• Your Trusted Usenet Provider
  • Secure, Private, Unlimited

Newsgroups Main » Newsgroups Directory » Computers - Non-OS » Source code

Reviews (M) ( comp.sources.reviewed )
 
From [email protected] Mon Sep 27 10:35:34 1993
Flags: 000000000201
Path: lear
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: CALL FOR DISCUSSION -- comp.sources.reviewed
Followup-to: news.groups
Nntp-Posting-Host: calvin.doc.ca
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: Sun,  3 Feb 91 21:43:32 PST
Keywords: posted

This is a formal Call For Discussion for a proposed newsgroup
"comp.sources.reviewed".  The Discussion Period will last to February
23, 1991, at which time a Call For Votes will be issued (pending the
results of the discussion).

The newsgroup "comp.sources.reviewed" is being proposed now for three
reasons:
    (1) to improve the timely distribution of high-quality software.
    (2) to give software authors a more responsive "proving ground" for
    	their work.
    (3) to distribute software with informative review information
    	attached such that readers can decide if it will be useful.

I have recently completed a Call for Peer Reviewers and received replies
>From enough interested people (31) to suggest that a Peer Reviewed
newsgroup may be feasible and worth pursuing.

The charter of the proposed group "comp.sources.reviewed" would be as 
follows:

"Comp.sources.reviewed" is a moderated newsgroup for the distribution of
program sources that have been subjected to a Peer Reviewed process.
Similar to the process used for academic journals, submissions are sent
to a moderator (unless a better option is discussed, I will act as the
moderator) who then sends the sources to Peer Review volunteers for
evaluation.  The Reviewers are asked to provided a timely evaluation of
the software by compiling and running it on their machine.  If time does
not permit them to complete a review, they are responsible for asking
the moderator to select another reviewer.

The duties of the Moderator are to accept submissions and assign them to
reviewers, collect the reviews and make publication decisions, and post
the accepted sources.  He is also be responsible for maintaining a list
of volunteers interested in acting as peer reviewers.  (Volunteers can
send a note to "[email protected]" to be placed on the list.) The
Moderator may seek the assistance of one or more Associate Moderators,
especially for the maintenance of an archive site (if one can be
arranged), and the rapid posting of patches to already-published
sources.  (Many volunteers suggested that having Associate Moderators
assign the submission to reviewers and compiling the evaluations was
adding too much bureaucracy.)

If the Moderator and Peer Reviewers judge a submission to be acceptable,
the sources will be posted along with the written comments provided
by the Reviewers.  If a submission is not found to be acceptable, the
submitter will be provided with the Reviewers' comments, and they will
have the option of addressing those comments and submitting the sources
again.


-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
               [email protected]    [email protected]
                      Bill Watterson for President!


From [email protected] Mon Sep 27 12:24:18 1993
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups
Path: rpi!tale
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: CFV:  comp.sources.reviewed moderated
Followup-To: poster
Summary: the real official call for votes for new moderated group
Keywords: news groups source review
Sender: [email protected]
Nntp-Posting-Host: cs.rpi.edu
Reply-To: [email protected]
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: 4 Mar 91 01:37:56 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 56

This is an official Call for Votes for the proposed newsgroup
"comp.sources.reviewed".  "Comp.sources.reviewed" will be a moderated
newsgroup (moderator: Andrew Patrick [[email protected]]) with the
following charter:

    "Comp.sources.reviewed" is a moderated newsgroup for the
    distribution of program sources that have been subjected to a Peer
    Review process.  Similar to the process used for academic
    journals, submissions are sent to a moderator who then sends the
    sources to Peer Review volunteers for evaluation.  The Reviewers are
    asked to provided a timely evaluation of the software by compiling
    and running it on their machine.  If time does not permit them to
    complete a review, they are responsible for asking the moderator to
    select another reviewer.  If the Moderator and Peer Reviewers judge
    a submission to be acceptable, the sources will be posted along with
    the written comments provided by the Reviewers.  If a submission is
    not found to be acceptable, the submitter will be provided with the
    Reviewers' comments, and they will have the option of addressing
    those comments and submitting the sources again.

    Volunteers interested in reviewing sources for this newsgroup can
    send a note to "[email protected]" to be placed on the list.

Votes for and against this proposed group should be sent to

	[email protected]
	
Please specify in your Subject: line if you vote yes or no by including
the words "yes" or "no" somewhere in the line, and then include in the
body a clear statement of your preference:

	e.g., "I vote YES for comp.sources.reviewed."
	or
	e.g., "I vote NO for comp.sources.reviewed."
	
The voting period will last from Feb. 28 1991 to March 31 1991.

Technical Information on Reaching "calvin.doc.ca"
-------------------------------------------------

"Calvin.doc.ca" is an Internet site that should be easily reachable
>from any network.  For those who need more detailed information:

The host "calvin.doc.ca" is directly connected to the Internet and uses
an MX forwarder called "dgbt.doc.ca" (also known as "dgbt.crc.dnd.ca")
(192.12.98.7).

"calvin.doc.ca" is also reachable by UUCP using a path like:

	...uunet!mnetor!lsuc!nrcaer!dgbt!calvin!votes

-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
[email protected]
                    "The interface IS the program."


