz                      
d1pihlan@dtek.chalmers.se                  Fredrik Pihlstr|m
d88hanpe@und.ida.liu.se                    Hans Persson
d90-flu@nada.kth.se                        Frederick Lundberg?
d90-joh@nada.kth.se                        Jan-Erik 2hman?
d90-two@nada.kth.se                        Thomas Wolmer
danco@leland.stanford.edu                  Daniel Hollander Colman
darsys@pro-entropy.cts.com                 Eric A. Seiden
dasher@well.sf.ca.us                       D Anton Sherwood
dasmith@husc.harvard.edu                   David A. Smith
dassen@sthp.wi.leidenuniv.nl               J.H.M. Dassen
dave@rincon.ema.rockwell.com               Dave Emde
dave@shark.smartstar.com                   David Schwartz
dave@twg.com                               "David E. Boyce"
david@albertina.inesc.pt                   David M. M. de Matos
davisr@cs.ucdavis.edu                      Robert Davis
dcl@ncsc5.att.com                          
dean2@bigbird.csd.scarolina.edu            Dean Pentcheff
deroo@eecs.umich.edu                       Roger DeRoo
dfaulkne@uafhp.uark.edu                    Don Faulkner
dgk4@po.cwru.edu                           David G. Kahane
dhamilto@gssec.bt.co.uk                    David Hamilton
disserli@us.oracle.com                     "Debra Isserlis"
djb6@midway.uchicago.edu                   "Dennis Brennan"
djohnson@willamette.edu                    Dane Johnson
djweisbe@unix.amherst.edu                  David Weisberger
dko@cs.wisc.edu                            David Olsen
dmize@bluemoon.use.com                     Dave Mize
dmk8r@birch.cs.virginia.edu                Darrell M. Kienzle?
dmsilev@athena.mit.edu                     Daniel Silevitch
dnh@mfltd.co.uk                            Des Herriott
dpn2@po.cwru.edu                           Damien P. Neil
dricki@rpi.edu                             Ilya Grigorievich Dricker?
dscheets@hpdmd48.boi.hp.com                dave scheets
dspalme@mke.ab.com                         Diane Palme x2617
dt4%cs@hub.ucsb.edu                        David E. Goggin
dunphy@sparc0a.cs.uiuc.edu                 Michael Dunphy
dwiseman@erim.org                          Dave Wiseman
dzik@access.digex.com                      Joseph Dzikiewicz
ebner@informatik.tu-muenchen.de            Ralf Ebner
eckman@eos1.larc.nasa.gov                  Richard Eckman
edh@staff.tc.umn.edu                       Eric D. Henderson
edsr!jat@uunet.uu.net                      Jon A. Turner
elendil@mintir.new-orleans.la.us           Edward J. Branley
elentar@camelot.bradley.edu                Michael Carman
eliaz@techunix.technion.ac.il              Amir Eliaz
en2prmm@ss1.bath.ac.uk                     P R Martell-Mead
eoberle@leland.stanford.edu                Eric Oberle
eoq@vthnw.cvm.msu.edu                      Edward Quillen
er@iscp.bellcore.com                       Elie Rosenfeld
erick@engin.umich.edu                      erick  alvarado
erwvegm@cs.vu.nl                           Erwin van Egmond
esi104@cch.coventry.ac.uk                  Jo
esri!esrican!scarlett@uunet.uu.net         Brian Scarlett
eugene_rick@macmail1.csg.mot.com           Rick M. Eugene
eyhung@garnet.berkeley.edu                 Eugene Hung
fath@mbcrr.harvard.edu                     Michael Fath
fehr@ms.uky.edu                            Jeff Davis
fingon@archtwr.tower.nullnet.fi            Markus Stenberg
fischer@iesd.auc.dk                        Lars Peter Fischer
fischer@mermaid.micro.umn.edu              Scott W Fischer
fishe@casbah.acns.nwu.edu                  Carwil James
fls@keynes.econ.duke.edu                   Forrest Smith
follick@jemez.eece.unm.edu                 Jeremy Follick
folta@cs.umd.edu                           Wayne Folta
forb0004@student.tc.umn.edu                "Eric J Forbis-1"
futor@llnl.gov                             Randall J. Futor?
