From [email protected] Thu Mar 11 11:31:40 1993 Path: uunet!bounce-back From: [email protected] (Chuck Ames) Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.software-eng Subject: RFD: comp.testing Followup-To: news.groups Date: 11 Mar 1993 00:54:07 -0500 Organization: Jet Propulsion Laboratory Lines: 115 Sender: [email protected] Approved: [email protected] Message-ID: <[email protected]> NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3332 news.groups:67868 comp.software-eng:13536 SUMMARY: This is a request for discussion regarding the proposed creation of a new moderated newsgroup, possibly called comp.testing. Comp.testing will be a spin-off from comp.software-eng to harbor discussions of testing tools and techniques for both hardware and software systems. PURPOSE: Currently, discussions of tools and techniques for software testing take place in comp.software-eng. While testing is inarguably a vital part of software engineering, a new group specifically designated for discussions of testing issues may be justified for two reasons: 1) comp.software-eng gets a relatively great deal of traffic. It may not be a bad idea to re-direct some of this traffic. 2) Usenet does not currently have a newsgroup which seems appropriate for discussions of hardware and system testing. A new newsgroup whose charter specifically includes these issues could fill this gap. CONTENTS: For the purpose of this discussion, we will assume that a system is comprised of hardware, software, people, and procedures. Comp.testing should be chartered to include discussions characterized by the following list of subjects, compiled from preliminary discussions: - system test automation - system test planning - system test optimization (e.g. minimize regression testing) - test tools - test metrics - measurement technology - nature of testing under various development models (e.g. object-oriented, real time, etc...) - testing in a rapid prototyping environment (i.e. sans spec) - relationship of various classes/types of tests to requirements, ... - conference and symposium announcements - the definition of "software testing" and its relationship to SQA and debugging. - requirements traceability - risk-based testing - the most useful form of specifications and functional requirements from the tester's point of view. - testing techniques, e.g., structured testing using control flowgraphs and basis path testing, equivalence class partitioning, boundary value analysis, cause-effect graphing, path predicate testing, data flow testing, program slices, data object state and usage analysis, data flow anomaly analysis, and sensitivity analysis. - test coverage criteria, e.g., statement (C1), path, branch (C2), module (S0), and call-pair (S1) coverage criteria. All levels of testing for both hardware and software should be considered appropriate subject matter. While it is likely that the group will take on a software flavor early on, we should try to generate interest and input from people with hardware and system testing experience. It is especially important that we foster discussion of *system* level testing issues, since this is the weakest area of our collective knowledge. If the Usenet community decides that the new group should be moderated, then I volunteer to serve in that capacity. (Warning: Campaign starts here:) I work in the spacecraft integration and test organization at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory. Engineers in my section, and within other JPL organizations, have a great deal of experience in system level integration and test which I would seek to relate in the proposed newsgroup. In addition, NASA's new commitment to technology transfer with Industry and Acadamia helps ensure that personnel at JPL and other NASA centers will be anxious to do their part in making this newsgroup a valuable resource for the entire Usenet community. RATIONALE: The system development community is very diverse in the kinds of systems we build. From scientific software to industrial machinery, all systems require testing. The number of systems that fall into the hybrid category - hardware/software/people/procedures - is increasing, but it is not clear that the focus of testing research is following that shift. Little knowledge of system level testing approaches, methods, and tools has been