From [email protected] Mon Sep 27 12:31:54 1993
Xref: rpi news.announce.newgroups:933 news.groups:22763
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups
Path: rpi!tale
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: VOTE ACK:  comp.sources.reviewed
Followup-To: poster
Sender: [email protected]
Nntp-Posting-Host: cs.rpi.edu
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: 10 Mar 91 02:44:38 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 224

As of March 8, I have recorded votes from the following people
(votes should be sent to "[email protected]" with "yes" or "no" in
the Subject: line):

"Christopher M. Conway" <[email protected]>
"Douglas F. DeJulio" <[email protected]>
"Erich Meier (Inf4 - hiwi)" <[email protected]>
"Jonathan I. Kamens" <[email protected]>
"Karsten Nyblad, TFL, Denmark" <[email protected]>
"Neil Rickert, N Illinois U, CS" <[email protected]>
"Stuart L Labovitz" <valinor!stu>
"The Wandering Wizard" <uunet!vampire!network_mgr>
"william b. coleman" <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Brian Matthews)
Alan B. Clegg <[email protected]>
Baruch Cochavy <blue%[email protected]>
Ben Golding <[email protected]>
Bengt Larsson <[email protected]>
Bill Randle <billr%[email protected]>
Brett K. Carver <[email protected]>
Bruce Sherrod <[email protected]>
Christopher Bryden <[email protected]>
Christopher Mc Kulka <[email protected]>
Dan Poirier <[email protected]>
Dan Schlitt <[email protected]>
Dave Sill <[email protected]>
Doug Lee <[email protected]>
Doug Sewell <[email protected]>
Eamonn McManus <[email protected]>
Ed McGuire <[email protected]>
Ed Reed <mitel!uunet!leadsv!ereed>
Eric Olson <[email protected]>
Geoff Kuenning <mitel!devnet.la.locus.com!geoff>
Gisle Hannemyr <[email protected]>
Guy Middleton <[email protected]>
James da Silva <[email protected]>
Jan van der Steen <[email protected]>
Jay Maynard <[email protected]>
Jean-Francois Rit <[email protected]>
Jean-Loup Gailly <[email protected]>
Jeremy J Bolio <[email protected]>
Jim Bevier - J B Systems <[email protected]>
John Romine <[email protected]>
Jussi Heinonen <[email protected]>
Larry Gillespie <[email protected]>
Magnus Olsson <[email protected]>
Marc Rouleau <[email protected]>
Mark Nagel <[email protected]>
Marty Ryba <[email protected]>
Matthew Farwell <[email protected]>
Matthias Urlichs <urlichs%[email protected]>
Merri L Naka <[email protected]>
Michel B. Cormier <micor!mcormier>
Ozan Yigit <[email protected]>
Palmer Davis <[email protected]>
Patrick e. Fleming <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Frederick G. M. Roeber)
Ralph Clark <[email protected]>
Rein Tollevik <[email protected]>
Richard H. Miller <[email protected]>
Roger Fulton <[email protected]>
Rupert G. Goldie <[email protected]>
Sam Horrocks <[email protected]>
Scott Barman <mitel!nbc1.ge.com!scott>
Scott R. Weis KB2EAR <[email protected]>
Sean Philip Engelson <[email protected]>
Shannon D. Appel <[email protected]>
Soren Larsen <[email protected]>
Steve Hayman <[email protected]>
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
Thomas Andreasson <[email protected]>
Tim Cook <[email protected]>
Tim Morgan <[email protected]>
Timothy VanFosson <[email protected]>
Tom Anderson <[email protected]>
Tom Christiansen <[email protected]>
Tom Haapanen <[email protected]>
Tom Roehl <[email protected]>
Torben Lange <[email protected]>
[email protected]
[email protected] (Andy Thomas)
[email protected] (Akiko Katayama)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Jean Marie Diaz)
[email protected] (Ron Gallant)
[email protected]
[email protected] (DOS: Tastes like chicken when properly prepared.)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Binayak Banerjee)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Bob Posert)
[email protected] (Dan Bernstein)
[email protected] (Bill White)
[email protected] (Mike Northam ext 2651)
[email protected] (Chris Greve)
[email protected] (Christos S. Zoulas)
[email protected] (Mike Coleman)
[email protected] (Cliff Tuel)
[email protected] (Curt Sampson)
[email protected] (Daniel Jacobson)
[email protected] (David Robinson)
[email protected]
davide%[email protected] (David Eckelkamp)
dciem!6sceng!blm%cs.washington.edu (Brian Matthews)
dciem!bkj386!brian (Brian Jenkins)
dciem!corondan%eds.com
dciem!doug%letni.LoneStar.org (Doug Davis)
dciem!jmm%eci386 (John Macdonald)
dciem!letni!digi.lonestar.org!kgallagh%utacfd.uta.edu (Kevin Gallagher)
dciem!nelson%berlioz.nsc.com (Taed Nelson)
dciem!nick%ryelect (Nick Colonello)
dciem!seachg!jalsop (John Alsop)
dciem!smu!letni!ataritx!dwh%cs.utexas.edu (Dave Hanna)
dciem!steve%txsil.lonestar.org (Steve McConnel)
[email protected] (David C. Miller)
[email protected] (Eric Delaney)
[email protected] (David G Freudenstein)
[email protected] (Dave Glowacki)
[email protected] (Paul Do (News))
[email protected] (M. J. Cole)
[email protected] (Wayne Schlitt)
[email protected] (Alexander Dupuy)
[email protected] (Ed Hew)
[email protected] (Tom Fitzgerald)
[email protected] (frank korzeniewski)
[email protected] (Jesse Perry)
gatech!uflorida!rm1!bapat (Subodh Bapat)
[email protected] (Gene Kim)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Glenn R. Stone)
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Herman Rubin)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Fernando Manuel Vasconcelos)
[email protected] (Rui Casteleiro)
isgtec!ted (Ted Richards)
[email protected] (Jan B.Andersen)
[email protected] (Jean-Christophe Collet)
[email protected] (John Martin)
[email protected] (Jef Poskanzer)
[email protected] (Randell Jesup)
[email protected] (John F. Woods)
[email protected] (Juan Gabriel Ruiz Pinto)
[email protected] (John G. DeArmond)
[email protected] (Jeffri H Frontz)
[email protected] (Jim Richardson)
[email protected] (John Nemeth)
[email protected] (John P. Nelson)
[email protected] (Keenan Ross )
[email protected] (Kirk Webb)
[email protected] (Ken McVay)
[email protected] (Hans-Peter Kolb)
[email protected] (Kevin Braunsdorf)
[email protected] (Eliot)
[email protected] (Ken Lerman)
[email protected] (Anselm Lingnau)
[email protected] (Larry Blair)
lsuc!linus!russ%shannon.Alliant.COM (Russell McFatter)
[email protected]
lwv27%[email protected]
[email protected] (Sean Malloy)
[email protected] (Marco Lorenzini)
[email protected] (Alex Martelli)
[email protected] (Thomas Maslen)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Michael W. Wellman)
[email protected]
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
mitel!juts.ccc.amdahl.com!ked01 (Kim DeVaughn)
mitel!onion.rain.com!jeff (Jeff Beadles)
mitel!se-sd.SanDiego.NCR.COM!bhoule (Bill Houle)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!kent (Kent Landfield)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!rick (Richard Ohnemus)
mitel!uunet!ars2!briank
mitel!uunet!coplex!dean (Dean Brooks)
mitel!uunet!infmx!crickhollow!cortesi (David Cortesi)
mitel!uunet!vicstoy!jellis (Jacob Ellis)
[email protected] (John Harkin)
[email protected] (David Muir Sharnoff)
[email protected] (Neil Murray)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steven C. Work)
[email protected] (Orlan Cannon)
[email protected] (Frank Ooms)
[email protected] (Jaye Mathisen)
[email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
[email protected] (Leonard Peirce)
[email protected] (Peter da Silva)
[email protected] (Philip Dart)
[email protected] (Marc C. Poulin)
[email protected] (Raymond Chen)
[email protected] (Ralph Finch)
[email protected] (Richard Foulk)
[email protected]
rob%[email protected] (Robert Ransbottom)
[email protected] (Rob Kenna)
[email protected] (Rich Kulawiec)
[email protected] (Mike Arms)
[email protected] (Dave Shaver)
[email protected] (Rich Skrenta)
[email protected] (Steve Lamont)
[email protected] (Steven C. Liu)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steintor Bjarnason)
[email protected] (Steen Hammerum)
[email protected] (Steve Nuchia)
[email protected] (Syd Weinstein)
[email protected] (Tim Ramsey)
[email protected] (Chip Salzenberg)
[email protected] (Tom Dinger - Sun BOS SPA)
tibor%[email protected] (Tibor Stern jr.)
[email protected] (Tom Horsley)
[email protected] (Karl Tombre)
[email protected] (Tom Frauenhofer)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Warren Tucker)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Winfried Koenig)
[email protected] (Jim Hebert)
-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
[email protected]
                    "The interface IS the program."