galahad@leland.stanford.edu                Scott Compton
gauecs@elara.fnma.com                      Eileen Scott
genetic+@pitt.edu                          David M. Tate
ggurman@cory.berkeley.edu                  Gail Gurman
ggw@wolves.durham.nc.us                    Gregory G. Woodbury
gix@mdd.comm.mot.com                       Brian Gix
goolsbey@cs.utexas.edu                     Keith Goolsbey
gorgen@ann-arbor.applicon.slb.com          David Gorgen
gottscha@ibr.cs.tu-bs.de                   Thomas Gottschalk
gptrenow@teaching.cs.adelaide.edu.au       GP TRENOWDEN
gradient!rogerc@uunet.uu.net               
griggs@kenyon.edu                          "Ron Griggs, ICS, x5632"
gt0644c@prism.gatech.edu                   Scott Gust
gt5052b@prism.gatech.edu                   SADUN, ERICA LIEBMAN
gt7691c@prism.gatech.edu                   Jay Lofstead
guenther@stolaf.edu                        "Philip Guenther"
gumby@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                     David Brian Gumminger
hagar@tpki.toppoint.de                     Oliver Fink
hall3@husc.harvard.edu                     Timothy "Cage" Hall
hamerb@casbah.acns.nwu.edu                 Barbara Hamer
hanoune@ensisun.imag.fr                    Pierre
hansm@info.win.tue.nl                      Hans Mulder
harper!rmartine@uunet.uu.net               Rick Martinez
hatakka@cc.helsinki.fi                     Yrjo Hatakka
hayter@ramsesii.ultryx.com                 Jim Hayter
hdupless@stellenbos.csir.co.za             Heinrich Du Plessis
heinau@chemie.fu-berlin.de                 Vera Heinau
helgek@ifi.uib.no                          Stud Helge Kvingedal
herbison@lassie.enet.dec.com               B.J.  03-Mar-1993 1622
hid009@cent1.lancs.ac.uk                   James Masterton
hinshaw@vsopz3.cern.ch                     Dean Hinshaw
hiscdcj@lux.latrobe.edu.au                 Jones-evans Dwayne C
hkhenson@cup.portal.com                    Keith Henson
holly@kauri.vuw.ac.nz                      RH Schone
hooverb@cs.wvu.wvnet.edu                   Bruce Hoover
huff@mcclb0.med.nyu.edu                    Edward J. Huff
iba@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov                   Wayne Iba
ibmpa!squirrel.austin.ibm.com!chesky@ibminet.awdpa.ibm.com    Bill Chesky
ihabed@unccvx.uncc.edu                     
j_herlih@oz.plymouth.edu                   Jay A. Herlihy?