codified and made readily available to the testing community. The proposed newsgroup, comp.testing, could help fill that gap by providing a channel for testing researchers and professionals to exchange experiences at all levels, from code fragment or circuit diagram to automobile or spacecraft. ISSUES: The following issues should be resolved during the discussion: - Name: for starters, how about: comp.testing comp.system-testing comp.qa (quality asurance) comp.vv (verification and validation) - Charter: What has been left out? What should be restated? Excluded? - Moderation: should the group be moderated? If so, by whom? - Attitude toward vendor publicity: solicited only? strictly forbidden? DISCUSSION PERIOD AND VOTE: The discussion period will be to 17 April 93. Please post all discussion in "news.groups", cross-posting as appropriate. If a consensus is reached by the end of the discussion period, a Call for Votes (CFV) will be posted at that time. The voting period, in accordance with Usenet guidelines, will last for 30 days. -- Chuck Ames Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology [email protected] From [email protected] Wed Apr 28 18:54:45 1993 Path: uunet!bounce-back From: Chuck AmesNewsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.software-eng Subject: CFV: comp.software.testing Followup-To: poster Date: 27 Apr 1993 16:22:19 -0400 Organization: Jet Propulsion Laboratory Lines: 105 Sender: [email protected] Approved: [email protected] Message-ID: <[email protected]> NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3514 news.groups:70949 comp.software-eng:14303 First Call for Votes: comp.software.testing ABSTRACT Here we go: Voting period is April 27 through May 27. To vote please send a message with the subject line: comp.software.testing: YES or comp.software.testing: NO to: [email protected] DISCUSSION A request for discussion (RFD) for a new software testing newsgroup was posted on March 15 with 2nd and 3rd RFDs posted on April 5 and April 16, respectively. The group's name (whew!) and charter were accepted. STATUS comp.software.testing will be unmoderated. CHARTER (duplicated from 3rd RFD) For the purpose of this discussion, we will assume that a system is comprised of hardware, software, people, and procedures. Comp.testing should be chartered to include discussions characterized by the following list of subjects, compiled from preliminary discussions: - system test automation - system test planning - system test optimization (e.g. minimize regression testing) - test tools - test metrics - measurement technology - nature of testing under various development models (e.g. object-oriented, real time, etc...) - testing in a rapid prototyping environment (i.e. sans spec) - relationship of various classes/types of tests to requirements, ... - conference and symposium announcements - the definition of "software testing" and its relationship to SQA and debugging. - requirements traceability - risk-based testing - the most useful form of specifications and functional requirements from the tester's point of view. - testing techniques, e.g., structured testing using control flowgraphs and basis path testing, equivalence class partitioning, boundary value analysis, cause-effect graphing, path predicate testing, data flow testing, program slices, data object state and usage analysis, data flow anomaly analysis, and sensitivity analysis. - test coverage criteria, e.g., statement (C1), path, branch (C2), module (S0), and call-pair (S1) coverage criteria. All levels of testing for both hardware and software should be considered appropriate subject matter. While it is likely that the group will take on a software flavor early on, we should try to generate interest and input from people with hardware and system testing experience. It is especially important that we foster discussion of *system* level testing issues, since this is the weakest area of our collective knowledge. VOTING The voting period will last from April 27 to May 27 (23:59 PST). In accordance with Usenet Guidelines, at least 2/3 of the votes cast must be YES votes, and there must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes. To vote, please send a message with the subject line: comp.software.testing: YES or comp.software.testing: NO to: [email protected] A "YES" vote will be