From [email protected] Wed Apr  5 19:27:58 1995
Xref: rpi news.announce.newgroups:967 news.groups:23337 comp.sources.d:3725
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.sources.d
Path: rpi!tale
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: 2nd CFV:  comp.sources.reviewed moderated
Followup-To: poster
Sender: [email protected]
Nntp-Posting-Host: cs.rpi.edu
Reply-To: [email protected]
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: 21 Mar 91 04:43:02 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 56

This is the second official Call for Votes for the proposed newsgroup
"comp.sources.reviewed".  "Comp.sources.reviewed" will be a moderated
newsgroup (moderator: Andrew Patrick [[email protected]]) with the
following charter:

    "Comp.sources.reviewed" is a moderated newsgroup for the
    distribution of program sources that have been subjected to a Peer
    Review process.  Similar to the process used for academic
    journals, submissions are sent to a moderator who then sends the
    sources to Peer Review volunteers for evaluation.  The Reviewers are
    asked to provided a timely evaluation of the software by compiling
    and running it on their machine.  If time does not permit them to
    complete a review, they are responsible for asking the moderator to
    select another reviewer.  If the Moderator and Peer Reviewers judge
    a submission to be acceptable, the sources will be posted along with
    the written comments provided by the Reviewers.  If a submission is
    not found to be acceptable, the submitter will be provided with the
    Reviewers' comments, and they will have the option of addressing
    those comments and submitting the sources again.

    Volunteers interested in reviewing sources for this newsgroup can
    send a note to "[email protected]" to be placed on the list.

Votes for and against this proposed group should be sent to

	[email protected]
	
Please specify in your Subject: line if you vote yes or no by including
the words "yes" or "no" somewhere in the line, and then include in the
body a clear statement of your preference:

	e.g., "I vote YES for comp.sources.reviewed."
	or
	e.g., "I vote NO for comp.sources.reviewed."
	
The voting period will last from Feb. 28 1991 to March 31 1991.


Technical Information on Reaching "calvin.doc.ca"
-------------------------------------------------

"Calvin.doc.ca" is an Internet site that should be easily reachable
>from any network.  For those who need more detailed information:

The host "calvin.doc.ca" is directly connected to the Internet and uses
an MX forwarder called "dgbt.doc.ca" (also known as "dgbt.crc.dnd.ca")
(192.12.98.7).

"calvin.doc.ca" is also reachable by UUCP using a path like:

	...uunet!mnetor!lsuc!nrcaer!dgbt!calvin!votes

-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
[email protected]
                    "The interface IS the program."