jacob@ipc1.rvs.uni-hannover.de             Ruediger Jacob
jamie@cs.sfu.ca                            Jamie Andrews
jan@lyr.dhmolde.no                         Jan Ove Liatun
jbaxter@leland.stanford.edu                Joel Kent Baxter
jbjorklu@aton.abo.fi                       Joakim Bj|rklund INF
jbuckley@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu         James Buckley
jbum@netcom.com                            James Bumgardner
jburgess@netcom.com                        Jon Burgess
jc@slim.gmd.de                             Juergen Christoffel
jcb@dcs.ed.ac.uk                           Julian Bradfield
jchokey@leland.stanford.edu                James Alexander Chokey
jclander@maestro.mitre.org                 Julian C. Lander
jclarke@csn.org                            J Christopher Clarke
jdh34098@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu                  "John D. Harper"
jenski@cae.wisc.edu                        Anders Jenski
jep1@cec2.wustl.edu                        Jason Edward Purcell
jfarrell@morgan.ucs.mun.ca                 James Farrell
jfurr@nyx.cs.du.edu                        Joel Furr
jgn@ukc.ac.uk                              
jgostin@eternal.chi.il.us                  Jeff Gostin
jhawk@panix.com                            John Hawkinson
jhi@vinkku.hut.fi                          Jarkko Hietaniemi
jhunter@willamette.edu                     Jason Hunter
jim@mycroft.rand.org                       Jim Gillogly
jimbo@math.psu.edu                         Jim Humphreys
jimk@engin.umich.edu                       
jjonsson@alexandria.lib.utah.edu           Jeffrey Jonsson
jkellett@netcom.com                        Joe Kellett
jks2j@faraday.clas.virginia.edu            Skip Sizemore
jmann@vineland.pubs.stratus.com            Jim Mann
jms@tardis.tymnet.com                      Joe Smith
jmw-b@minster.york.ac.uk                   
jodi@ftp.com                               Jodi Riley
joern@ifi.uio.no                           J|rn Hagerup
john@iastate.edu                           John Hascall?
jonas@beor.informatik.rwth-aachen.de       Josef Nelissen
jordanna@leland.stanford.edu               Jordanna Bailkin
jreese@sablon.ics.uci.edu                  Jon Damon Reese
jrr@oolong.la.locus.com                    Jefery Roberts
julliard@di.epfl.ch                        "(Alexandre Julliard)"
jute@sday.pulp.nullnet.fi                  Jussi Kantola
jw@eng.ufl.edu                             "John White"
jwhitney@seas.smu.edu                      John Whitney
jxh@unixhub.slac.stanford.edu              John Halperin
kaig@ccmail.odh.no                         Kai Gjessing
kardaras@ecn.purdue.edu                    George S Kardaras
karyn@cheetah.llnl.gov                     Karyn Pichnarczyk
kcj@apd.net.com                            Keith Jakobs
kelsey@unixhub.slac.stanford.edu           Michael Kelsey
kenw%bilbo@ihs.com                         Ken Weinert
keoghs@dabuh.demon.co.uk                   Sean Mathew Keogh
kgush@cs1.uct.ac.za                        Kim L Gush
klaus@diku.dk                              Klaus Ole Kristiansen
koc5@midway.uchicago.edu                   "michael shalom kochin"
konrad@mace.cc.purdue.edu                  Bill Konrad
kozlowsk@acs.ucalgary.ca                   Don Kozlowski
kpaasial@cc.helsinki.fi                    Kimmo T Paasiala
kreitzer@husc.harvard.edu                  Joshua Kreitzer
ksackett@uahcs2.cs.uah.edu 		   Karl R. Sackett)
kthompso@ptolemy.arc.nasa.gov              Kevin Thompson
kzimmer@leland.stanford.edu                Kristin L Zimmerman
lampson@software.pulse.com                 Dave Lampson
laura@catfish.ocpt.ccur.com                Laura Gillespie
lbug@toeplitz.ee.cornell.edu               James Michael Lebak
leefbern@acpub.duke.edu                    Lee Bernhard