interpreted as "I vote for the creation of comp.software.testing as proposed." and a "NO" vote will be taken to mean "I vote against the creation of comp.software.testing as proposed." Conditional votes will not be counted. In the event that more than one vote is received from an individual, only the most recent will be counted. Two additional CFV's will be posted during the voting period and each will contain a list of all people who have voted up to that time, however no indication of how people are voting will be given until the final acknowledgement, at which time the full vote will be made public. SCHEDULE This CFV was issued April 27. The voting period will end May 27 at 23:59 (PST). -- Chuck Ames Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology [email protected] From [email protected] Tue May 11 08:42:29 1993 Path: uunet!bounce-back From: [email protected] (Chuck Ames) Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.software-eng Subject: 2nd CFV and VOTE ACK: comp.software.testing Followup-To: poster Date: 10 May 1993 12:02:11 -0400 Organization: Jet Propulsion Laboratory Lines: 367 Sender: [email protected] Approved: [email protected] Message-ID: NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3566 news.groups:71739 comp.software-eng:14464 Call for Votes: comp.software.testing Second Call and Acknowledgment ABSTRACT Voting period is April 27 through May 27. To vote please send a message with the subject line: comp.software.testing: YES or comp.software.testing: NO to: [email protected] The names of all who have voted thus far are listed at the end of this post. If you have voted, please verify that your name is on this list and notify me of any discrepancies. DISCUSSION A request for discussion (RFD) for a new software testing newsgroup was posted on March 15 with 2nd and 3rd RFDs posted on April 5 and April 16, respectively. The group's name (whew!) and charter were accepted. STATUS comp.software.testing will be unmoderated. CHARTER (duplicated from 3rd RFD) For the purpose of this discussion, we will assume that a system is comprised of hardware, software, people, and procedures. Comp.software.testing should be chartered to include discussions characterized by the following list of subjects, compiled from preliminary discussions: - system test automation - system test planning - system test optimization (e.g. minimize regression testing) - test tools - test metrics - measurement technology - nature of testing under various development models (e.g. object-oriented, real time, etc...) - testing in a rapid prototyping environment (i.e. sans spec) - relationship of various classes/types of tests to requirements - conference and symposium announcements - the definition of "software testing" and its relationship to SQA and debugging. - requirements traceability - risk-based testing - the most useful form of specifications and functional requirements from the tester's point of view. - testing techniques, e.g., structured testing using control flowgraphs and basis path testing, equivalence class partitioning, boundary value analysis, cause-effect graphing, path predicate testing, data flow testing, program slices, data object state and usage analysis, data flow anomaly analysis, and sensitivity analysis. - test coverage criteria, e.g., statement (C1), path, branch (C2), module (S0), and call-pair (S1) coverage criteria. All levels of testing for both hardware and software should be considered appropriate subject matter. While it is likely that the group will take on a software flavor early on, we should try to generate interest and input from people with hardware and system testing experience. It is especially important that we foster discussion of *system* level testing issues, since this is the weakest area of our collective knowledge. VOTING The voting period will last from April 27 to May 27 (23:59 PST). In accordance with Usenet Guidelines, at least 2/3 of the votes cast must be YES votes, and there must be at least 100 more YES votes than NO votes. To vote, please send a message with the subject line: comp.software.testing: YES or comp.software.testing: NO to: [email protected] A "YES" vote will be interpreted as "I vote for the creation of comp.software.testing as proposed." and a "NO" vote will be taken to mean "I vote against the creation of