From [email protected] Wed Apr  5 19:28:24 1995
Xref: rpi news.announce.newgroups:978 news.groups:23488
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups
Path: rpi!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: VOTE ACK:  comp.sources.reviewed
Followup-To: poster
Sender: [email protected]
Nntp-Posting-Host: cs.rpi.edu
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: 24 Mar 91 03:41:15 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 310

With about one week left in the voting period, it is time for a second
votes acknowledgement.  As of
	Sat Mar 23 14:56:18 EST 1991
I have recorded votes from the following people: 

[Votes can be sent to "[email protected]" with the string "yes" or
"no" in the Subject line]

"CONTR, HERRICK, DAN" <[email protected]>
"Christopher M. Conway" <[email protected]>
"D. J. McCarthy ~" <dmccart%[email protected]>
"Douglas F. DeJulio" <[email protected]>
"Erich Meier (Inf4 - hiwi)" <[email protected]>
"Jonathan I. Kamens" <[email protected]>
"Karsten Nyblad, TFL, Denmark" <[email protected]>
"Mark W. Eichin" <[email protected]>
"Neil Rickert, N Illinois U, CS" <[email protected]>
"Ralph P. Sobek" <[email protected]>
"Roger H. Goun  18-Mar-1991 1242" <[email protected]>
"Stuart L Labovitz" <valinor!stu>
"Terry Kennedy, Operations Mgr" <TERRY%[email protected]>
"Terry Poot" <[email protected]>
"The Wandering Wizard" <uunet!vampire!network_mgr>
"Vander Pol, Mark" <[email protected]>
"william b. coleman" <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Brian Matthews)
Alan B. Clegg <[email protected]>
Andrei Cogan <[email protected]>
Apparently-van-bc!TWG!bill
Baruch Cochavy <blue%[email protected]>
Ben Golding <[email protected]>
Bengt Larsson <[email protected]>
Bill Bogstad <[email protected]>
Bill Randle <billr%[email protected]>
Bob Narron <[email protected]>
Brett K. Carver <[email protected]>
Bruce Sherrod <[email protected]>
Christopher Bryden <[email protected]>
Christopher Mc Kulka <[email protected]>
Dan Poirier <[email protected]>
Dan Schlitt <[email protected]>
Dave Sill <[email protected]>
Doug Lee <[email protected]>
Doug Sewell <[email protected]>
Douglas N. Arnold <[email protected]>
Eamonn McManus <[email protected]>
Ed McGuire <[email protected]>
Ed Reed <mitel!uunet!leadsv!ereed>
Eric Olson <[email protected]>
Fergus O'Reilly <magic!fergus%crp.capsogeti.fr>
Geoff Kuenning <mitel!devnet.la.locus.com!geoff>
Gisle Hannemyr <[email protected]>
Guy Middleton <[email protected]>
James da Silva <[email protected]>
Jamie Blustein <[email protected]>
Jan van der Steen <[email protected]>
Jay Maynard <[email protected]>
Jean-Francois Rit <[email protected]>
Jean-Loup Gailly <[email protected]>
Jeff Okamoto <[email protected]>
Jeremy J Bolio <[email protected]>
Jim Bevier - J B Systems <[email protected]>
Jo Are Rosland <[email protected]>
Joel B Levin <[email protected]>
John Coolidge <[email protected]>
John Lacey <[email protected]>
John Romine <[email protected]>
Jussi Heinonen <[email protected]>
Larry Gillespie <[email protected]>
Laszlo C. Balint <[email protected]>
Linh Ngo <[email protected]>
Magnus Olsson <[email protected]>
Malcolm Mladenovic <[email protected]>
Marc Rouleau <[email protected]>
Mark Eichin <[email protected]>
Mark Nagel <[email protected]>
Marty Ryba <[email protected]>
Matthew Farwell <[email protected]>
Matthias Urlichs <urlichs%[email protected]>
Merri L Naka <[email protected]>
Michel B. Cormier <micor!mcormier>
Ozan Yigit <[email protected]>
Palmer Davis <[email protected]>
Patrick e. Fleming <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Frederick G. M. Roeber)
Ralph Clark <[email protected]>
Rein Tollevik <[email protected]>
Richard H. Miller <[email protected]>
Rick Ellis <[email protected]>
Roger Fulton <[email protected]>
Rupert G. Goldie <[email protected]>
Sam Horrocks <[email protected]>
Scott Barman <mitel!nbc1.ge.com!scott>
Scott R. Weis KB2EAR <[email protected]>
Sean Philip Engelson <[email protected]>
Shannon D. Appel <[email protected]>
Soren Larsen <[email protected]>
Stan Barber <[email protected]>
Steve Hayman <[email protected]>
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
Terry B Lyons <[email protected]>
Thomas Andreasson <[email protected]>
Tim Cook <[email protected]>
Tim Morgan <[email protected]>
Timothy VanFosson <[email protected]>
Tom Anderson <[email protected]>
Tom Christiansen <[email protected]>
Tom Epperly <[email protected]>
Tom Haapanen <[email protected]>
Tom Roehl <[email protected]>
Torben Lange <[email protected]>
[email protected]
[email protected] (Arthur David Olson)
[email protected] (Andy Thomas)
[email protected] (Akiko Katayama)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Jean Marie Diaz)
[email protected] (Bor-Jau Hsieh)
[email protected] (Andy Rose)
[email protected] (Anthony Baxter)
[email protected] (Ron Gallant)
[email protected] (Arnold Robbins)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Robert Miles)
[email protected] (DOS: Tastes like chicken when properly prepared.)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Binayak Banerjee)
[email protected] (David A. Berson)
[email protected]
[email protected] (T. William Wells)
[email protected] (Bob Posert)
[email protected] (James R (Bob) White)
[email protected] (Dan Bernstein)
[email protected] (Bill White)
[email protected] (Mike Northam ext 2651)
[email protected] (Craig E. Ward)
[email protected] (Chris Greve)
[email protected] (Christos S. Zoulas)
[email protected] (Mike Coleman)
[email protected] (Cliff Tuel)
[email protected] (Curt J. Sampson)
[email protected] (Daniel Jacobson)
[email protected] (David H. Brierley)
[email protected] (David Robinson)
[email protected]
davide%[email protected] (David Eckelkamp)
[email protected]