lees@asf.com                               Lee Short
leet@acsu.buffalo.edu                      Brian D. Leet
leitm@essex.ac.uk                          Leith M F
leneis@cse.ogi.edu                         Tony Leneis
leonard@ssd.intel.com                      Leonard Bottleman
librik@cory.berkeley.edu                   David Librik
lindaas@cae.wisc.edu                       Bradley Lindaas
lindemul@cs.purdue.edu                     Timothy Andrew Lindemulder
ljones@cithe502.cithep.caltech.edu         Lawrence Jones
loren@leland.stanford.edu                  Elina Aulikki Compton
lorenz@wu-wien.ac.at                       (Bernhard Lorenz)
louison@wfw.wtb.tue.nl                     Louison Buijs
lucas@scicom.alphacdc.com                  Mithrandir
lundgren@polaris.unm.edu                   Chad Lundgren
lytle@noao.edu                             Dyer Lytle
ma0dmr@ss1.bath.ac.uk                      
ma9tn@ss1.bath.ac.uk                       Tom Nettleship
markc@vnet.ibm.com                         Mark Connell
mason@finsen.chara.gsu.edu                 Brian D. Mason
mastr@husc.harvard.edu                     Claudia Mastroianni
matwood@peruvian.cs.utah.edu               Mark Atwood
maureen@lamar.colostate.edu                Lynn Bormann
maus@olias.linet.org                       
mbm@dsbc.icl.co.uk                         Malcolm Mladenovic
mcconnel@mcs.kent.edu                      Mike McConnell
mcglk@cpac.washington.edu                  Ken McGlothlen
mcmurry%orion.physics@ox.ac.uk             Andrew McMurry
meyers@alpha.ces.cwru.edu                  Greg Meyers
mfey@cco.caltech.edu                       Mark P. Fey
mforget@elfhaven.ersys.edmonton.ab.ca      Michel Forget
mfreid@hkuxa.hku.hk                        Mike Reid
mhatz@nyx.cs.du.edu                        Mike Hatz
mhn@hpfcmhn.fc.hp.com                      Mark Notess
mho@stacken.kth.se                         Magnus Holmberg
micky@marie.physik.tu-berlin.de            Michael Patra
microsoc@ox.ac.uk                          Nicholas McMurray
miked@phenos.physics.wisc.edu              Michael A. Doncheski
mikep@sequent.com                          Michael A. Prescott
mj@wyvern.dfv.rwth-aachen.de               Martin Junius
mjm@hplb.hpl.hp.com                        Martin Merry
mjw@cck.coventry.ac.uk                     Alien
mkelly@ovid.helios.nd.edu                  michael kelly
mmunoz@vxcrna.cern.ch                      Marc Munoz
mnaka@john-whorfin.ics.uci.edu             Merri L Naka
moonman@camelot.bradley.edu                Craig Levin
morgoth@titan.ucs.umass.edu                Scott M. Rogala
mpope@itd.dsto.gov.au                      Michael Pope
msg@cse.iitb.ernet.in                      Milind Gandhe
msp@physique.ens.fr                        PETTERSEN Mike
msroark@silver.ucs.indiana.edu             michael roark
mss2@midway.uchicago.edu                   "Michael S. Schiffer"
msuzio@tiamat.umd.umich.edu                Mike Suzio
mvoorhis@wpi.wpi.edu                       Michael C Voorhis
nadeau@bnr.ca                              "Rheal (R.J.) Nadeau"
nagjpw@vax.ox.ac.uk                        Jeremy Walton
nobby@u.washington.edu                     Vitaly Shmatikov
norm@starfish.webo.dg.com                  Norm Joslin
okamoto@cs.stanford.edu                    Yoshinori Okamoto
paist@cyclonic.sw.stratus.com              David Paist
paul@erc.msstate.edu                       Paul Adams
paulg@convex.csd.uwm.edu                   Paul A Gunderson
pavalin@bnr.ca                             "Paul (P.A.) Valin"
pbhyc!djdaneh@ns.pacbell.com               Dan'l Danehy-Oakes
peder@hpubgon.norway.hp.com                Peder Langlo
pelindb@utu.fi                             Petteri Lindberg
per@front.se                               "Per Lindberg"
peters@physics.ubc.ca                      Dan Peters