comp.software.testing as proposed." Conditional votes will not be counted. In the event that more than one vote is received from an individual, only the most recent will be counted. Two additional CFV's will be posted during the voting period and each will contain a list of all people who have voted up to that time, however no indication of how people are voting will be given until the final acknowledgement, at which time the full vote will be made public. SCHEDULE The original CFV was issued April 27. The voting period will end May 27 at 23:59 (PST). ACKNOWLEDGMENT @hp4at.eunet.co.at:gh%[email protected] (Harald Grossauer) @hp4at.eunet.co.at:kna%[email protected] (Franz Knauseder) @hp4at.eunet.co.at:sg%[email protected] (Schmidleitner Gottfried) @hp4at.eunet.co.at:zirk%[email protected] (h. zirknitzer) [email protected] () [email protected] ("Alan A.W. Williams") [email protected] (Alan R. Weiss) [email protected] (Allon Stern) [email protected] (Arnaldo Mandel) [email protected] (amby) [email protected] (Arthur Sprecher) [email protected] (DX504 Andrij Neczwid) [email protected] (Andrew Klein) [email protected] (Antonia Bertolino) [email protected] (Rivera, Annabel M) [email protected] (J. Kintscher) [email protected] ("B.e.Ayeb") [email protected] (Sudin Bhat) [email protected] (Robert Hutchison) [email protected] (bill daniels) [email protected] (Alan Bleier) [email protected] (Bernard Hatt) [email protected] (Bob Christ) [email protected] ("BONG") [email protected] (John Braden) [email protected] (Todd Bradfute) [email protected] ("D. Brian Kimmel") [email protected] (Paul Kennedy) [email protected] (Chris Turner) [email protected] () [email protected] (Heinrich Kopp) [email protected] (Manfred Schiefert) [email protected] (Chip Rosenthal) [email protected] (Christian Fleischer) [email protected] (Christine Hickman) [email protected] (Chuck Markee) [email protected] (Claude Huss) [email protected] (Mike Overstreet) [email protected] (David Cordes) [email protected] ("Joseph Z. Provo") [email protected] (dack) [email protected] (Dan Veditz) [email protected] (Dave Cline) [email protected] (Dave Bulatek) [email protected] (Dave Saunders) [email protected] () [email protected] (David Hatley) [email protected] () [email protected] (David Bruno) [email protected] (Dave Barker) [email protected] (Dom Paniscotti) [email protected] (Don Johnson) [email protected] (Doug Thiele) [email protected] (David B Rodman) dwwx@cbnewsk (david.w.wood) [email protected] () [email protected] () [email protected] (Ed Sarlls) [email protected] (sherif el kassas) [email protected] () [email protected] (Robert Ellis) [email protected] (Ed McGuire) [email protected] (Erkki P|yh|nen) [email protected] (Eric Raisters) [email protected] (Bengt-Erik Nygren) [email protected] (Lars Lundeg}rd TX/DKF) [email protected] ("J. Scott Farrow") [email protected] (Francisco Monteiro) [email protected] (Homer Franck) [email protected] (Gregory C Franklin ) [email protected] (Fred Campos) [email protected] (Fred Mikkelsen) [email protected] (Hardcore Alaskan) [email protected] (Milt Fulghum) [email protected] (Alan Gant) [email protected] (GAZ RANDALL LOUIS) [email protected] (Geoff Burd) [email protected] (George Joseph) [email protected] (George Salonikidis) [email protected] (Gregory G. Woodbury) [email protected] () [email protected] (Scott Glasser) [email protected] (Martin Gloeckle) [email protected] (Ellen Glusman) [email protected] (Guy Meador) [email protected] (Gail Murphy) [email protected] (Paul Gregory) [email protected] (Rick Grubin) [email protected] (Gary Whiting) [email protected] (Mercenary Programmer) [email protected] (Dick Hamlet) [email protected] (John Harris) [email protected] (John Harvie) [email protected] () [email protected] (Takao Hatazaki) [email protected] (Harry H Avant) [email protected] (B.J.) [email protected] (David C Hermsen) [email protected] (Herbert M Petro) [email protected] (Holly Mahedy) [email protected] (Patricia Horton) [email protected] (Todd Huffman) [email protected] ("Henry Yung The Last In Line") [email protected] (Ilan Cohen) [email protected] (James Kandler) [email protected] (Kevin Jameson) [email protected] (Jurgen Botz) [email protected] (Jeremy Henty) [email protected] (John R. Dougan) [email protected] (Jean Libera) [email protected] (John E. Baseler) [email