dciem!6sceng!blm%cs.washington.edu (Brian Matthews)
dciem!bkj386!brian (Brian Jenkins)
dciem!chrisj%netcom.com (Christopher Jewell)
dciem!corondan%eds.com
dciem!doug%letni.LoneStar.org (Doug Davis)
dciem!gatech!uncecs.edu!thebeach.UUCP!meto (nobody)
dciem!jmm%eci386 (John Macdonald)
dciem!letni!digi.lonestar.org!kgallagh%utacfd.uta.edu (Kevin Gallagher)
dciem!nelson%berlioz.nsc.com (Taed Nelson)
dciem!nick%ryelect (Nick Colonello)
dciem!rancor!bob%cs.utexas.edu (Bob Willcox)
dciem!rducky!jrp%polyslo.calpoly.edu (JIM PICKERING)
dciem!seachg!jalsop (John Alsop)
dciem!smu!letni!ataritx!dwh%cs.utexas.edu (Dave Hanna)
dciem!steve%txsil.lonestar.org (Steve McConnel)
dciem!woods%eci386 (Greg A. Woods)
[email protected] (David C. Miller)
[email protected] (Eric Delaney)
[email protected] (David G Freudenstein)
[email protected] (Dave Glowacki)
[email protected] (Paul Do (News))
[email protected] (M. J. Cole)
[email protected] (Wayne Schlitt)
[email protected] (Alexander Dupuy)
[email protected] (Ed Hew)
[email protected] (Carlo Sgro)
[email protected] (Eric P. Scott)
[email protected] (Tom Fitzgerald)
[email protected] (fritz zaucker)
[email protected] (frank korzeniewski)
[email protected] (Jesse Perry)
[email protected] (Gary Bridgewater)
gatech!uflorida!rm1!bapat (Subodh Bapat)
[email protected] (Gene Kim)
[email protected]@munnari.oz.au
[email protected]
[email protected] (Glenn R. Stone)
[email protected]
[email protected] (George V. Reilly)
[email protected] (John Hassey)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Herman Rubin)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Fernando Manuel Vasconcelos)
[email protected] (Rui Casteleiro)
isgtec!ted (Ted Richards)
[email protected] (Jan B.Andersen)
[email protected] (Jonathan Dasteel)
[email protected] (Jean-Christophe Collet)
[email protected] (John Martin)
[email protected] (Jef Poskanzer)
[email protected] (Randell Jesup)
[email protected] (John F. Woods)
[email protected] (Juan Gabriel Ruiz Pinto)
[email protected] (John G. DeArmond)
[email protected] (Jeffri H Frontz)
[email protected] (Jim Richardson)
[email protected] (John Litvin)
[email protected] (John Nemeth)
[email protected] (John P. Nelson)
[email protected] (karl lehenbauer)
[email protected] (Keenan Ross )
[email protected] (Kirk Webb)
[email protected] (Ken McVay)
[email protected] (Hans-Peter Kolb)
[email protected] (Kevin Braunsdorf)
[email protected] (Eliot)
[email protected] (Ken Lerman)
[email protected] (Mark Levison)
[email protected] (Anselm Lingnau)
[email protected] (Larry Blair)
lsuc!linus!russ%shannon.Alliant.COM (Russell McFatter)
[email protected]
lwv27%[email protected]
[email protected] (Sean Malloy)
[email protected] (Marco Lorenzini)
[email protected] (Alex Martelli)
[email protected] (Thomas Maslen)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Ted Lemon)
[email protected] (Randal L. Schwartz)
[email protected] (Tom Metcalf)
[email protected] (Michael W. Wellman)
[email protected]
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
mitel!indetech.com!david (David Kuder x2003)
mitel!juts.ccc.amdahl.com!ked01 (Kim DeVaughn)
mitel!mport.com!lee (Lee Crocker)
mitel!onion.rain.com!jeff (Jeff Beadles)
mitel!psg.com!news (Randy Bush)
mitel!pyramid.pyramid.com!csg (Carl S. Gutekunst)
mitel!se-sd.SanDiego.NCR.COM!bhoule (Bill Houle)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!kent (Kent Landfield)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!rick (Richard Ohnemus)
mitel!uunet!ars2!briank
mitel!uunet!coplex!dean (Dean Brooks)
mitel!uunet!infmx!crickhollow!cortesi (David Cortesi)
mitel!uunet!vicstoy!jellis (Jacob Ellis)
[email protected] (Mark-Jason Dominus)
[email protected] (John Harkin)
[email protected] (David Muir Sharnoff)
[email protected] (Kee Hinckley)
[email protected] (Neil Murray)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steven C. Work)
[email protected] (Orlan Cannon)
[email protected] (Frank Ooms)
[email protected] (Jaye Mathisen)
paj <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Paul Sutcliffe Jr.)
[email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
[email protected] (Leonard Peirce)
[email protected] (Peter da Silva)
[email protected] (Philip Dart)
[email protected] (Paul Graham)
[email protected] (Marc C. Poulin)
[email protected] (Raymond Chen)
[email protected] (Ralph Finch)
[email protected] (Richard Foulk)
[email protected] (Rod Holland)
[email protected]
rob%[email protected] (Robert Ransbottom)
[email protected] (Rob Kenna)
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Michael Rothstein)
[email protected] (Rich Kulawiec)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Mike Arms)
[email protected] (Steve Simmons)
[email protected] (Dave Shaver)
[email protected] (Rich Skrenta)
[email protected] (Steve Lamont)
[email protected] (Steven C. Liu)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steintor Bjarnason)
[email protected] (Steen Hammerum)
[email protected] (Steve Nuchia)
[email protected] (Syd Weinstein)
[email protected] (Tim Ramsey)
[email protected] (Chip Salzenberg)
[email protected] (Tom Dinger - Sun BOS SPA)
tibor%[email protected] (Tibor Stern jr.)
[email protected] (Tim J Ihde)
[email protected] (Timothy D Aanerud)
[email protected] (Tom Horsley)
[email protected] (Karl Tombre)
[email protected] (Tom Frauenhofer)
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Vasco Pedro)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Warren Tucker)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Winfried Koenig)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Gregory G. Woodbury)
[email protected] (Jim Hebert)
[email protected]
-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
[email protected]
                    "The interface IS the program."