petervr@sci.kun.nl                         Peter van Rossum
pevans@sanjuan.uvic.ca                     Patricia Evans
phaniraj@plains.nodak.edu                  "V. Phaniraj"
phiber@eff.org                             Phiber Optik
phoenix@ugcs.caltech.edu                   Damien R. Sullivan
phydeaux@guru.med.cornell.edu              Dave Weingart
pierpons@bones.et.byu.edu                  Scott Pierpont
pjb4288@ultb.isc.rit.edu                   Peter Boulay
pmfitzge@fitz.b30.ingr.com                 Patrick Fitzgerald
polvinen@cc.helsinki.fi                    Sari H Polvinen
ponds!squink.UUCP!biljir@dg-rtp.dg.com     Alan Beale
ppeltone@hkkk.fi                           Petri Peltonen
prauda@dol-guldur.hut.fi                   Kristiina Prauda
prking@silver.cs.umanitoba.ca              Peter King
pv02@lehigh.edu                            Peter V. Vorobieff
pxs@dcs.ed.ac.uk                           Perdita Stevens
quelch@hartree.chem.wfu.edu                Geoffrey E. Quelch
rabin@cs.yale.edu                          Daniel E. Rabin
rabin@osf.org                              Paul Rabin
rachel@phsbbs.princeton.nj.us              Rachel Meredith Kadel
rcb3@win.tue.nl                            Olaf Weber
rene@iesd.auc.dk                           Rene Boe Soerensen
rev2@po.cwru.edu                           Robert E. Vogel
rezk@bourbaki.mit.edu                      Charles Rezk
rfd@po.cwru.edu                            Richard F. Drushel
rka20423@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu                  Ruben Areyzaga
rkamal@ccs.carleton.ca                     R Kamal
rlcarr@animato.network23.com               Rich Carreiro
rleroux1@ra.uvic.ca                        Roger Leroux
rlt@cbnewsl.att.com                        Roberta L Taylor
rn.1558@rose.com                           Jo Churcher
rnichols@ihlpm.att.com                     Bob Nichols
rnlee@sdcc3.ucsd.edu                       Roderick Lee
rnmg1200@uxa.cso.uiuc.edu                  John W. Vargas
roberson@masc1.rice.edu                    Kyle Ray Roberson
robh@cyberspace.org                        Robert Henderson
ronena@ccsg.tau.ac.il                      Ronen Altman
ronnie@cisco.com                           "Ronnie B. Kon"
roshne@faerun.mi.org                       Rod Shelton
rsquires@cyclops.eece.unm.edu              Roger Squires
rtbunker@princeton.edu                     Ross Thomas Bunker
rwang@husc.harvard.edu                     Richard Wang
s_latour@oz.plymouth.edu                   Steven M. Latour
salome@leland.stanford.edu                 Guinevere Marie Boostrom?
samw@bucket.rain.com                       Sam Warden
sandee@quake.think.com                     Daan Sandee
schitre@netcom.com                         Sunil Chitre
scruggs@gtewd.mtv.gsc.gte.com              BCFD #36
seurer+@rchland.ibm.com                    Bill Seurer
sfd@soda.berkeley.edu                      Scott Drellishak
sgerbig@silver.ucs.indiana.edu             Stan M Gerbig
shimeall@taurus.cs.nps.navy.mil            timothy shimeall
shimkus@athena.cs.uga.edu                  Doc
siler@cs.utk.edu                           Vernon Siler
simon@fsinfo.cs.uni-sb.de                  "Julia Simon"
simpsong@dns0.bham.ac.uk                   Glyn Simpson
sirowe@suncis.ycc.yale.edu                 Si Rowe
sjm1@postoffice.mail.cornell.edu           Seth J. Morabito
sjsmith@cs.umd.edu                         Stephen Joseph Smith
slb22@cunixb.cc.columbia.edu               Seth L. Blumberg?
smacmanu@brahms.helios.nd.edu              stephen macmanus
snabb@apu.fi                               Janne Snabb
soepstad@nora.gih.no                       lars soepstad
solovay@netcom.com                         Andrew Solovay
spenceb@ucunix.san.uc.edu                  Brad A. Spencer
spm2d@topaz.cs.virginia.edu                Steven Miale?