protected] (John Liptak) [email protected] (J Michael Hammond) [email protected] (John Kingsley) [email protected] (John Sturtevant) [email protected] (John Wright) [email protected] () [email protected] (Jon Allen) [email protected] (Joshua Cole) [email protected] (Bob Horgan) [email protected] (Judy Sturtevant) [email protected] (Julia Haviland) [email protected] ("Facts are our Friends.....") [email protected] ("Kishor Apte, Engineer -DQ - BLR - 091-0812-269920") [email protected] (Klaus Kluge) [email protected] ( David Klemp) [email protected] (Krystina Hill) [email protected] (Kurt Horton) [email protected] (Ken Collier) [email protected] (Brent LaVelle) [email protected] (Laurie White) [email protected] (Lee Mellinger) [email protected] (John Lehman -- GDP) [email protected] (Sherri Leu) [email protected] (Linda M. Easterbrooks) [email protected] (Lucy Chubb) [email protected] (Lynn Robinson) [email protected] (Magnus Kempe) [email protected] () [email protected] (Mark Cain) [email protected] () [email protected] () [email protected] () [email protected] (Marianne Becker) [email protected] (Karan Mehra) [email protected] () merk!uvmark!todd (Todd Cooper) [email protected] (Mark Heinrick) [email protected] (Mike Ball) [email protected] (Mike Watson) [email protected] (Mitzi Morris) [email protected] (Mark J. Kean) [email protected] () [email protected] (Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS) [email protected] (Monica Hutchins) [email protected] (Mark McWhinney) [email protected] (Mark Swanson) [email protected] (Marcus S. Yoo) [email protected] (Mark Woodward) [email protected] (Nancy Parsons) [email protected] (Naren Bala) [email protected] (Xumin Nie) [email protected] () [email protected] (Suzan Dry Noden) [email protected] (Katherine Noell) [email protected] (Nozar Azarakhsh) [email protected] (Carla Oexmann) [email protected] (Jan Overbeck) [email protected] (Paul Meakin) [email protected] (Paul Hudson) [email protected] ("Panos Livadas") [email protected] () [email protected] (Paul E. Hoffman) [email protected] (Pete Young) [email protected] () [email protected] (Peter A. Vogel) [email protected] () [email protected] (Raphael Manfredi) [email protected] (Randy Bush) [email protected] (Ronald B. Miller) [email protected] (Hal Render) [email protected] (Rex Davis) [email protected] (Richard H. Miller) [email protected] (Rick Innis) [email protected] (Robert Kitzberger) [email protected] (Rochelle Grober) [email protected] (W. David Rohwer) [email protected] (Ron Peterson) [email protected] (SystemManager) [email protected] (Rose Reynolds x435) [email protected] ("Royce D. Myers -- Quality Engineering 23-Apr-1993 1447") [email protected] (Rich Scire) [email protected] (Sarr Blumson) [email protected] (Bruce Tindall) [email protected] (Oita C. Coleman) [email protected] (Roger Chenoweth) [email protected] (Sue McGrath) [email protected] (Bob Patten) [email protected] (Satish Popat) [email protected] (Sean Dockery) schwartz%[email protected] ("Roman Schwartz") [email protected] (Markus Schoenbucher) [email protected] (Scott Budesheim) [email protected] (Sharon Peleg) [email protected] (Steven Hebert) [email protected] (timothy shimeall) [email protected] (Scott M McLewin) [email protected] (Steve Langstaff) [email protected] (Stephen R. Schach) [email protected] (Stephane Barbey) [email protected] (Stephen L Nicoud) [email protected] (Steve Farmer) [email protected] (Bob Stratton) [email protected] (Satish Subramanian) [email protected] (Sukan Makmuri) [email protected] (Phillip Beiler) [email protected] (Terry Rout) [email protected] (Tarak S. Goradia) [email protected] (Tom Tatlow) [email protected] (Tom Arman) [email protected] (Ted Krivoruchka) [email protected] (Tero Ahtee) [email protected] (Thomas D.Gasser) [email protected] (RAVI SHASTRI) [email protected] (Teresa Merklin) [email protected] (Hansjoerg Toepfer) [email protected] (Thomas Gould x3210) [email protected] (Tom Neal) [email protected] (Tom Cunningham) [email protected] (Timo Salmi) [email protected] () [email protected] (Mark Veksler) [email protected] (Vonn Marsch) [email protected] (Udo Voges) [email protected] () [email protected] (Wags Man) [email protected] (Bill Wake) [email protected] (Walt Weber) [email protected] (Ron Wiegand) [email protected] ("Lih Yen Hsieh") [email protected] (Dennis