From [email protected] Mon Sep 11 16:14:55 1995
Xref: rpi news.announce.newgroups:1009 news.groups:23864 comp.sources.d:3787
Newsgroups: news.announce.newgroups,news.groups,comp.sources.d
Path: rpi!bounce-back
From: [email protected] (Andrew Patrick)
Subject: RESULT:  comp.sources.reviewed passes 270:54
Followup-To: news.groups
Sender: [email protected]
Nntp-Posting-Host: cs.rpi.edu
Organization: Communications Research Centre, Ottawa
Date: 2 Apr 91 04:34:53 GMT
Approved: [email protected]
Lines: 378
Status: RO
X-Status: 

The results are in for the proposed newsgroup comp.sources.reviewed.
The voting was closed on Sun Mar 31 1991.

A total of 324 valid votes were received (excluding duplicate votes and
one person who voted both "yes" and "no", see below).

"Yes":  270 votes
"No":   54 votes

Criterion 1: 100 more "yes" than "no" votes
	270 - 54 = 216      OK

Criterion 2: at least 2/3 of the total number of votes are "yes"
	270/324 = 83%       OK

Therefore, comp.sources.reviewed passes and will be added as a
newsgroup.  However, it is customary to have a 5-day waiting when the
votes can be verified.

Listed below are the names of the people from whom I recorded votes,
sorted into "yes" and "no" categories.

"Yes" votes:

"CONTR, HERRICK, DAN" <[email protected]>
"Christopher M. Conway" <[email protected]>
"D. J. McCarthy ~" <dmccart%[email protected]>
"Erich Meier (Inf4 - hiwi)" <[email protected]>
"Jonathan I. Kamens" <[email protected]>
"Karsten Nyblad, TFL, Denmark" <[email protected]>
"Mark W. Eichin" <[email protected]>
"Ralph P. Sobek" <[email protected]>
"Roger H. Goun  18-Mar-1991 1242" <[email protected]>
"Stuart L Labovitz" <valinor!stu>
"Terry Kennedy, Operations Mgr" <TERRY%[email protected]>
"Terry Poot" <[email protected]>
"Vander Pol, Mark" <[email protected]>
"david d [zoo] zuhn" <[email protected]>
"william b. coleman" <[email protected]>
@[email protected] ( )
Alan B. Clegg <[email protected]>
Andrei Cogan <[email protected]>
Baruch Cochavy <blue%[email protected]>
Ben Golding <[email protected]>
Bengt Larsson <[email protected]>
Bill Bogstad <[email protected]>
Bill Randle <billr%[email protected]>
Bob Narron <[email protected]>
Bruce Sherrod <[email protected]>
Christopher Bryden <[email protected]>
Christopher Mc Kulka <[email protected]>
Clive Chinery <[email protected]>
Dan Poirier <[email protected]>
Dave Allum <[email protected]>
Dave Sill <[email protected]>
David Herron <[email protected]>
Doug Lee <[email protected]>
Doug Sewell <[email protected]>
Douglas N. Arnold <[email protected]>
Draphsor vo'drun-Aelf <[email protected]>
Eamonn McManus <[email protected]>
Ed McGuire <[email protected]>
Ed Reed <mitel!uunet!leadsv!ereed>
Fergus O'Reilly <magic!fergus%crp.capsogeti.fr>
Geoff Kuenning <mitel!devnet.la.locus.com!geoff>
Gisle Hannemyr <[email protected]>
Guy Middleton <[email protected]>
James Beal <[email protected]>
James da Silva <[email protected]>
Jamie Blustein <[email protected]>
Jan van der Steen <[email protected]>
Jay Maynard <[email protected]>
Jean-Loup Gailly <[email protected]>
Jeff Okamoto <[email protected]>
Jeremy J Bolio <[email protected]>
Jim Bevier - J B Systems <[email protected]>
Jo Are Rosland <[email protected]>
John Coolidge <[email protected]>
John Romine <[email protected]>
Jussi Heinonen <[email protected]>
Larry Gillespie <[email protected]>
Laszlo C. Balint <[email protected]>
Linh Ngo <[email protected]>
Malcolm Mladenovic <[email protected]>
Marc Rouleau <[email protected]>
Mark Eichin <[email protected]>
Mark Nagel <[email protected]>
Mark Reinhold <[email protected]>
Marty Ryba <[email protected]>
Matthias Urlichs <urlichs%[email protected]>
Merri L Naka <[email protected]>
Michel B. Cormier <micor!mcormier>
Palmer Davis <[email protected]>
Patrick e. Fleming <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Frederick G. M. Roeber)
Rein Tollevik <[email protected]>
Rick Ellis <[email protected]>
Roger Fulton <[email protected]>
Rupert G. Goldie <[email protected]>
Sam Horrocks <[email protected]>
Scott Barman <mitel!nbc1.ge.com!scott>
Scott R. Weis KB2EAR <[email protected]>
Sean Philip Engelson <[email protected]>
Soren Larsen <[email protected]>
Stan Barber <[email protected]>
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
Terry B Lyons <[email protected]>
Thomas Andreasson <[email protected]>
Tim Cook <[email protected]>
Tim Day <[email protected]>
Tim Morgan <[email protected]>
Tom Anderson <[email protected]>
Tom Haapanen <[email protected]>
Tom Roehl <[email protected]>
Tony Wilson <[email protected]>
Torben Lange <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Andy Thomas)
[email protected] (Akiko Katayama)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Jean Marie Diaz)
[email protected] (Andrew H. Marrinson)
[email protected] (Bor-Jau Hsieh)
[email protected] (Andy Rose)
[email protected] (Anthony Baxter)
[email protected] (Ron Gallant)
[email protected] (Arnold Robbins)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Robert Miles)
[email protected] (DOS: Tastes like chicken when properly prepared.)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Binayak Banerjee)
[email protected] (David A. Berson)
[email protected]
[email protected] (T. William Wells)
[email protected] (Bob Posert)
[email protected] (James R (Bob) White)
[email protected] (Bill White)
[email protected] (Charles A. Sefranek)
[email protected] (Mike Northam ext 2651)
[email protected] (Craig E. Ward)
[email protected] (Chris Greve)
[email protected] (Christos S. Zoulas)
cognos!cunews!alzabo.ocunix.on.ca!kebera (Krishna E. Bera)
[email protected] (Mike Coleman)
[email protected] (Curt J. Sampson)
[email protected] (Daniel Jacobson)
[email protected] (David H. Brierley)
[email protected]
davide%[email protected] (David Eckelkamp)
dciem!bkj386!brian (Brian Jenkins)
dciem!chrisj%netcom.com (Christopher Jewell)
dciem!corondan%eds.com
dciem!doug%letni.LoneStar.org (Doug Davis)
dciem!gatech!scicom.alphacdc.com!rcw (Robert White)
dciem!gatech!uncecs.edu!thebeach.UUCP!meto (nobody)
dciem!jmm%eci386 (John Macdonald)
dciem!nelson%berlioz.nsc.com (Taed Nelson)
dciem!nick%ryelect (Nick Colonello)
dciem!rancor!bob%cs.utexas.edu (Bob Willcox)
dciem!rducky!jrp%polyslo.calpoly.edu (JIM PICKERING)
dciem!seachg!jalsop (John Alsop)
dciem!smu!letni!ataritx!dwh%cs.utexas.edu (Dave Hanna)
dciem!steve%txsil.lonestar.org (Steve McConnel)
[email protected] (David C. Miller)
[email protected] (Eric Delaney)
[email protected] (David G Freudenstein)
[email protected] (Dave Glowacki)
[email protected] (Paul Do (News))
[email protected] (M. J. Cole)
[email protected] (Wayne Schlitt)
[email protected] (Alexander Dupuy)
[email protected] (Ed Hew)
[email protected] (Carlo Sgro)
[email protected] (Tom Fitzgerald)
[email protected]
[email protected] (fritz zaucker)
[email protected] (frank korzeniewski)
[email protected] (Jesse Perry)
gatech!uflorida!rm1!bapat (Subodh Bapat)
[email protected] (Gene Kim)
[email protected]@munnari.oz.au
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Glenn R. Stone)
[email protected]
[email protected] (George V. Reilly)
[email protected] (John Hassey)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Herman Rubin)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Fernando Manuel Vasconcelos)
[email protected] (Rui Casteleiro)
isgtec!ted (Ted Richards)
[email protected] (Jan B.Andersen)
[email protected] (Jonathan Dasteel)
[email protected] (Jean-Christophe Collet)
[email protected] (John Martin)
[email protected] (Jef Poskanzer)
[email protected] (Randell Jesup)
[email protected] (John F. Woods)
[email protected] (Juan Gabriel Ruiz Pinto)
[email protected] (Jeffri H Frontz)
[email protected] (Jim Richardson)
[email protected] (John Nemeth)
[email protected] (John P. Nelson)
[email protected] (Keenan Ross )
[email protected] (Kirk Webb)
[email protected] (Ken McVay)
[email protected] (Hans-Peter Kolb)
[email protected] (Kevin Braunsdorf)
[email protected] (Ken Lerman)
[email protected] (Mark Levison)
[email protected] (Anselm Lingnau)
[email protected] (Larry Blair)
[email protected]
lwv27%[email protected]
[email protected] (Sean Malloy)
[email protected] (Marco Lorenzini)
[email protected] (Alex Martelli)
[email protected] (Thomas Maslen)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Ted Lemon)
[email protected] (Tom Metcalf)
[email protected]
[email protected]@dgbt.doc.ca
mitel!ddsw1.mcs.com!kestrel (Ryan Pazdur)
mitel!happym.wa.com!irving (Irving_Wolfe on reddog)
mitel!indetech.com!david (David Kuder x2003)
mitel!juts.ccc.amdahl.com!ked01 (Kim DeVaughn)
mitel!mport.com!lee (Lee Crocker)
mitel!onion.rain.com!jeff (Jeff Beadles)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!kent (Kent Landfield)
mitel!sparky.IMD.Sterling.COM!rick (Richard Ohnemus)
mitel!uunet!ars2!briank
mitel!uunet!coplex!dean (Dean Brooks)
mitel!uunet!infmx!crickhollow!cortesi (David Cortesi)
[email protected] (Mark-Jason Dominus)
[email protected] (John Harkin)
[email protected] (David Muir Sharnoff)
[email protected] (Neil Murray)
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steven C. Work)
[email protected] (Frank Ooms)
paj <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
[email protected] (Peter da Silva)
[email protected] (Philip Dart)
[email protected] (Paul Graham)
[email protected] (Ralph Finch)
[email protected] (Richard Foulk)
[email protected] (Rod Holland)
[email protected]
rob%[email protected] (Robert Ransbottom)
[email protected] (Rob Kenna)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Systems Staff)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Michael Rothstein)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Ryan Waldron)
[email protected] (Mike Arms)
[email protected] (Steve Simmons)
[email protected] (Dave Shaver)
[email protected] (Rich Skrenta)
[email protected] (Steve Lamont)
[email protected] (Steven C. Liu)
[email protected]
[email protected]
[email protected] (Steintor Bjarnason)
[email protected] (Steen Hammerum)
[email protected] (Steve Nuchia)
[email protected] (Joshua Osborne)
[email protected] (Syd Weinstein)
[email protected] (Tim Ramsey)
[email protected] (Christian Taube)
[email protected] (Chip Salzenberg)
[email protected] (Tom Dinger - Sun BOS SPA)
tibor%[email protected] (Tibor Stern jr.)
[email protected] (Tim J Ihde)
[email protected] (Timothy D Aanerud)
[email protected] (Tom Horsley)
[email protected] (Karl Tombre)
[email protected] (Tom Frauenhofer)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Vasco Pedro)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Warren Tucker)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Winfried Koenig)
[email protected]
[email protected] (Gregory G. Woodbury)
[email protected] (Jim Hebert)
[email protected]