spriyana@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu         Sahana Priyanath
sshriner@magnus.acs.ohio-state.edu         Sara L Shriner
ssleong@csasoft.csam.my                    
starhunter@cix.compulink.co.uk             Peter Boulter
steve@kittyhawk.ecn.uoknor.edu             Steve Coltrin
stssram@st.unocal.com                      Bob Myers
stu1016@discover.wright.edu                Chris Thompson
stu@valinor.mythical.com                   Stu Labovitz
stuart@scs.leeds.ac.uk                     S Butterfield
suo@cs.uwp.edu                             Franklin Suo
svasi@skinner.cs.uoregon.edu               Nathan Tenny
sward+@cmu.edu                             David Reeve Sward
swildner@channelz.gun.de                   Sascha Wildner
szymon@uci.agh.edu.pl                      Szymon Sokol
t92etr@bellatrix.tdb.uu.se                 Erik Trulsson
tamora@owlnet.rice.edu                     Tami Dawn Kimmel
tdober@simtow.netcom.com                   Terri Oberkamper
terry@edsi.plexus.com                      Terry Dawson
tim@fiu.edu                                Timothy Walker
tittle@alexandre-dumas.ics.uci.edu         Cindy Tittle Moore
tkoelman@cs.vu.nl                          Tom Koelman
tmm@cs.brown.edu                           T. M. Murali
todd@alembic.com                           Todd Steigerwald
torpana@vinkku.hut.fi                      Tommi Orpana?
tp913363@fir.canberra.edu.au               Richard Wise
tredysvr!tredysvr!cnmss!mcl@gvls1.vfl.paramax.com   Michael C. Leap
trodrigu@spock.ecs.umass.edu               Tao R or Stephen L
troyer@ips.id.ethz.ch                      
tsnow@bigbird.cs.ohiou.edu                 Todd Snow
ttiittan@vinkku.hut.fi                     Tero Tiittanen
twk@zycad.com                              Tom Kronmiller
tyers@acs.ucalgary.ca                      Bruce Tyers
tyrone@minnie.cs.su.oz.au                  Tyrone Jude Joseph ONeill?
umgelter@azu.informatik.uni-stuttgart.de   Peter Umgelter?
uunet!MeMyAm!meggers                       Markus Eggers
uunet!atlantis!aaron                       Aaron Humphrey
uunet!decwrl!decvax!gatech!nj8j.blackwlf.mese.com!ben    Ben Coleman
uunet!decwrl!decvax!nj8j.blackwlf.mese.com!ben   Ben Coleman
uunet!impmh!dsg                            Dave Gordon
uunet!uflorida!sinkhole!junix!msmirl       Melinda Smirl
vernon@safe.ia.gov                         	Mark Vernon - DSB	
voeckler@ipc1.rvs.uni-hannover.de          Jens-S. Voeckler
wanagin@kingkong.escape.de                 Ulf Bahrenfuss
wbralick@afit.af.mil                       
wenzelm@informatik.tu-muenchen.de          Markus Wenzel
wft@math.canterbury.ac.nz                  Bill Taylor?
willis@ensibull.imag.fr                    Didier Willis
wmperry@blueberry.ucs.indiana.edu          "William M. Perry"
xmed@vse.vse.cs                            Kynek Med
yyy2t@holmes.acc.virginia.edu              "Yvonne Y. Yang"
zeeshan@occs.cs.oberlin.edu                Zeeshan Hasan
zeolis@elvis.ds.boeing.com                 Sherrie Zeoli
zimmer@marvin.or.uni-bonn.de               Carsten Zimmer
zkessin@chaos.cs.brandeis.edu              "Zach Kessin"

NO votes (109)
==============

DEMON@desire.wright.edu                    
FNCLL@acad3.alaska.edu                     Christopher L. Lott
FSSPR@acad3.alaska.edu                     
JLM@slacvm.slac.stanford.edu               Jose Martinez?