Wodarz) [email protected] (Pok Wong) [email protected] (Jim Wood) woods%[email protected] (Greg A. Woods) [email protected] (Steve Wright) [email protected] (Yaakov Kayman) [email protected] (David Zeitler) [email protected] (Xiaoming Zhang) [email protected] (Jon Ziegler) -- Chuck Ames Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology [email protected] From [email protected] Mon Jun 7 10:37:06 1993 Path: uunet!bounce-back From: Chuck Ames Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.software-eng Subject: RESULT: comp.software.testing passes 318:9 Followup-To: news.groups Date: 4 Jun 1993 14:12:09 -0400 Organization: Jet Propulsion Laboratory Lines: 346 Sender: [email protected] Approved: [email protected] Message-ID: <[email protected]> NNTP-Posting-Host: rodan.uu.net Xref: uunet news.announce.newgroups:3660 news.groups:73388 comp.software-eng:14904 Vote Result: comp.software.testing ---------------------------------- 318 YES 9 NO 1 ABSTAIN ----------- 328 Total Roughly 97% of all votes received were YES votes and there 309 more YES votes than NO votes. All votes received during the voting period are listed below: ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): NO ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): NO ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES ([email protected]): YES Abhay Patil ([email protected]): YES Adrian Wontroba ([email protected]): YES Alan Williams ([email protected]): YES Alan Bleier ([email protected]): YES Alan R. Weiss ([email protected]): YES Alice Taylor ([email protected]): YES Allon Stern ([email protected]): YES amby ([email protected]): YES Andrew Klein ([email protected]): YES Antonia Bertolino ([email protected]): YES Arnaldo Mandel ([email protected]): YES Arthur A. Reyes ([email protected]): YES Arthur Hicken ([email protected]): YES Arthur Sprecher ([email protected]): YES B.e.Ayeb ([email protected]): YES B.J. ([email protected]): YES Barry Kaplan ([email protected]): YES Belinda Juran ([email protected]): YES Bengt-Erik Nygren ([email protected]): YES Bernard Hatt ([email protected]): YES bill daniels ([email protected]): YES Bill Wake ([email protected]): YES Bob Christ ([email protected]): YES Bob Horgan ([email protected]): YES Bob McIlree ([email protected]): YES Bob Patten ([email protected]): YES Bob Stratton ([email protected]): YES Bob Treitman ([email protected]): YES BONG ([email protected]): YES Brad Davidson ([email protected]): YES Brady Schutt ([email protected]): YES Brent LaVelle ([email protected]): YES Bret Pettichord ([email protected]): YES Bruce Tindall ([email protected]): YES Carla Oexmann ([email protected]): YES Charlie Trainor ([email protected]): YES Chin-Peng Choo ([email protected]): YES Chip Rosenthal ([email protected]): NO Chris Turner ([email protected]): YES Christian Fleischer ([email protected]): YES Christine Hickman ([email protected]): YES Chuck Brunson ([email protected]): YES Chuck Karish ([email protected]): YES Chuck Markee ([email protected]): YES cindy woolworth x3380 ([email protected]): YES Claude Huss ([email protected]): YES Colin Jitlal ([email protected]): YES D. Brian Kimmel ([email protected]): YES dack ([email protected]): YES Dan Veditz ([email protected]): YES Dave Barker ([email protected]): YES Dave Bulatek ([email protected]): YES Dave Cline ([email protected]): YES Dave Flewitt ([email protected]): YES Dave L Isenberg ([email protected]): YES Dave Saunders ([email protected]): YES David B Rodman ([email protected]): YES David Boyd ([email protected]): YES David Bruno ([email protected]): YES David C Hermsen ([email protected]): YES David Cordes ([email protected]): YES David Hatley ([email protected]): YES David Klemp ([email protected]): YES David Zeitler ([email protected]): YES Debi Humphries ([email protected]): YES Dennis J. Wilkinson ([email protected]): YES Dennis Wodarz ([email protected]): YES Dick Hamlet ([email protected]): YES Dom Paniscotti ([email protected]): YES Don Johnson ([email protected]): YES Don Miller ([email protected]): YES Doug Thiele ([email protected]): YES DX504 Andrij Neczwid ([email protected]): YES Ed Childs ([email protected]): YES Ed McGuire ([email protected]): YES Ed Sarlls ([email protected]): YES Ellen Glusman ([email protected]): YES Eric J. Olson ([email protected]): NO Eric Raisters ([email protected]): YES Erkki P|yh|nen ([email protected]): YES Facts are our Friends..... ([email protected]): YES Francisco Monteiro ([email protected]): YES Franco Mazzanti ([email protected]): YES Franz Hofer ([email protected]): YES Franz Knauseder (@hp4at.eunet.co.at:kna%[email protected]): YES Fred Campos ([email protected]): YES Fred Mikkelsen ([email protected]): YES Gail Murphy ([email protected]): YES Garrett Colson ([email protected]): NO Gary Whiting ([email protected]): YES GAZ RANDALL LOUIS ([email protected]): YES Geoff Burd ([email protected]): YES George Joseph ([email protected]): YES George S Kardaras ([email protected]): YES George Salonikidis ([email protected]): YES Greg A. Woods (woods%[email protected]): YES Gregory C Franklin ([email protected]): YES Gregory G. Woodbury ([email protected]): ABSTAIN Guy Meador ([email protected]): YES h. zirknitzer (@hp4at.eunet.co.at:zirk%[email protected]): YES Hal Render ([email protected]): YES Hansjoerg Toepfer ([email protected]): YES Harald Grossauer (@hp4at.eunet.co.at:gh%[email protected]): YES Hardcore Alaskan ([email protected]): YES Harry H Avant ([email protected]): YES Heinrich Kopp ([email protected]): YES Henry Yung The Last In Line ([email protected]): YES Herbert M Petro ([email protected]): NO Holly Mahedy ([email protected]): YES Homer Franck ([email protected]): YES Ilan Cohen ([email protected]): YES J Michael Hammond ([email protected]): YES J. Kintscher ([email protected]): YES J. Scott Farrow ([email protected]): YES James Kandler ([email protected]): YES Jan Overbeck ([email protected]): YES Janice Ritter x5444 ([email protected]): YES jasper (@ada3.ca.boeing.com:[email protected]): YES Jean Libera ([email protected]): YES Jeff Thompson ([email protected]): YES Jere Judd ([email protected]): YES Jeremy Henty ([email protected]): YES Jeremy Shaw ([email protected]): YES Jim Wood ([email protected]): YES John Braden ([email protected]): YES John E. Baseler ([email protected]): YES John Harris ([email protected]): YES John Harvie ([email protected]): YES John Kingsley ([email protected]): YES John Lehman -- GDP ([email protected]): YES John Liptak ([email protected]): YES John R. Dougan ([email protected]): YES John Shepard ([email protected]): YES John Sturtevant ([email protected]): YES John Wright ([email protected]): YES Jon A. Wilcox ([email protected]): YES Jon Allen ([email protected]): YES Jon Ziegler ([email protected]): YES Joseph Z. Provo ([email protected]): YES Joshua Cole ([email protected]): YES Joshua Levy ([email protected]): YES Judy Keeley ([email protected]): YES Judy Sturtevant ([email protected]): YES Juergen Nickelsen ([email protected]): YES Julia Haviland ([email protected]): YES Jurgen Botz ([email protected]): YES Karan Mehra ([email protected]): YES Katherine Noell ([email protected]): YES Ken Collier ([email protected]): YES Ken Mikolajek ([email protected]): YES Kevin Jameson ([email protected]): YES Kishor Apte ([email protected]): YES Klaus Kluge ([email protected]): YES Kon Lovett ([email protected]): YES Krystina Hill ([email protected]): YES Kurt Horton ([email protected]): YES Larry Enos x5572 ([email protected]): YES Lars Lundeg}rd TX/DKF ([email protected]): YES Laurie White ([email protected]): YES Lee Mellinger ([email protected]): YES Lih Yen Hsieh ([email protected]): YES Linda M. Easterbrooks ([email protected]): YES Lucy Chubb ([email protected]): YES Lynn Robinson ([email protected]): YES Magnus Kempe ([email protected]): YES Manfred Schiefert ([email protected]): YES Marcus S. Yoo ([email protected]): YES Marianne Becker ([email protected]): YES Mark Cain ([email protected]): YES Mark E. McKain ([email protected]): YES Mark Heinrick ([email protected]): YES Mark J. Kean ([email protected]): YES Mark McWhinney ([email protected]): YES Mark Swanson ([email protected]): YES Mark Veksler ([email protected]): YES Mark Woodward ([email protected]): YES Markus Schoenbucher ([email protected]): YES Martin Gloeckle ([email protected]): YES Maxime Taksar KC6ZPS ([email protected]): YES Mercenary Programmer ([email protected]): YES Mike Ball ([email protected]): YES Mike Overstreet ([email protected]): YES Mike Watson ([email protected]): YES Milt Fulghum ([email protected]): YES Mitzi Morris ([email protected]): YES Monica Hutchins ([email protected]): YES