"No" votes:

"Douglas F. DeJulio" <[email protected]>
"Neil Rickert, N Illinois U, CS" <[email protected]>
"The Wandering Wizard" <uunet!vampire!network_mgr>
[email protected] (Brian Matthews)
Brett K. Carver <[email protected]>
Dan Schlitt <[email protected]>
Eric Olson <[email protected]>
Jean-Francois Rit <[email protected]>
Joel B Levin <[email protected]>
John Curran <[email protected]>
John Lacey <[email protected]>
Magnus Olsson <[email protected]>
Matthew Farwell <[email protected]>
Ozan Yigit <[email protected]>
Ralph Clark <[email protected]>
Richard H. Miller <[email protected]>
Shannon D. Appel <[email protected]>
Steve Hayman <[email protected]>
Timothy VanFosson <[email protected]>
Tom Christiansen <[email protected]>
Tom Epperly <[email protected]>
[email protected] (Arthur David Olson)
[email protected] (Dan Bernstein)
[email protected] (Cliff Tuel)
[email protected] (David Robinson)
[email protected]
dciem!6sceng!blm%cs.washington.edu (Brian Matthews)
dciem!letni!digi.lonestar.org!kgallagh%utacfd.uta.edu (Kevin Gallagher)
dciem!woods%eci386 (Greg A. Woods)
[email protected] (Eric P. Scott)
[email protected] (Gary Bridgewater)
[email protected] (James Sullins)
[email protected] (John G. DeArmond)
[email protected] (John Litvin)
[email protected] (karl lehenbauer)
[email protected] (Eliot)
lsuc!linus!russ%shannon.Alliant.COM (Russell McFatter)
[email protected] (Randal L. Schwartz)
[email protected] (Michael W. Wellman)
mitel!psg.com!news (Randy Bush)
mitel!pyramid.pyramid.com!csg (Carl S. Gutekunst)
mitel!se-sd.SanDiego.NCR.COM!bhoule (Bill Houle)
mitel!uunet!vicstoy!jellis (Jacob Ellis)
[email protected] (Kee Hinckley)
[email protected] (Orlan Cannon)
[email protected] (Jaye Mathisen)
[email protected] (Paul Sutcliffe Jr.)
[email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
[email protected] (Leonard Peirce)
[email protected] (Marc C. Poulin)
[email protected] (Raymond Chen)
[email protected] (Rich Kulawiec)
[email protected] (Dave V. Schaller)
[email protected]


One person voted both "yes" and "no":

	Date: 28 Feb 91 10:14:02 EST (Thu)
	From: [email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
	
	"I vote YES for comp.sources.reviewed."
	
	---
	* Paul Anderson * Dixie Communications * (404) 578-9547 * [email protected] *
	
	Date: 4 Mar 91 10:42:52 EST (Mon)
	From: [email protected] (Paul D. Anderson)
	Status: OR
	
	"I vote NO for comp.sources.reviewed."
	
	---
	* Paul Anderson * Dixie Communications * (404) 578-9547 * [email protected] *

These two votes were ignored.
-- 
Andrew Patrick, Ph.D.       Department of Communications, Ottawa, CANADA
[email protected]
                    "The interface IS the program."

 
USENET FACT: Flaming
Flaming is the hostile interaction between multiple Usenet users.