MORROW@fnal.fnal.gov                       Greg Morrow
OTTO@vaxb.acs.unt.edu                      "M. Otto"
RIAWELCH@ubvmsb.cc.buffalo.edu             Mad City Blues
SODONNELL@umassd.edu                       
TOHALL@ariel.lerc.nasa.gov                 
U48073@uicvm.uic.edu                       "Cole Kendall"
UD172440@vm1.nodak.edu                     Jeffrey Johnson?
a_rubin@dsg4.dse.beckman.com               Arthur Rubin
akiy@cs.titech.ac.jp                       Jun Akiyama
al198723@academ01.mty.itesm.mx             Jesus Eugenio S nchez Pe~a
amberle@staff.tc.umn.edu                   Amberle Ferrian
andy@vistachrome.com                       Andrew Finkenstadt
ap1i+@andrew.cmu.edu                       "Andrew C. Plotkin"
barr@pop.psu.edu                           David Barr
brian@audiofax.com                         Brian TroxeLL
bson@gnu.ai.mit.edu                        Jan Brittenson
burt+@cmu.edu                              Burt N Holzman
caplan@barrier.island.com                  Rob Caplan
carr@acsu.buffalo.edu                      Dave Carr
chancock@igc.apc.org                       Charlie Hancock
charles%trintex@uunet.uu.net               Charles Emmons
ckd@eff.org                                Christopher Davis
crispops@world.std.com                     Dale A Smoak
culliton@srg.srg.af.mil                    Tom Culliton x2278
davei@wam.umd.edu                          The One True Dave
davidf@xenitec.on.ca                       David Fiander
dmosher@nyx.cs.du.edu                      David Mosher
durrell@chop.isca.uiowa.edu                Bryant Durrell
eab@msc.edu                                Edward Bertsch
edb@fairport.hq.ileaf.com                  Ed Blachman x4420
ejo@kaja.gi.alaska.edu                     "Eric J. Olson"
emcguire@intellection.com                  Ed McGuire
emma@russell.stanford.edu                  Emma Pease
exuhag@exu.ericsson.se                     James Hague
fzimmerm@erim.org                          Fred Zimmerman
garrett@cs.rochester.edu                   Bill Garrett
geoffb@coos.dartmouth.edu                  Geoff Bronner
graham@cs.washington.edu                   Stephen Graham
gulla@pvv.unit.no                          Anders H}kon Gulla
hades@coos.dartmouth.edu                   Brian Hughes
hansenr@ohsu.edu                           Robert Hansen
heidi@casey.net.com                        Heidi Wolf
hollasch@kpc.com                           Steve Hollasch
ig25@rz.uni-karlsruhe.de                   Thomas Koenig
jan@bagend.atl.ga.us                       Jan Isley
jc@crosfield.co.uk                         jerry cullingford
jduncan@prism.nmt.edu                      John Duncan
jeff@casbah.acns.nwu.edu                   Jeff Williamson
jf41+@andrew.cmu.edu                       "Jonathan R. Ferro"
jhopkins@cbacc.cba.uga.edu                 John Hopkins
jjh00@diag.amdahl.com                      Joel Hanes
jmaynard@nyx.cs.du.edu                     Jay Maynard
jmck@norge.eng.sun.com                     John McKernan
jsax@igc.apc.org                           Joel Sax
jspencer@world.std.com                     Jeffrey C Spencer
jvh@mdata.fi                               Jussi-Ville Heiskanen
kaltef@theo-physik.uni-kiel.dbp.de         Roland Kaltefleiter
kamorgan@athena.mit.edu                    Keith Morgan?
kasprj@rpi.edu                             Jim Kasprzak?