Murthy N ([email protected]): YES Nancy Parsons ([email protected]): YES Naren Bala ([email protected]): YES Nate Williams ([email protected]): YES Nozar Azarakhsh ([email protected]): YES Oita C. Coleman ([email protected]): YES Panos Livadas ([email protected]): YES Patricia Horton ([email protected]): YES Paul E. Hoffman ([email protected]): YES Paul Gregory ([email protected]): YES Paul Hudson ([email protected]): YES Paul Kennedy ([email protected]): NO Paul Meakin ([email protected]): YES Paul Wikstrom ([email protected]): YES Pete Young ([email protected]): YES Peter A. Vogel ([email protected]): YES Phillip Beiler ([email protected]): YES Pok Wong ([email protected]): YES Poutanen Olavi ([email protected]): YES Prasanna Limaye ([email protected]): YES R. P. White ([email protected]): YES Ramana K V ([email protected]): YES Randy Bush ([email protected]): YES Raphael Manfredi ([email protected]): YES RAVI SHASTRI ([email protected]): YES Rex Davis ([email protected]): YES Rich Scire ([email protected]): YES Richard H. Miller ([email protected]): NO Rick Grubin ([email protected]): YES Rick Innis ([email protected]): YES Rivera, Annabel M ([email protected]): YES Rob Knauerhase ([email protected]): YES Robert Ellis ([email protected]): YES Robert F. Benningfield ([email protected]): NO Robert Hutchison ([email protected]): YES Robert Kitzberger ([email protected]): YES Roberto Loro ([email protected]): YES Rochelle Grober ([email protected]): YES Roger Chenoweth ([email protected]): YES Roman Schwartz (schwartz%[email protected]): YES Ron Peterson ([email protected]): YES Ron Wiegand ([email protected]): YES Ronald B. Miller ([email protected]): YES Rose Reynolds x435 ([email protected]): YES Ross Knights [x4463] ([email protected]): YES Royce D. Myers ([email protected]): YES Sam Goins ([email protected]): YES Sarr Blumson ([email protected]): YES Satish Popat ([email protected]): YES Satish Subramanian ([email protected]): YES Schmidleitner Gottfried (@hp4at.eunet.co.at:sg%[email protected]): YES Scott Glasser ([email protected]): YES Scott M McLewin ([email protected]): YES Sean Dockery ([email protected]): YES Sharon Peleg ([email protected]): YES Shekhar H. Kirani ([email protected]): YES Shel Prince ([email protected]): YES Shengru Tu ([email protected]): YES sherif el kassas ([email protected]): YES Sherri Leu ([email protected]): YES Shie-Rei Huang ([email protected]): YES Stephane Barbey ([email protected]): YES Stephen Belt ([email protected]): YES Stephen L Nicoud ([email protected]): YES Stephen R. Schach ([email protected]): YES Steve Farmer ([email protected]): YES Steve Langstaff ([email protected]): YES steve norton ([email protected]): YES Steve Wright ([email protected]): YES Steven Hebert ([email protected]): YES Sudin Bhat ([email protected]): YES Sue McGrath ([email protected]): YES Sukan Makmuri ([email protected]): YES suresh krishnajois ([email protected]): YES Suzan Dry Noden ([email protected]): YES Takao Hatazaki ([email protected]): YES Tarak S. Goradia ([email protected]): YES Tarun Rajput Contractor ([email protected]): YES Ted Krivoruchka ([email protected]): YES Ted Richards ([email protected]): YES Teresa Merklin ([email protected]): YES Tero Ahtee ([email protected]): YES Terry Rout ([email protected]): YES Thomas Gould x3210 ([email protected]): YES Thomas Parker ([email protected]): YES Tim Bunce ([email protected]): YES Timo Salmi ([email protected]): YES timothy shimeall ([email protected]): YES Todd Bradfute ([email protected]): YES Todd Cooper (merk!uvmark!todd): YES Todd Huffman ([email protected]): YES Todd Montgomery ([email protected]): YES Tom Arman ([email protected]): YES Tom Cunningham ([email protected]): YES Tom Horton ([email protected]): YES Tom Neal ([email protected]): YES Tom Tatlow ([email protected]): YES Udo Voges ([email protected]): YES Vince Mehringer ([email protected]): YES Vivek N Gavaskar ([email protected]): YES Vonn Marsch ([email protected]): YES W. David Rohwer ([email protected]): YES Wags Man ([email protected]): YES Walejko, Jim ([email protected]): YES Walt Weber ([email protected]): YES William J. Menter ([email protected]): YES Xiaoming Zhang ([email protected]): YES Yaakov Kayman ([email protected]): YES -- Chuck Ames Jet Propulsion Laboratory, California Institute of Technology [email protected]