kenney@saturn.hsi.com                      Brian Kenney
kogoma@triton.unm.edu                      Taki Kogoma
lau@ai.sri.com                             Stephen Lau
lgainor@panix.com                          Larry Gainor
lisbon@vpnet.chi.il.us                     Gerry Swetsky
magi@eng.umd.edu                           "John E. Krokes"
markm@netcom.com                           Mark Mavroudis
maverick@fir.cs.berkeley.edu               Vance Maverick
mcgregoa@cognos.com                        Alayne McGregor
meldal@fanaraaken.stanford.edu             Sigurd Meldal
mf23@umd5.umd.edu                          James B. Whitmore
minnotte@raven.math.usu.edu                Mike Minnotte
mtaranto@panix.com                         Mark Taranto
mworley@mathcs.emory.edu                   Meg Worley
odgate!homebru!smith!dick@sunbird.central   
paul@oberon.econ.yale.edu                  Paul McGuire
phillips@syrinx.umd.edu                    Felan shena Thoron'edras
plutchak@porter.geo.brown.edu              Joel Plutchak
pulkka@cs.washington.edu                   Aaron Pulkka
randall-joshua@yale.edu                    Joshua Randall
rick@crick.ssctr.bcm.tmc.edu               Richard H. Miller
rlb@access.digex.com                       "Richard L. Butler"
rmg3@grebyn.com                            Robert Grumbine
rp04@lehigh.edu                            R M Price
sandia!marms@unmvax.cs.unm.edu             Mike Arms
schaller@hsi.com                           "Dave V. Schaller"
sears@cello.hpl.hp.com                     Bart Sears
sheilah@wam.umd.edu                        Sheila Herndon
smarry@zooid.guild.org                     Marc Moorcroft
ssircar@canon.com                          Subrata Sircar
sven@cs.widener.edu                        "Sven M. Heinicke"
swf@elsegundoca.ncr.com                    Stan Friesen
tdarcos@access.digex.com                   Paul Robinson
thompson@cisco.com                         Elaine Thompson
tkoppel@cassandra.cair.du.edu              Ted Koppel
trier@slc6.ins.cwru.edu                    Stephen C. Trier
tyg@valhalla.hq.ileaf.com                  Tom Galloway
vjg@cbnews.att.com                         Vince Guinto
vk@aloft.att.com                           Vivek Kalra
wald@theory.lcs.mit.edu                    David Wald
warninm@xanth.cs.orst.edu                  Michael Warning
werner@soe.berkeley.edu                    John Werner
wwhitman@nevada.edu                        MICHAEL WISE
yarnot@babbage.ecs.csus.edu                Jan Yarnot
zippy@berry.cs.brandeis.edu                Patrick Tufts
zorak@matt.ksu.ksu.edu                     Scott E Flowers

INVALID VOTES (7)
=================

  A few votes were invalid. I made at least one attempt to contact
  every person who cast an invalid ballot. Some of these people
  responded with valid votes; the following people did not.

GANESH@jhuvms.hcf.jhu.edu
  Sent me a copy of the CFV, but did not include a YES or NO vote.

rvblumer@mailbox.syr.edu (Robert V. Blumer)
  Sent mail with subject "Re: CFV: rec.arts.books.tolkien", but no YES
  or NO vote.

ma_blase@csd.uwe-bristol.ac.uk (Fox) 
  Sent mail with subject "no", no text in body (except for sig block);
  mail did not mention group or vote.

glr8c@uva.pcmail.virginia.edu (Gregory Lawrence Romano)
  Sent mail with subject "YES!!!", no text in body; mail did not
  mention group or vote.

guest@nntpxfer.psi.com  (Randy Goldberg, MS96, New York Med)
  YES vote not from valid account.

rich@page-cad2.den.mmc.com (Rich Hart 1-4822 PAGER 20-1127)
  Sent mail with subject "Reply is NO", body text was "NO"; mail did
  not mention group or vote.

tw41836@is1.bfu.vub.ac.be (CAMERMAN FILIP)
  Sent mail with subject "Re: 3rd CFV and VOTE ACK:
  rec.arts.books.tolkien", no text in body; mail did not contain a YES
  or NO vote.
-- 
Andrew M. Solovay    

"I have been Foolish and Deluded, 
 and I am a Bear of No Brain at All."     -- Pooh

 
USENET FACT: Flaming
Flaming is the hostile interaction between multiple Usenet users.